341 Comments

Do a similar critique of media - e.g. NPR let Netanyahu rant, lie and call Palestinians animals unrebutted for several minutes yesterday morning. It was disgusting.

Expand full comment

It amazes me that those around me don't consider NPR to be MSM...

Expand full comment

True, AJ. Some years ago both NPR and PBS signed onto a document to refrain from criticizing IsraHell.

They’re nothing but MSM.

Expand full comment
Nov 18, 2023·edited Nov 18, 2023

Some decades ago NPR got a corporatized CEO. Shortly afterwards, a gentleman progressively oriented news man was suddenly fired from his early morning program. Then, later on NPR iniatiated their “non-commercial” commercials regularly chewing up time. Concomitantly, News hosts interviewing “experts and notables” somehow forgot to mention those beacons of truth and wisdom were from the Federalist Society and various right-wing think tanks. And when listening carefully to reportage you came increasingly aware of greater and more frequent sins of omission. So the picture given you was snagged in certain directions like a fun house mirror where you body contorts and stretches in weird exaggerated movements. I was angry about the deceits for a long time and wrote letters. Then, with sadness I simply accepted the consequence of corporatization is purposeful distortion in service of mammon in lieu of service to civic integrity. Always —Inc. in the manner it operates today —-cheapens, fowls, and degrades “right relationship” with anything animate and inanimate. Like someone wise said. You cannot serve both Mammon and God.(mystery, life source, creativity, the great Thou…).

Expand full comment

The people you hear on NPR are members of SAG/AFTRA and they just read the scripts they are given as convincingly as they can, as they portray professional journalists they will never be.

Expand full comment

Maybe that's because the head of NPR is Netanyahu's first wife

Expand full comment

Miriam Weizmann died in 1974.

Expand full comment

Just like Hitler committed suicide.

Expand full comment

Just like one of his many doubles was made to look like a suicide so no one would track him to Argentina.

Expand full comment

They are the only communistic parts of America's mainstream media.

They are also its most copious liars, largely by omission.

Expand full comment

They are hardly communistic! Communists have a sense of honor, NPR a has none. They are 110% capitalist approved and supported.

Expand full comment

You clearly have never read The Communist Manifesto unless you failed to understand.

110% is impossible.

Expand full comment

You clearly are blinded by some weird abject and irrational fear of the word "communist". I can't think of any country on earth right now that actually fits the definition of communist.

Expand full comment

I used to really like NPR but finally recognized that they are just a propaganda tool like cable news but the best at hiding it with their soft tones and over acted stance on social change. I literally can’t tolerate listening to them for more than 10 min. I start to yell at my radio at the stupidity and obvious attempt to push a narrative

Expand full comment

I have a friend who wrote her dissertation at home with NPR on in the background. Decades ago. I remember when I too perceived it as a comfort and a bulwark against for-profit news corporations. I was slapped into reality several years ago and now I look back and scratch my head. How could I have been so dumb?!

Expand full comment

They played classical music. That's probably what did it. Pernicious stuff, classical music.

Expand full comment
Nov 19, 2023·edited Nov 19, 2023

No, it was talk radio. Talk, talk, talk.

But you could set your watch by it if you know the line-up of the daily shows! And each show has signature music. And each show has hosts who have been taught to speak “public radio” and they have the correct vocabularies and intonations. It all sounds very different to these elements used on corporate tv—music, vocabulary, intonation, etc. if you’ve ever been stuck in an American airport departure lounge for several hours, it’s almost impossible to avoid!

Expand full comment

I'm not really familiar with that side of NPR. I do remember being shocked when an NPR station reporting on the war against Serbia went totally us-against-them jingoistic, as if they were broadcasting from an American Legion post in Indiana. A very small war by modern standards, but I think that was when I realized I couldn't listen to them any more. Before that I had been listening to WNYC, a pre-NPR public radio station.

Expand full comment

Propaganda by Edward Bernays is a book about advertising...

Expand full comment

NPR and PBS are covertly owned and operated by the CPB, which was created as a public non-profit corporation to do the same things in propaganda that the similar Federal Reserve Board was created to do to the nation's currency.

Expand full comment

Yes that was their creation, under Johnson I think, but under Bush they became a training ground for the pentagon in narrative control.

Expand full comment

Presidents have no control over the CPB because it is non-governmental.

Expand full comment

I thought the CIA dictated unallowed content to all media.

Expand full comment

What would be unallowed?

Expand full comment

Well, the tongue in cheek name for NPR (i.e. Natiomal 🦍 Pentagon Radio) has a LOT of truth to it, so technically speaking, it is more a part of the 😈 MIC than of the 🐍 MSM.

