"Zionism means nonstop apartheid, ethnic cleansing, war, genocide, and abuse." And worse, Zionists think that they have the right to impose all that because they are "special". Even worse, the US, UK, Canada, Australia and many other countries do not step in to stop any of this behaviour. In fact, many send arms to Israel. It seems that the lives of some do not matter when there is a profit to be made.
Right, Susan. The states you list are complicit through technical and arms support provided to Israel in its pursuit of murderous policy and action. Clearly our political representatives are scared shitless of Zionazi influence, and can't summon the spine to confront the Israeli bastardry that's so clearly undeniable. 'Straya's performance is weak, embarrassing, sickening and infuriating. It's only Greens and some Independents who are in any way forthright in their condemnation of Zionazi slaughter, and our gutlessness.
It's past time someone did. Although some are making their choices known in different ways. What sickens me about Australia is how our PM makes no moves until others have, the hangs on the coattails as though that means anything., especially when this same person before his step up was a "Friend of Palestine". He sure as he'll dropped that super fast, I keep wondering just who whispered in his ear long enough to change a whole stance so radically, so fast.
Actually, I don't think it is about anyone being scared of Zionazis except that maybe they might lose some money. I don't think they really care about the "Zionazi influence" anywhere near as much as they are concerned about their bank accounts being affected.
Even at that, I think they don't see what Epstein and his crowd did as all that bad unless they were in the position to lose money over it. Maybe I am getting too cynical, but there seems to be very little that really gets to these people other than when their bank accounts are hit or when they might lose some of the power over other people that they have taken for themselves.
Zionism also means using jews until they are no longer useful to "world domination" that zionists plan. On, if, that should happen jews become of no more use to them, so up go the concentration camps once again, just like they helped the Nazis with the planning of the camps in the 1930s and on.
It's pretty sick when you think about it; the moneyed cult that helped, actually pushed for the killing of six million jews, give or take a few hundred, then planned to use the survivors in their takeover of another country - out of a choice of four countries, Palestine lost big time, and still are.
That's your gentle, peace-loving, zionist liars cult, so enamoured by themselves they'll use anyone to get their agenda completed. I'm not sure if I should feel sorry for the jews that were taken in by their lies, and what is coming, or be angry that they believed themselves to be as important as the zionists believe themselves to be, and went along with the killing because of that lie?
Except that the number of 6 million is impossible. Many of them weren't even killed anyway, the Final Solution was about relocating them, not killing them.
“Final Solution” did not mean simple relocation by 1941–42. Earlier Nazi policy had indeed emphasized forced emigration and expulsion. But after the invasion of the Soviet Union, policy shifted to systematic mass murder. At Wannsee in January 1942, officials discussed roughly 11 million European Jews under the “Final Solution.” The surviving protocol says many forced laborers would die and that the surviving “remnant” would have to be “treated accordingly.” By then mass shootings and gassings were already underway.
“Resettlement to the East” was Nazi camouflage language. Deportees were routinely told they were being relocated or sent to labor camps; many were actually transported to killing centers and murdered.
The Germans generated enormous amounts of documentation. The Einsatzgruppen and associated units murdered more than one million Jews in mass shootings in the occupied Soviet territories. Entire communities—men, women and children—were shot.
The approximately six-million figure is not based on one witness or one postwar guess. Historians combine surviving German records, transport and killing-center records, prewar and postwar demographic data, Jewish records and other archives. The US Holocaust Memorial Museum estimates roughly 2.7 million murdered at killing centers, about 2 million in mass shootings, 800,000–1 million in ghettos/labor/concentration camps, and at least 250,000 in other violence and deprivation.
A concise reply you could post:
Reply to Holocaust denial
That is Holocaust denial, not history.
The Nazis’ own records refute it. By 1941–42 the “Final Solution” meant the systematic destruction of Europe’s Jews, not merely relocation. “Resettlement to the East” was one of the euphemisms used while Jews were deported to killing centers.
The Germans also kept records of the killing. Einsatzgruppen reports document mass shootings of entire Jewish communities—men, women and children. More than a million Jews were murdered in these shootings alone."
