Israel Pushes New Atrocity Narrative Just As Ceasefire Deadline Approaches
Listen to a reading of this article (reading by Tim Foley):
A new narrative is being aggressively pushed by Israel and its apologists to justify resuming the Gaza genocide, conveniently just as an important deadline for ceasefire negotiations draws near.
The IDF is now claiming that the Israeli children Kfir and Ariel Bibas “were both brutally murdered by terrorists while being held hostage in Gaza, no later than November 2023.”
IDF spokesman Daniel Hagari told the press on Friday that, “Contrary to Hamas’ lies, Ariel and Kfir were not killed in an airstrike. Ariel and Kfir Bibas were murdered by terrorists in cold blood. The terrorists did not shoot the two young boys, they killed them with their bare hands. Afterward, they committed horrific acts to cover up these atrocities.”
Anyone who has been following the events in Gaza over the last year and a half will be unsurprised to learn that Israel provided no evidence to support these incendiary claims.
Benjamin Netanyahu released a video statement in his signature American English waving around an enlarged photograph of the children and talking about what savage monsters the Palestinians are.
“Hamas murdered them in cold blood,” Netanyahu says, while the camera zooms in on the adorable little redheads. “As the prime minister of Israel, I vow that I will not rest until the savages who executed our hostages are brought to justice. They do not deserve to walk this earth. Nothing will stop me. Nothing.”
This happens just as Netanyahu has been working to sabotage ceasefire negotiations by adding new non-starter demands that were not in the original agreement, just as sources in Israeli media predicted he would do upon his return from Washington earlier this month. The six-week-long first stage of the ceasefire deal with Hamas is set to expire at the beginning of March.
This is obvious babies-on-bayonets atrocity propaganda, being released at the most convenient of times. After Israel has been caught lying about beheaded babies and mass rapes and so much more, only an idiot would take any of these claims on faith.
But it’s doing the job. Now everywhere you look you’ll see Israel supporters calling to end the ceasefire and reignite the Gaza holocaust to avenge these innocent children. I just saw an article from Tablet Magazine titled “Their Time Is Up,” subtitled “The murder of the Bibas children caps off an 18-month catalog of horrors that has told us exactly who our Palestinian neighbors are. Backed by a friend in the White House, Israel must secure its future through strong unilateral action.”
All this despite the fact that we know the most likely cause of the children’s death was the fact that their own government was raining military explosives on places where hostages were being held during that time. Hamas reported back in November 2023 that the Bibas children had been killed in an Israeli airstrike along with their mother. In December 2023 it was reported in the mainstream press that Hamas had offered to return their bodies to Israel but Israel refused, telling the press that “Israel will not address propaganda-based reports coming from Hamas”.
You don’t need to trust Hamas or anyone else to deduce that a woman and two children being killed by Israeli airstrikes in an area where many women and children were being killed by Israeli airstrikes every day is a much more likely scenario than Palestinian resistance fighters spontaneously deciding to murder children with their bare hands instead of using them as negotiating leverage as planned.
As journalist Muhammad Shehada recently noted on Twitter, Israel already has an established track record of lying about Hamas killing hostages who were actually killed in Israeli airstrikes. In December 2023, Israel informed the families of three hostages that they had been murdered by Hamas. The mother of one of the hostages kept digging and eventually discovered that they had died of asphyxiation when IDF troops “gassed” the tunnel they were hiding in. Last September the IDF admitted that they killed the hostages in an airstrike and lied about it.
Three weeks ago Shehada correctly predicted in an article with Zeteo that Israel was preparing to use the Bibas deaths as an excuse to terminate the ceasefire, long before any of this started. Shehada noticed the way pro-Israel narrative managers had been pushing the line that great vengeance must be exacted upon Gaza if it turns out the Bibas children have been harmed, despite Hamas having announced their deaths more than a year ago. They knew those children were dead, so after the ceasefire was announced in late January they began circulating the narrative that discovery of their demise would be a valid reason to end it.