The Old IDF "Hamas Command and Control Center" TRICK IS NOT WORKIN'

https://soberthinking.createaforum.com/geopolitics/war-provocations-and-peace-actions/msg1463/#msg1463

Expand full comment

NPR is repulsive - nothing "public" about them, and that's been true since the 70s. Now that con is fully out there for all to see. Look at who their corporate funders are! I think they're worse than mainstream commercial media because their entire posturing is such a lie. And there's so many things they refuse to address, or that they will bring up only one side of.

They've got a very definite agenda, and it's NOT public information.

Expand full comment

In 2022, NPR received only 12% ($16,268,014) of its revenue from individual donations, and 39% ($135,292,987) of its revenue from corporate sponsors. Obviously, it is corporate radio, not public radio.

Expand full comment

Anyone who listens to NPR frequently (as I do) will notice that they sell and carry advertising which is different in one important way from that carried by commercial broadcasters.

Expand full comment

What’s that Rickie Nelson song, “O, o poor little fool, I was fool o ya.”

Expand full comment

Did you forget to take your meds this morning?

Expand full comment

Nope. Took em’ all. They’re mushrooms so I rarely forget. Great healers mushrooms.

Expand full comment

Also, I would bet the individual donors are not average joes

Expand full comment

Define "average joes," since that could be confused with the one in the White House by the really confused and/or ignorant.

Expand full comment

You would know more about it if you listened to a pledge drive by a NPR affiliate.

Expand full comment

I have in the past and it’s impossible to listen to for more than a few minutes before my brain begins to swell up. Id prefer donor data to see

Expand full comment

All of the affiliate stations retain such data in compliance with FCC regulations.

Ask to see their public file.

Listening to NPR, assuming one has a working BS filter, fine tunes it.

Expand full comment

"They've got a very definite agenda, and it's NOT public information."

Amen. I it were "public", it would be *continually seeking* to understand its audience and any changes that occur in it, then transmitting crystalized and coherent summaries of those findings back to that audience as well as to elites.

In journalism, discovery comes before assertion.

Expand full comment

Public in its majority approves the US policies if elections and polls are to be taken seriously. Since NPR does too, then it follows that it reflects the public's sentiment. It is public in the same sense that Fox, CNN, MSNBC, etc are.

Expand full comment

I guess you have never worked as a volunteer in any NPR affiliate.

Expand full comment

I guess you believed the bullshit they fed you when you were naive enough to volunteer for an NPR affiliate.

Expand full comment

Only the very stupid have ever done that, honey. People on here aren’t stupid. Some are a bit crazy maybe, but not stupid. 😝

Expand full comment

I prevented more of it from getting on the air than you have ever has the courage to vet.

Expand full comment

People still listen to NPR? I quit after the "All things Considered," news wench gushed about how "sexy" Rumsfeld looked on the eve of "shock and awe" over 20 years ago.

Expand full comment

For some reason, no other major radio broadcaster has ever produced a twice daily comprehensive current events program.

Expand full comment

A perfect platform for indoctrination. Sadly today's yoof probably have too short an attention span for 2 hours of propaganda is why.

Expand full comment

Plus, they’re all at the tail end of the Yuppie era—around 50– and think NPR is “liberal” because it mentions Buttigieg once in awhile.

Expand full comment

Yes this, I am 57 old Gen X, but I never believed the bullshit.

Expand full comment

Exactly. And thank you. There were some in the yuppie era who never bought the corporate bs. They’ve had a hard time—but now is their reward and we can start to see clearly now.

Expand full comment

All television programming is a perfect platform for indoctrination.

Social media picks up where the media leaves off.

Expand full comment

This is unbelievably ABOMINABLE. Extreme Right Wingers & Evangelicals probably applaud these Nazis. Yes, I said NAZIS.

Expand full comment

Yeah, look at tens of thousands of them in DC: "No ceasefire, no ceasefire". All right-wingers and evangelicals no doubt. To a person.

https://rumble.com/v3w3r81-massive-pro-israeli-rally-held-in-dc.html

Expand full comment

The Church That Pushed TFG # 45 raised my ire in the process. Ignorance, lack of critical thinking, & fear of progress made me leave with FEW REGRETS, & the GOP is too busy shooting itself in the nether regions.

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Expand full comment

Ernesto Che - Are you a mind reader ? I posted something quite similar to this, including the idea that Zionists read MEIN KAMPF a few minutes ago !

Christians & political conservatives are all - too - willing to give them a pass, a golden ticket because they're " God's Country ", " The Promised Land ", blah, blah, blah. As if that relieves them from any responsibility. I don't buy it anymore. & I trust them as much as the GOP & Joel Osteen.