And six million is an approximate historical total derived from German documents, transport records and prewar/postwar demographic studies—not a number somebody simply invented. About 2.7 million were murdered at killing centers, roughly 2 million in mass shootings, and hundreds of thousands more in ghettos, camps, forced labor, starvation and other killing operations.
You don't have to trust Allied propaganda. The perpetrators left the paperwork."
You needed AI to find public information that has been available for 80 years, and you STILL got it wrong. Just because someone wrote that something happened doesn't make it true. AI scanned those sources which were fed by info which was already incorrect. How many other sources did you comb through to see if what you wrote is correct? Oh, my bad...YOU didn't write it, you relied on AI to do the work for you, then you copy/pasted the incorrect responses given to you by AI. Most of the points you gave here are incorrect. The Germans didn't just randomly kill everyone, they actually provided what amounts to health care because they didn't want diseases such as Typhus to infect all the people in the labor camps. The number of 11 million can't be correct, as i said about the number of 6 million being incorrect because the numbers were inflated to make the Nazis sound worse than they actually were. For example, outside of Auschwitz the memorial plaque stated 4.5 million dead. They changed it to reflect that only around 1.1 million died. So around 3.4 million people did not die there, and also in how many other camps? The info you provided is not correct.
Here, if you can still use your own mind to find details, try reading this instead of using fallible AI, which always comes with the disclaimer,
" information related by AI may not be accurate; may contain mistakes " ...not to mention the obvious fact that your search for any relatable info on the Holocaust would have immediately searched through all the propagandized and incorrect info that we were told as compared to the real narrative which was buried due to the involvement of US and other forces arming and financing BOTH sides in WW2.
Exactly. Kudos to Green Party leader Zach Polanski for naming what is obvious to anyone paying attention.
Any philosophy shows itself by what it does. If I like what a person does, I'll be interested in their philosophy, and the same goes for a state. If it's people are thriving and doing good things in the world, I'll be interested in the philosophy that's guiding it.
When we see what Israel has done and continues to do, there's no other conclusion to come to except that it's a racist ideology.
I wish someone would explain to me why Jews "deserve" or "have a right to" self-determination. What other religion demands a collective self-determination for all its adherents? Where does it say in international law that a group who share a religion is entitled to self-determination?
All people are entitled to self-determination, it's a jus cogens norm. People just confuse external self-determination (creating a state) with internal self-determination (having equal rights and the ability to determine your future through the political process) within a state.
Jews in NY have a right of self-determination and exercise that right as internal self-determination (equal rights, right to vote and be elected, etc). Palestinians in the OPT also have a right of self-determination and are obviously denied that right by Israel (ICJ/2024)
Individuals have a right to self-determination, I agree. It's the claimed right of collective self-determination on the basis of religion that I balk at.
Judaism is only a religion. Sephardic Jews, Ethiopian Jews, Ashkenazi Jews, Iranian Jews and all the other Jewish groups do not have a shared history or culture. Hebrew is a very modern, ersatz language and is not universally spoken by Jews. Palestine is not the ancestral homeland of European Jews. I know Jews who are as pure Han Chinese as you can get, and they don't claim Palestine as their ancestral homeland. I also know converts to Judaism who have no Levantine ancestry at all.
Self-determination is a right of individuals, not groups. There are many ethnicities that don't claim land on the grounds that they have a right to those lands, so there is no reason why Jews are entitled to steal land on the imagined basis of collective "self-determination".
One thing is very sure; Zionists are incorrigible liars. You are a classic example of that, Phillip.
Read it again! And maybe work on your English comprehension?
The KKK (Ku Klux Klan) is a white supremacist hate group; calling it "racist" is obviously true, not absurd. So if the sentence says "claiming Zionism is racist is as absurd as claiming the KKK is racist," the literal logic is: both claims are absurd. That would imply the speaker thinks calling the KKK racist is absurd — which is self-evidently false to most people.
Your "correction" removes the sarcasm, which removes the moral intent of my sentence construction: "The moral purpose of sarcasm is usually to expose a contradiction, hypocrisy, or moral absurdity by making it sound ridiculous.