Israeli forces shot and killed two Palestinian children in the West Bank just today — both of them shot in the back. You could be forgiven for not knowing that this happened, because the western political/media class has been too focused on the deaths of two little white kids to pay attention to such trivialities.
Israel needs to keep “discovering” new Hamas atrocities from 2023 because otherwise it just looks like one-sided atrocities being committed by Israel this whole time. First it was beheaded babies, then later it was “We’ve discovered Hamas did mass rapes!”, and now it’s the Bibas kids.
They need to do this because the Hamas attack was the last time anything happened where Israel could frame itself as the victim, so they’ve been milking it and milking it and milking it for as long as possible while committing orders of magnitude worse abuse in Gaza. It’s all designed to drum up outrage, and to draw sympathy toward Israel and away from the obvious victims who Israel has been abusing, displacing and mass murdering for a year and a half.
As calls to rain vengeance upon Gaza grow louder, remember this: the Bibas kids aren’t the reason, they’re the excuse. The excuse to advance pre-planned agendas against the Palestinians that have been in place since long before those children were born.
__________________
My work is entirely reader-supported, so if you enjoyed this piece here are some options where you can toss some money into my tip jar if you want to. Go here to find video versions of my articles. If you’d prefer to listen to audio of these articles, you can subscribe to them on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Soundcloud or YouTube. Go here to buy paperback editions of my writings from month to month. All my work is free to bootleg and use in any way, shape or form; republish it, translate it, use it on merchandise; whatever you want. The best way to make sure you see the stuff I publish is to subscribe to the mailing list on Substack, which will get you an email notification for everything I publish. All works co-authored with my husband Tim Foley.
Bitcoin donations: 1Ac7PCQXoQoLA9Sh8fhAgiU3PHA2EX5Zm2
Featured image is a screen grab from the IDF.
So, if such a crime were to be proven by independent investigators since nothing the Israelis say could be trusted, how would that compare to the well documented atrocities committed by Israeli snipers of shooting children, including toddlers, in the head and heart?
Anyone who thinks the remains of two small bodies, after 15 months, who were killed by Israeli bombs which suffocated them and/or, tore their bodies apart, would retain such evidence is truly gullible.
And if it did, how could anyone know whether or not the mother in total trauma decided to save her little ones from a worse fate, ripped apart by Israeli bombs?
Given the fact that the Palestinian Resistance/Hamas, said in November 23 they had all been killed by Israeli bombs, why in the name of sanity would they, since hostages, living ones, have value, have strangled two little kids?
This whole thing smacks of more Israeli excuses to murder more Palestinians, nearly half of them children, as it did when it invented beheaded babies, microwaved babies and babies hung on lines, all utterly debunked long ago.
The horrifying thing is that anyone is stupid enough to believe such blatant lies.
I just finished writing about this before reading Caitlin's article. Netanyahu, whose shield is war, is looking for any pretext to resume the genocide, and so while Hamas, which has NO motive to resume the bloodshed, has admitted it made an error after Israeli DNA tests show the woman delivered was not the hostage intended, and it has, reasonably, explained that she (an the children) were pulled out of a bombed out building and mistakenly thought to be the woman in question. Hamas has no DNA analysis to confirm identity so must go, in the case of people lying in the rubble of large concrete buildings on proximity. I have concluded there is no reason to believe Netanyahu that Hamas deliberately sabotaged a ceasefire they have sought for over a year nor to doubt Hamas, which admits to an error. I recall one of the released hostages telling the press that they, the hostages, feared IDF bombing as threats to their lives rather than Hamas, for whom living hostages have more value in bargaining terms. Even the Israeli's know that Netanyahu's political survival and escape from prison (he faces 3 corruption trials) is based on being at war and so he has done everything possible to keep the blood flowing. Hamas, as reason would suggest, desires equally for the attack on them and their neighbors, to stop.
People who would slaughter tens of thousands of women and children wouldn't hesitate to lie or to use a false and absurd accusation to resume the genocide, which is the means by which they maintain power.