Expand full comment

Welcome Daniel. You are one of the “wins” for freedom that the Gazan people are getting for their sacrifice. As horrible as this all is, it’s making a massive difference in perception in the world. Now I pray perception change will lead to action and change.

Expand full comment

Roughly 2 decades ago, I might've been completely different. I HOPE that I've changed for the better, really.

I hope that SOMETHING positive arises from this mess, like, ah, new, more humane leadership rather than Zionism backed by rabid conservatives & God - bothering Evangelicals.

Expand full comment

From your lips to the gods’ ears.

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Expand full comment

2 people among myriads who are SICK of all the crap about Israel & " the evil, terrible Palestinians ". I've started muting these late night infomercials ( ? ) put on the airwaves by The Fellowship of Christians & Jews because of undisguised bias. If ONLY they wouldn't demonize Palestinians.....

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Expand full comment

NPR has been 100% government fascist propaganda since 9/11. At least. They are vile.

Expand full comment

Yes that, see my comment above.

Expand full comment

NPR—New Pentagon Radio

Expand full comment

1 Netanyahu is not a spokesperson for the Israeli people. BE very careful what you say.

2.It's becoming obvious to me that 'stupid' people are making all kinds of comments which are not accurate. STOP this now.

3. The Israeli people were protesting against Netanyahu for at least a month before this war started. Netanyahu is not Israel he is a right wing fanatic trying to stay out of Prison.

4. Do you know anything about Orthodox Jews? If not look it up.

5. The ignorance of American people is very telling in these comments.

Read and understand what is happening in Israel and I think you may find that the US Government is using them.

Did you know for instance that the oil found off the Gaza coast is now in the hands of Israel?America?

WHY does the US support Israel? Look it up. We are talking about who controls Oil?

Expand full comment

Jenny - I m not "stupid" and the sources I read and rely on are Norm Finkelstein, Llan Pappe, Chris Hedges, Rashid Khalidi, Edward Said, Alistair Crooke, Max Blumenthal, The Duran, and Scott Ritter.

Sadly, see my prior comment about Netanyahu. The Israeli State was oppressing and conducting genocide, war crimes and ethnic cleansing on the Palestinians long before Netanyahu came to power. The current right wing government just took the mask off the historical project. The US interests in middle east oil are far broader than the Palestinian catastrophe and even Israel, so please don'y try to use that as cover.

Expand full comment

Yes, the Israeli State has been committing war crimes for decades, but right now it is Netanyahu and I don't think that a maniac like that should be considered to be speaking for the people of Israel or anyone other than whatever other murderous cronies he has on his side.

Expand full comment

and Aaro Mate and his father Gabor!

Expand full comment

and George Galloway!

Expand full comment

and Patrick Lawrence and Bob Scheer (and the art of Mr. Fish!)

Expand full comment

oops, I almost forgot Jeffrey St. Clair at CounterPunch

Expand full comment

Jeeez, how did I leave out Jeff Sachs?

Expand full comment

"The Israeli people were protesting against Netanyahu" - this isn't a pass, the question is protesting about what exactly?

Expand full comment

His right wing Govnt and wanting to change the Judiciary system.

Of course it's not a pass!

Expand full comment
Nov 18, 2023·edited Nov 18, 2023

"4. Do you know anything about Orthodox Jews? If not look it up."

Hi Jennifer, I understand there are Orthodox Jews who are against the very concept of the state of Israel. Is that not true? If it is true, which factions exist, what are there populations, and where are they (if concentrated)? Thanks

Expand full comment

The number of times she asked that question suggests she's actually asking it. Someone please answer.

Expand full comment

GOOD.

Hopefully dim Americans will realise who is in charge of Israel. It is not the general Israeli people who have been protesting AGAINST Netanyahu for months before this began. What did Net. do.

Allow Hamas to come into Israel, taking people's minds away from his deplorable ethics.

He is wanted on several charges of fraud and bribery. He wanted to change the Judicial system in Israel.

READ and learn before submitting stupid comments.

I thought you had free speech in the US but you want to shut down this rant.

Netanyahu is owned by the USA!

Expand full comment

Sorry Jenny, you are an Israeli apologist. This is not a problem of an individual (i.e. Netanyahu) or even the Orthodox Jews. It is the Zionist State of Israel, which is an apartheid colonial settler nation implementing "Nakba 2.0". The polls I've seen of the Israeli people show strong support for the Gaza genocide, and the social media garbage many Israeli people are posting is obscene.

Expand full comment

No I am not. Please stop trying to put me in a 'BOX.'

