Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Geoff Fischer's avatar

If the Islamic Republic of Iran was truly evil, it would not be at war with the United States and Israel. It would be a firm ally of both those entities.

It is true that Iran has a level of domestic dissent. I know that from personal experience, because I have attended anti-government demonstrations in Tehran as an observer of the actions of both the protesters and the security forces, and I can say with confidence that militant protest demonstrations are tolerated by the regime so long as they stop short of physical violence.

We also know that when dissent erupted into violence early this year, it was incited and directed by the CIA and Mossad. One of the reasons we know that is because Donald Trump has demanded reparations for US troops killed or injured in the course of the war against Iran, and also for the insurrectionists who died in the February conflict. That was a clear acknowledgement that the insurrectionists were US assets. You don't demand reparations for someone else's losses.

It remains the case that public opinion in Iran is deeply divided between groups that I term the "Khameneis" on the one hand and the "Kardashians" on the other, and at times the conflict manifests in violence. But it is worth noting that less than 4000 died on both sides in the disturbances of early this year. Compare that with the 700,000 who died in the US civil war.

Those like myself who have actually lived in Iran and who don't have any loyalty to the iniquitous Pahlavi dynasty are able to see through the barrage of anti-Iranian propaganda in western media such as the Guardian.

Given that the west has been trying to strangle Iran to death since 1953, and arguably long before that, Iran is a remarkably open society which tolerates a greater range of political opinion than anything that I have seen in the west. An Iranian victory is vital for the future peace and security of the world in the face of the criminally insane behavior of Trump, Netanyahu, Hegseth, Rubio and all their henchmen. Those on the left who choose this moment to attack Iran are doing the work of Trump and Netanyahu, and they know it.

Jordan's avatar

The U.S. killed more schoolchildren in one strike, on the first day of the war, than Iran has killed including combatants and civilians over the entire six months. It's complete insanity to frame them as equal.

140 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?