212 Comments

I picture my dad way back when, dying in hospital of lung cancer complications, experiencing the profound pit of loss in my heart as I watched him leave us. But at least he seemed peaceful, the hospital room was clean, the staff compassionate, the atmosphere appropriately solemn. Then I try to imagine the alternative: instead of the placid face of the kind, just, loving man to whom I'll always be grateful, there lies on a filthy floor, a plastic bag of carnage,bloody human meat that used to be him. And it kindles just a bit of the sorrow and outrage that we need to sustain to realize that Israel must go, Zionism must be eliminated from the face of this planet. ASAP

Expand full comment

Vin LoPresti, I am with you. You have expressed what I feel but cannot put into words.

Expand full comment

I feel the same way, Indu. Vin LoPresti worded it so well and so powerfully. It is all so horrific and terrible. It sickens me that my country, the USA, still continues to send our tax dollars to Israel and fund this genocide and these atrocities. When Americans have protested this disgusting use of funding which should instead be used to help people in need, they have been met with brutality and violence from the police, in many cases. Indeed, as Vin LoPresti said, "Israel must go" and "Zionism must be eliminated."

Expand full comment

The strike is the only weapon that might stop this. The west needs to strike its masters, and every other nation in the world needs to strike the west.

It will hurt like holy crap. It is the only way.

5,000 screaming protesters outside the capital while the gore-encrusted psychopath inside gets 58 standing ovations in 52 minutes from the traitors who claim to represent those protesters. Our stupid signs are worth every bit as much as our stupid votes.

Strike.

We are out of alternatives, we are out of time: STRIKE

Expand full comment

Not a strike. A goddamned revolution.

Expand full comment

BUT who is going to start the revolution?

As you now dear Gypsy I lived in the US for 23yrs.

Expand full comment

Hi Jenny

I’m hoping that something gets brewing during the Dem convention in Chicago.

I want THIS one to put 1968’s to shame!

Expand full comment

Dear Gypsy. In my own opinion this will be a NOTHING convention. The Democrats are running scared. Will it happen?

Will the US elections happen?

Expand full comment

Hi Jenny

There was a certain gentleman from Russia who made several actual predictions about specific events. If anyone here could help me out with his name, much appreciated.

Anyways Jenny, this man stated that there won’t be a US election in ‘24 because there won’t BE a US.

We’ll see, I guess. Truthfully the world would be better off without us.

Expand full comment

Gypsy................I was shut down from substack for 4hrs.

I wish I could remember the name. He was employed by the Russian noblliy.

Expand full comment

Rasputin

Expand full comment

I think there will be a US but after??????????

Expand full comment

as long as strikes are voluntary for participants and do not violate the rights of others, I can support that.

However most of what we know as strikes are required and determined by a union where one has no choice on even whether to be a member or not - other than quitting the job

Expand full comment

Boycott, protest, disrupt, direct action, etc. 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸

Expand full comment

Donating as well!

Expand full comment

Perhaps a full-out Watts style action is required. Not looting, but something more significant.

Expand full comment

A general strike?

Expand full comment

That would be a start. Say all the garbage workers in DC go on strike until we stop shipping bombs to Israel.

Expand full comment

I like that. Small enough that many of us around the U.S. could chip in and sustain them for the duration. Symbolic too, for the only thing that stinks more than garbage left out to rot is what we're doing in Palestine.

Expand full comment

This should happen..........but the American people are milksops.

They have had their American Dream and are incapable of realising it has come to an end.

How many countries HATE the USA?

Expand full comment

And who are the most vulnerable to disruption? The politicians or the poor? The strong or the disabled?

Expand full comment

Why are you arguing against it?

Expand full comment

Neotoddlerism in a nutshell.

Expand full comment

I LOVE this word: Neotoddlerism!

Expand full comment

There was a piece i read this weekend on substack that introduced the term. I wish I'd saved it, sorry. The gist was that these shocking displays of protest or outrage are conducted with no consideration of the practical means to achieve the desired goal, nor any consideration of the cosequences associated with acts. In other words, a toddler temper tantrum.

Expand full comment

I would have thought it was blindingly obvious. Hey ho.