IF you read Polls then I have NO answer for you.

Expand full comment

And since you have ALL the answers what do you read, Jenny? Being in France, of course?

Expand full comment

You put yourself in a ox (and called many her "stupid").

I cited polls to rebut you fact free and false claim. See, I'm old fashioned: I like to support claims with evidence.

Expand full comment

You are right I am an OX. How did you know?

Expand full comment

Lame attempts at humor to exploit obvious typos are not an olive branch and will get you nowhere.

I called you on your indefensible BS - so withdraw it or own it.

Expand full comment

Steve Inskeep isn't paid to rebut, just read the script and we'll fix it in the edit.

Expand full comment

It confirmed that Netanyahu is the unmitigated piece of dung he has always been.

Netanyahu is Israel's Hitler, and the Palestinians are his straw men.

Expand full comment

Media is State.

Expand full comment
Nov 18, 2023·edited Nov 18, 2023

But never so blatantly, never so openly or harshly ... this is pure evil and I would suggest part (somehow) of the globalist agenda.

Distraction from the Ukraine CF, depopulation, land, wealth and asset (especially gas) grab, shoving a couple of million real refugees into the EU and UK, Greater Israel project, WWIII (Muslim vs Zionist) and on and on...

Meanwhile, whilst we are all watching, anyone notice that the Pakistanis are kicking out all illegal refugees from the Afghan war (Afganis) and guess where they are coming over to ?.

Expand full comment

....and who gets all the refugees.

We now have American refugees clamouring to come to Europe!

Expand full comment

My favorite incident(s) from our "war on terror" was when we delibrately targetted hospitals with Doctors Without Borders- multiple times. Even used a C-130 gunship.

Expand full comment

War OF terror.

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Expand full comment

This came to mind, my friend. James Tiberius Kirk & Spock Cha'Sarek on the Klingons from Star Trek : The Undiscovered Country -

Spock : Jim, they are dying.

Kirk : Let them DIE.

Chilling how critical thinking gets jammed into a trunk on such occasions.

Expand full comment

Longer than the US Army did it to native Americans?

Expand full comment

What-aboutism doesn’t change the fact that Israel is also doing it.

Expand full comment

Would you like to rephrase that into cogent form?

Expand full comment

You're grotesque.

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Expand full comment

Steve Shives has a podcast, several, in fact. He deals with subjects like this. Youtube. Look him up. Tell him Dr. Dan sent ya.

Expand full comment

The BIA took over the job from the US Army.

Expand full comment

You're a fucking troll. Go cheer on the Ukrainian Nazis on some other thread. Let Joe Biden grope your daughter. You'll feel more at home

Expand full comment

You are just the newest jackass I am ignoring, henceforth.

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Expand full comment

Don't be lazy Ernesto. What is the BIA?

Expand full comment

The CIA has always needed as many proxies as it could recruit.

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Expand full comment

Bureau of Indian Affairs

Expand full comment

This is true Ernesto BUT it does NO mean all Israelis think Net. is good.

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Expand full comment

How do you KNOW?

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Expand full comment

Where?

Expand full comment

And - neither Israel nor the US gives an aerial intercourse about what the rest of us think regarding those fifteen things. In fact, I get the feeling they are points of pride, with a soupçon of irritation over bad press and possible election fallout.

Expand full comment

By this point they have full control of elections. It won't matter if particular names fall. The replacements will continue doing what needs to be done.

Expand full comment

Exactly right.

Expand full comment

Found a new context for the slogan “Never Again”. It’s for the unrelenting mind-blowing atrocities of the despicable Zion state against the helpless Palestinians. Hope this energizes the non-Western useless speechifying to action!! “ Never Again”. Let’s remind Israel of how that feels!

Expand full comment

While I'm aware that this comment opens me up to all sorts of rebound hatred, it naturally flows from psychological logic, reinforced by certain videos of mass support for IDF actions by groups of Israeli citizens (and their US Zionist counterparts) I begin to think that the collective scars of the European holocaust were/are so deep and pervasive in the Zionist psyche of Israeli society that the ultimate outcome is a society trapped in a mass psychosis of self-justifiable torture and murder. and when I hear that "Israel has a right to defend itself", I quickly morph that thought to: If that mass psychosis is real, Israel doesn't even have a right to exist as an equal partner among nations. And then, to be fair, I must apply that same metric to my own country, the good ol' US of A. But that latter thought has been with me for decades now.

Expand full comment

I'd say that the way to make any group of humans into roaring assholes is to give them unlimited rights and no responsibilities.

Expand full comment

As I just posted, they think that they have a GOLDEN TICKET from God ( which one ? )

Expand full comment

I suspect they generally don’t believe that but use it as an excuse. Many use religion to justify atrocities to weaker minds

Expand full comment

Conquistadors, missionaries, slave owners, people who passed out diseased blankets on Native American reservations..... AND it's mainly monotheistic religions.

Expand full comment
Nov 18, 2023·edited Nov 18, 2023

"it's mainly monotheistic religions."

It's clear to me that the Abrahamic tradition of Eye-of-Sauron monster gods is the Mother of all Psy-Ops. Absolutely nothing compares to its psychic power, even after the rather withering onslaught of the half-millenium Enlightenment.

Expand full comment

They have quite a vice grip on most Western cultures. I ENVY Europe because Thoth bless them ( ! ) they're pursuing a secular mindset / way of life. They are shaking the shackles of archaic belief systems. That isn't a SMALL ACHIEVEMENT. The 1st sentient AI will question most human belief systems, as will any possible ETs whose attention is attracted to us, for some reason.

Expand full comment

I should've also mentioned the deep psychosis entailed in the Hannibal directive by which Israel kills its own to sustain some twisted pieces of veneer to its policies. Well covered by Max Blumenthal in a Hedges interview

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d0gECjlpXF8

and in a Grayzone piece.

https://thegrayzone.com/2023/10/27/israels-military-shelled-burning-tanks-helicopters/

Expand full comment

Not only Jews were holocausted in Nazi Germany, but many Germans too: communists, socialists, alcoholics, the disabled, gypsies, vagabonds, gay, Jehova's Witnesses, other Christians, feminists, intellectuals, artists, musicians...the collective scars of the holocaust are so deep in Germany's and Europe's psyche, that even the word "nation" should be forbidden.

Expand full comment

What do those crimes against outcasts have to do with nationhood, and needing to forbid it? This is a very strange POV to me. I think that at the beginning of the French Revolution they had it right: Liberty (Rightism), Equality (Leftism), and Fraternity (at root, shared identity as a people).

None of these, or any other, components of a nation, properly constituted -- yes, including "communists, socialists, alcoholics, the disabled, gypsies, vagabonds, gay, Jehova's Witnesses, other Christians, feminists", etc. etc. -- need be exiled. To foment do so is a perversion of idea of "Fraternite".

But then, it was Marx that began setting internal components of nation at (supposed necessary) war -- no longer negotiation -- with each other, and the rest has been a very sorry history.

Expand full comment

Cher citoyen! If there is a nation, it would be defined by identity. The 'outcasts' were not outcast at all, but they provided identity: the markets, the music, books, art, language, religion. After the holocaust, culture was kitsch. False identity for everyone.

National borders however, are traditionally made by militarists. A real national identity has fractal borders like an island: the more you zoom in, the longer is its coastline. The coastline paradox. Israel has a fractal Palestine inside of it, besides kibbuzim, and are these not communist?

I don't understand what you say about Marx.

Expand full comment
Nov 19, 2023·edited Nov 19, 2023

"I don't understand what you say about Marx."

"Workers of the world, unite!" was a *war* cry. And with it, Marx hijacked Leftism. Leftism is about democracy (the "egalite" AND "fraternite" parts of the French motto) at its most fundamental. Democracy requires eternal, open-minded fluidity in politics, not rigid dogma.

Marx likes to speak of alienation. However, for him alienation (in the relatively new industrialization) not only occurs (explicitly) in the divorce of product from use. It also occurs (implicitly) in the fact that the parties -- worker and owner -- to the crime of property alienation were *themselves* alienated from each other. The destruction of national fraternity led to a "crystalized" alienation of citizen from citizen.

The latter didn't have to occur. But, IMO, Marxists *wanted* it to occur, to create an army of the powerless under their thumbs. This was implemented eventually under Lenin and his vanguards, and we all know how that cry of "power to the people" worked out, not only in Russia, but as well in nearly *all* similar efforts of the twentieth century. That's what happens when you foment a war and create a power vacuum without explaining what you're doing. "Oh, wow, *we* the vanguard will fill that vacuum! Don't worry your pretty little heads over it, soldiers-slash-worker bees!"

Now, since roughly the 50s, when the population of unherdable class-cats (that is, who migrate between classes) started going out of fashion, this so-called "Left" have the bright idea of separating people not by mutable characteristics (class), but by *immutable* ones (all the embedded identities of humans), whipped up and organized by the vanguard inheritors of Marxism. Does this sound like a way to "bring people together"?

Expand full comment

Any diatribe about Marx that does not even mention capitalism or economic class is either incredibly ignorant or based on anti-Marxist propaganda, and not even well done propaganda at that.