Expand full comment

Well, what do you propose?

Expand full comment

Is this comment/question as utterly idiotic as it seems to be ?

Expand full comment

Golly! We better just keep doing the same things then.

Expand full comment

I now this is irony ..............but many people do not.

Expand full comment

the poor and probably disabled too

Expand full comment

Our government should all be sent to The Hague , what criminals we’ve become in support of crazy people of Israel and its WW11 all over again instead of Germans it’s now Israelis , the world has to get rid of the name of Israel off the map and restore Palestine before we get into WW111 these Israelis have no soul they are a menace to the whole world and shame on the United States for being a part of this !!

Expand full comment

At this point, if someone is still in "Israel" they are a murdering monster. They are staying by choice, and revel in the blood.

Expand full comment

There are a few notable exceptions, like Gideon Levy and Amira Haas (not sure if she is still in Israel).

Expand full comment

extraction of israelis that have come to oppose the state of israel and just like palestinians risk to be taken hostage and used as human shields might be part of the resistance actions. (alas, i suspect it is a quite doable quantity.)

Expand full comment

NOT all Israeli's ....Zionists.

Expand full comment

No self-respecting person of Jewish faith would ever dare even to dream moving to Occupied Palestine and settle there under these conditions ...

Expand full comment

I think good people are fooled into the narrative that Gaza is filled with 2 million terrorists bent on killing Jews because of ‘ radical Islam ’. I’m sure the Nazis convinced otherwise good people in Germany that all their problems were caused by Jews. Why can’t we learn that atrocities are ALWAYS justified by lies.

Expand full comment

BINGO !!!

Absolute evil can only happen when most of the good people do nothing. And here we are again ...

Expand full comment

I think good people are fooled into a narrative that Israel is filled with 9.5M zionists bent on killing Palestinians because of zionism.

Expand full comment

According to Norman Finkelstein only 4 percent of the people in Israel want the slaughter to end.This is for all those people who kid themselves that Israelis have any heart.

Expand full comment

Heart: The Israelis seem to have no heart nor do their benefactors of the US/western supremacists?

Expand full comment

99.9% of Israelis ?

Expand full comment

Jenny, over half of the IsraHelli public believes that it’s fine and dandy to sodomize Palestinian “prisoners”.

Expand full comment

Gypsy. Israhell. I keep wondering about the Zionists. Are they all anti-gay?

IF so: We will all be obliged to give them what they want.

An iron (heated) rod up their own backsides...who knows they would probably enjoy this.

Expand full comment

all zionists are nationalists.

From my personal perspective, nationalist tend to be conservative in many way

Expand full comment

Apparently,according to Norman Finkelstein,only 4 percent of people in Israel want the genocide to stop.They are murdering bastards.

Expand full comment

Hi Jenny,,

Did your dad run KEGD in In Kalispell MT, about two decades ago?

Expand full comment

NO and I am not American..................!

Expand full comment

Sorry. A guy named John Stokes ran a really cool radio station there.

Since your not an American ,would you like to tell me where you're from?

Expand full comment

Interesting.

Firstly in English names "Stokes" was a very common name..........I am almost positive that they 'stoked' the flames during the Industrial revolution.

I am a music fan and would love to know the Radio Station.

I married a Stokes..it ended badly!

Many thanks for your interest.

Expand full comment

Sorry, I have a much darker view of this awful situation the so called rules based international order is in, several people mentioned this recently: it is a fight to the death for both sides and therefore there will be no compromises ... Very close to this opinion is the recent interview with Alastair Crooke (for my taste it is an excellent view of the bigger picture and we will be very lucky to survive this ... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0_kCS6Cy0dw)

Expand full comment

Well said Majid Khoury! And I agree with you 100%!!

Expand full comment
Aug 12·edited Aug 12

I read this and wonder aloud "how can my country (the U.S.A.) do this?" Yes, my country - our country - provide the massacre weapons to this genocidal Zionist regime? How do we live with ourselves? What lies must the powers that be tell themselves to justify their support and welcoming of the genocidal maniac Nentanyahu into our Congress and applaud him like he is some kind of God speaking truth when all he gives them are lies so they will continue to provide the genocidal weapons and warships? Shamed and angry is how I feel.