Expand full comment
Nov 19, 2023·edited Nov 19, 2023

"alienation ... in the divorce of product from use" [I should have said "production" here]

"worker and owner"

"unherdable class-cats (that is, who migrate between classes)"

i.e. Did I not identify that there are problems with class? There's not a lot one can cover in a handful of paragraphs -- especially when pointing out a different problem.

So, what are some great new insights about class today, that will be just the trick to turn the world around to an actually *viable* solution? Hint: We Leftists are barking up the wrong tree. We need to figure out better how societies actually work. If Marx himself actually understood, then we have to ask about his motives.

Just because Marx identified class (and eloquently) didn't mean he knew what to do about it. We in the 21st century have the great advantage of seeing what happened when his followers attempted to implement a revolt, and *dozens* of times. In my opinion, this is in large part based on a rigid *war* attitude, of implacable us-vs.-them, my team right or wrong, and of fight-to-the-death. It is this same war mindset that infects modern societies to this day. Made sense, maybe, in existential confrontations between hunter-gatherer bands tens and hundreds of thousands of years ago. But the only war needed *today* is to quarantine sociopaths/psychopaths -- they're the true enemies of society, and they're found everywhere. We need to put our thinking caps on.

So, it's past high time to step out of this box. I'd like to recognize that Leftism (social fairness), Rightism (individualist freedom), and Nationhood (societal belonging) are all pieces of the same puzzle of how to run a society.

Expand full comment
Nov 18, 2023·edited Nov 18, 2023

"shared identity as a people"

I mean that as in geographic -- and in consequence, language, culture, etc. -- realms, where it has been natural and near-universal for a very long time. That is, since the dawn of agriculture. But where that goes awry, then, it seems, there can be problems.

Expand full comment

TRIBALISM is a mindset in which NO ONE is a complete winner, one group loses territory, the other loses ethics / morals & soul, it crumbles away.

Expand full comment

Oh yeah, defend yourself in the back pocket of the sugar daddy USA!!! Sniveling cowardice!!!

Expand full comment

This is soooo good Vin, thank you.

Expand full comment

As a moral argument, I think you have a point. As a practical argument, it’s not practical to go back in time. Some things can’t be undone and now you have a moral and practical conundrum. Both have a right to exist now regardless of history and both have innocent people to consider in a resolution

Expand full comment
Nov 18, 2023·edited Nov 18, 2023

No. They most certainly do NOT have a right to exist and they never did. This is like arguing that Nazi Germany should have a right to exist since they existed in the 1930s. Da fuk is wrong with you. Israel hasn't existed since 322 BC when Alexander the Great eliminated them. Fuck that idea. It's psychotic and delusional.

Expand full comment

A fallacy on par with THIS GEM : " America has always been a Christian nation ". How were we Christian before the arrival of Europeans, pray tell ?

Expand full comment

‘Da fuck’ do you propose that doesn’t involve a Jewish genocide?

Expand full comment

"Da Fuk" can't you see that Israel is committing a genocide right fucking now. That's not "defense". You're like arguing that Hitler, or any other mass-murdering dictatorial monster just "had to do what he had to do" or else they'd be defeated. Are you abjectly stupid, or just evil? Humans have been forced to get along RATHER THAN SLAUGHTER EACH OTHER for fucking ever. And if the Israelis get slaughtered, guess whose fault that will be -- THEIR OWN. The Palestinians let them migrate there is the 40's, sympathetic to their suffering in the Holocaust, then the fucking "Israelis" turned the tables on them, as if they had learned from Hitler's techniques rather than decided to condemn them forever as the rest of the world had. The Israelis are the new Reich. They are literally fascists and Nazis; hell, Albert Einstein even called them out on that. So you can take your Nazi-apologia and GTFO of here.

They should have listed to Einstein and his other Jewish friends who wrote the following typo the NYT decades ago:

https://archive.org/details/AlbertEinsteinLetterToTheNewYorkTimes.December41948

Expand full comment

I don't think Palestinians had any say in the matter.

Expand full comment

You didn’t answer my question

Expand full comment
Nov 18, 2023·edited Nov 18, 2023

Answer your own question you lying piece of shit. "Israel" started this and they can end it. "Israel" can either work for peace or they can get DESTROYED. Or are you so stupid and/or indoctrinated that you can't see this. You're arguing that Hitler had to keep going or else he'd get wiped out. Well guess what, wiping out Hitler was the only way to end it. Sadly, Nazis were imported into the US after the war, and that shit lives on, both in the US and "Israel". It's time to truly wipe out Nazism.

Expand full comment

I will—how about making them live in one state where all rights and duties are shared by all citizens with a real constitution (Israel doesn’t have one) and is a protectorate of the UN outside the security council. Wipe “Israel” off the map just as we should pull down all the confederate statues put up in the 1920’s and claimed as “heritage” by the murderous South.

Expand full comment

Who is conferring this “right” anyway? Some god, some pope, some military, some self-righteous mofo?

Expand full comment

Evangelicals are cheerleading it, if not spearheading it themselves.

Expand full comment

My question is: When do these horrific acts become War Crimes and who will do anything about it?

Expand full comment

Well, the answer to the first part of your question is "When they are done by Putin".

Expand full comment

Putin doesn't even have to do anything to commit war crimes.

Because Muh Rules-Based International Order.

Expand full comment

Putin does exactly what the Duma tells him to do.

Expand full comment

Troll

Expand full comment

Only, Putin never did no sick shit like these Israelis is doin’, been doin’.

I don’t think he’s no rabid sicko, like them Talmud talkers.

Expand full comment

Right on Mike.

Expand full comment

exactly so. Bucha, Snake Island russians raping babies---all bullshit.

Expand full comment

Hahahahahahaha. Excellent. And completely right. In the US its not what is done it’s who is doing it that counts. So, if T-tump were doing what Bigone is doing, they would be war crimes.

Expand full comment

They became war crimes with the signing of the Geneva Convention on August 12, 1949.

But as someone pointed out, in order for this operation to be a war, Hamas would need to have an actual military. They are not at war against another's army, they are leveling a neighborhood where 2.2 million people live.

Expand full comment

Trudeau has just been charged with supporting genocide by the ICC.

The Corpse-in-chief is next.

Expand full comment

Good name. I doubt it US never gets charged with anything!

Expand full comment

The CCR is suing him in the 9th District for violating Geneva to which we are a signatory. It’s a start.

Expand full comment

Not in our lifetimes.

Expand full comment

Only when world power is multipolar (I.e decentralized) and finally recognizing that it’s better to collaborate as a species, share resources, and still compete with each other fairly and humanely. The first will force treaties that have teeth

Expand full comment

Not going to happen sad to say. Rich people would never agree.

Expand full comment

It’s already happening and you’re right, rich people are trying to stop that by using poor countries and poor people for destabilizing wars. They don’t want stable competition

Expand full comment

Makes one wonder just who are the “human animals”. Oh let’s change that to “monsters”; ANIMALS are much better humans than the current IsraHelli crop of insane murderers.

In the meanwhile, THANK YOU 🇧🇿 BELIZE for severing all ties with the apartheid quasi-nation!

Expand full comment

Thank you. Yes, I hate it when people, who are the most destructive and vicious sentient beings on the planet, project their own hatefulness and evil onto animals. Gimme a break! If people "acted like animals" in reality, none of this would be happening.

Expand full comment

Animals ( or four-legged sentient beings, as I prefer to call them) do not commit crimes, wage war, or find pleasure in killing.

I saw a recent video that broke my heart. Two kittens in Gaza were huddled against a wall, clutching each other as bombs rattled the background. These kittens deserve to live far more than any IsraHelli “soldier”!

Expand full comment

Unfortunately, chimpanzees, who are 99.9% like us, do wage war, literally tearing the babies of the “enemy” limb from limb. We have a long way to go to outgrow our wickedness but it isn’t savagery, it’s humanoid.

Expand full comment

Bonobos are also genetically similar primates (to us and chimps) who live peacefully and cooperate with others. Humans are capable of choosing peaceful, cooperative behavior.

Expand full comment

Yes, exactly and thank you for reminding me. I love Bonobos. I read that their go to for soothing another is sex, that they have sex all the time!!! So 2 things—1) The church and it’s hatred of sex is responsible for all the West’s wars and B) the Hippies were right—make love, not war. Hope that comes back!!! 😁😆😇

Expand full comment

Couldn't agree more! :)

Expand full comment

Still doesn't compare to the depravity of many humans. Not by a long shot.

Expand full comment

Also, Colombia, Hundurus, Jordan, TURKEY, South Africa, Bolivia, Chile, Chad, Bahrain. That means these countries are also defying US!!! It’s a great start.

Expand full comment

Ireland. and Turkey too.

Expand full comment

In a way it makes me glad that our Resident is such a slack mouthed, empty eyed fool—it makes the world feel more free to dump their loyalty to the US when they see his duffle butt shuffling along concentrating on not stumbling. That and Pluto in Aquarius!

Expand full comment

Israel is monstrously evil.

Expand full comment

I think this is not true. Israelis were protesting in the streets before all this happened, against Netanyahu.