Expand full comment

Humans say that they are rational but they are not. They are rationalizers, not rational.

Expand full comment

Anyone who cannot see this as unforgivable evil has lost their soul. They are like rabid dogs who will not stop until they are destroyed either by the ravages of their sickness or the hand of humanity putting them down like any caring person would do for a terminally ill animal. How can anybody justify this? The Western Countries and governments have truly lost their souls to allow this to continue.

Expand full comment

Totally agree. They’re not going to stop this massacre of their own accord, it’s a psychopathic state.

Expand full comment

They don’t see it and are not looking. They do what the tv tells them

Expand full comment

We absolutely have to move from pain to anger, from anger to reaction, from reaction to solution, and from solution to action. This must be done! Whether we are working or on vacation.

Expand full comment

Those who comfort themselves by telling themselves that "this is a long game" ignore the fact that real cats and humans suffer right now.

Expand full comment

'Those who comfort themselves by telling themselves that "this is a long game"'

They do? That's too weird.

Expand full comment

Humans are true masters at rationalizing.

Expand full comment

Those who insist on voting for Kamala say that.

Expand full comment

Just what are they hoping to get out of this "long game?" I have no contact with such people.

Expand full comment

To avoid having to do something right now.

Expand full comment

Blimey! Each time I think "it can't get worse" I'm proven wrong. So now I say it will get worse.

Expand full comment

The journey of an empath through this world ain’t easy. Seems like we just speak to and encourage each other amid the never ending storm across time. I still feel though. I know it matters. The psychic energy. If Satan owns this world, don’t let him own the others. God bless all the children of the light.

Expand full comment

We were not born for this world.

Expand full comment

It is exactly we who were born for this world in times of the greatest need.

Expand full comment

A sow has the same genetic make up as a woman, though in a slightly different arrangement yet we confine the former to birthing crates til she drops dead. A monkey has the same range of emotions as a human yet we confine the former to research labs and drill electrodes into their brains.

Are we not 'monsters' too?

Expand full comment

Regardless of the answer, we have to stop being monsters, and it needs to start with the most outrageous atrocities we are committing against our own species.

Expand full comment

There's no hierarchy of atrocities nor separation between species. How we live and interact is all connected.

Expand full comment

is there a need to tacticly prioritise or is the suggestion to first focus on liberating lab-animals?

Expand full comment

All I said was everyone is deserving of compassion. If you feel you can ‘tacticly’ control events and stop genocides and/or vivisection by focusing on them- why haven’t you done it yet?

Expand full comment

We are.

Expand full comment

Similar things were happening in Eastern Ukraine for eight long years and happen still, until Russian "aggressors" decided to intervene. It's amazing how the rest of Ukraine could care less and often cheered.

Expand full comment

And when the Russians finally intervened, the West decried and condemned it as an “illegal invasion”.

Expand full comment

The rest of Ukraine wanted the tax revenue.

Expand full comment

imo, it only served to provoke russia. what the rest of ukraine wanted, did not matter at all.

Expand full comment

Thank you so much, Caitlin, for naming what we are all in danger of losing as we relentlessly witness in shock the seemingly endless horror, and the helplessness to stop, the truly unspeakable suffering of our brothers and sisters in Gaza/Palestine. Naming the danger and also the remedy, because having "wide open hearts full of compassion" along with the equally fully human anger and outrage, is the hard inner work of love that feeds all effective actions that can and will stop these malevolent forces!

"Do not let them harden you."

"It is safe to feel."

"The victims deserve our sorrow. We deserve to have wide open hearts full of compassion. And the monsters who are doing this absolutely do not deserve to take it away from us."

Yes, Yes and Yes!

Expand full comment

It is a US genocide - Nazi Israelis are “just” the executioners.

Shame on US — eternal shame !!!!

Expand full comment

Name and shame the monsters that your elect for Congress but then again their underlying grassroots base is as rotten!

Expand full comment

Thank you Caitlin 👏👏👏

Expand full comment