Expand full comment

Were they protesting the apartheid status of the country? Treatment of Palestine?

Expand full comment

I believe they protesting against Netanyahu and his right wing Govt. Plus they know he wants to dismantle the Justice system. He is basically trying to keep out of prison for many nefarious dealings.

I also don't think the average Israeli likes the fact that a lot of his Govt. are Orthodox Jews.

Expand full comment

Right. So most of those protesting, if not all, are not against the current onslaught. That's what I was getting at. That they are "monstrously evil" as the OP put it.

Expand full comment

I heard an interview with a friend of a Canadian/Jewish human rights worker who died on October 7. She was devastated that her friend had died and also disgusted with Netanyahu's response as she felt her friend would have been as well.

Expand full comment

The Israeli’s probably killed her. They killed most of those who died on Oct 6th. Still, I’m sad for her death. Human rights workers are angels.

Expand full comment

From Ponsonby's "Falsehood in Wartime":

"There are lies emanating from the inherent unreliability and fallibility of human testimony. No two people can relate the occurrence of a street accident so as to make the two stories tally. When bias and emotion are introduced, human testimony becomes quite valueless. In war-time such testimony is accepted as conclusive. The scrappiest and most unreliable evidence is sufficient - "the friend of the brother of a man who was killed", or, as a German investigator of his own liars puts it, "somebody who had seen it", or, "an extremely respectable old woman".

Expand full comment

I think they are against the onslaught. Most people want to live without fear this includes probably a huge bunch of Israelis.

Expand full comment

Can you HEAR me. They were against Net. who started this catastrophe. He has been in power now for what 17yrs?

He did nothing about the settlers/tried to change the Court system etc.

He and his right wing Orthodox Jews are the ones you should be angry with.

Expand full comment

You did not read correctly and I know it's difficult.

They are against the current conflict (use your brain)!

What is OP?

Many people in Israel do not like Netanyahu.

Why? Because Net. has been indicted on many crimes. He is trying to stay out of prison. He also wanted to change the Judiciary the Israeli people were against this.

Do you know about Orthodox Jews? If you don't then take the time to look it up before you make stupid comments.

I suggest you do not make comments here until you take the time to look up and read about Israel!

Expand full comment

"You did not read correctly and I know it's difficult." - I know. Only people in France can manage easily. Others struggle mightily.

OP - original poster, the one who started the thread.

Expand full comment

Not sure but they certainly don't like Netanyahu and the Orthodox Jews who sit at home producing more and more children using women as breeding machines and don't have to fight wars.

Expand full comment

if they want to protest in support of the Palestinians, they will be arrested. It is illegal in Israel. In Germany too, it seems.

Expand full comment

I have to say one thing about Germany.

Please try and put yourselves in their shoes.

Most of the people living there now were not alive during the Holocaust. They know full well what happened and what was done.

Expand full comment

I don't think it is the German people making it illegal to support Palestine any more than it is the people of Israel making it illegal there. The holocaust left scars on many people, worse for those in Germany and Poland. It left scars on the people of the world. The present (and maybe the past) leaders of the world seem to have learned nothing from it.

Expand full comment

Oh, so they were doing it sneakily. Those Jews!

Expand full comment

Don't you know ? God ( or a reasonable facsimile ) just looks the OTHER WAY when Israel does something unimaginably abominable that attracts global attention & outrage. They THINK that they've gotten a big golden ticket.

Expand full comment

The other thing is that according to their holy books and the Old Testament, they’ve been doing this for 2000 years. No one has ever liked them for this reason—they are terrible neighbors!

Expand full comment

Property values take a BIG HIT. Literally. I'm trying to use minimal spoonfulls of humor to deal with a HORRIBLE, EVIL situation. I may succeed, I may fail abysmally.

Expand full comment

It’s all you can do sometimes.

Expand full comment

Fighting fire with Lakes Erie & Ontario. It could happen.

Expand full comment

Only if the pipeline Canada wants to put under the Lakes breaks.

Expand full comment

Did they ask PERMISSION 1st ? Politeness is practically an Article of Faith there. Except during traffic - related situations, so I hear.

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Expand full comment

I think we also have to look at our own countries. Lowkey is revealing how many British tech and surveillance companies are owned by Israel and how linked our secret services are. Our media and politicians are being funded by friends of Israel.

The same went for the covid policies directed by pharma. And the subsidies and abandonment of greeen policies directed by animal ag and oil.

Expand full comment

From Israel 's perspective, there is only one thing- don't face consequences.

Expand full comment

Nothing to see here, folks, just wounded Palestinians & Palestinian corpses, some almost intact.

Expand full comment