It can do several things at once: shame hypocrisy, puncture self-importance, reveal that an argument leads somewhere absurd, and communicate moral outrage without giving a long lecture. In that sense, sarcasm can be a form of moral criticism." I am sorry you missed the intent and on that basis, want to remove something you missed.
Following this thread, I think your attempt at sarcasm is unclear (though it may seem clear to you from your perspective). Hence the pushback you seem to be receiving.
Since you seem to be a proponent of AI, why not try asking an AI the following two questions?
(1) "Is the sarcasm or irony in the statement "Claiming that Zionism is racist is as absurd as claiming the KKK is racist." apparent or obvious?"
(2) "how to denote sarcasm when it is not readily apparent from sentence construction"
Here is the response from one AI on the question "Is the sarcasm or irony in the statement "Claiming that Zionism is racist is as absurd as claiming the KKK is racist." apparent or obvious?"
----------
No. The statement will generally be read as literal rather than sarcastic: it appears to argue that calling Zionism racist is absurd, just as—according to the speaker—calling the KKK racist would be absurd.
If the intended meaning is sarcastic—that calling Zionism racist is not absurd—most readers may miss it because the comparison is grammatically straightforward and the KKK example strongly invites a literal interpretation. Make the intended reversal explicit, for example:
“Yes, obviously the KKK is racist—but apparently calling Zionism racist is supposed to be absurd? That logic is itself absurd.”
Or add a marker:
“Claiming that Zionism is racist is as absurd as claiming the KKK is racist. (Sarcasm.)”
Even then, the first version is clearer because it states the intended meaning rather than relying on a sarcasm cue.
--------
You can try it with other AIs to see what you get.
DR's sentence is perfectly clear to me as it is offered in a stylistic choice that in effect states: we all know the KKK is racist, so there's nothing absurd about saying as much. Equally, there's nothing absurd about saying Zionism is racist because it is indeed very much as racist as the KKK. Both, thus, are profoundly racist ideologies and there's nothing absurd about point out these clearly evident facts.
No. DR's sentence construction is rhetorically slippery. It relies on the audience sharing the speaker's premise about either Zionism or the KKK.
If DR's actual intent was to defend Zionism, then my version expresses the opposite sentiment. If DR's intent was to attack Zionism, then my version is the logically cleaner and much harder to misread way to say it, and the original was just a confusingly worded version of the same idea. Hence I suggested checking 'the sentence construction'.
Which one is "correct" depends entirely on what the original speaker (DR) actually meant, and the original is ambiguous precisely because it's badly built.
You really don't know how sarcasm works, do you? And then you double, triple, and quadruple down on your lack of understanding. The original sentence was perfectly understandable in the context of SARCASM. Obviously it's not meant to be taken literally.
Some people, who feign certainty, are so insecure about their claims, that when shown to be unjustified, rather than saying "Thank you; now I am able to be correct," get defensive and start to gaslight or invent excuses or go ad hominem or in your case, block you. I try always to thank the person who corrects me as a great gift. Some see it as an attack, signaling a primary lack of committment to the truth, or being correct. We all make errors and the quicker we admit it, the quicker we are in truth.
Oh, yeah. I'd rather have a correct understanding that means my previous opinion was wrong than bravely defend my wrong opinion to the death. It’s not a good look.
But you say that you don't use AI or search engines. What's your basis for "correct" understanding? Whatever you think is correct? Without evidence backing up your arguments, it's just an opinion like any other.
Zionism is aiming and shooting children in the face. Zionism is blowing babies into baby bits on a daily basis. Zionism is bombing the limbs off of thousands of humans and taking medical help and food away from them. Zionism is not just terrorism. Zionism is abject EVIL!
If Judaism had never been invented no Jew would exist. No religion has a right to land, homeland, self determination and that includes Jews. More so because while Zionism is a fascist political movement created by atheists the only reason they are in Palestine is because of Jewish fairy tales, i.e. religious reasons which are illegal and immoral.
No religion gets a homeland. If Jews had such a right then every religion would have the same right. None do.
The zionist Ashkenazi power structure is “special."
After all its the spawn of white supremacist European imperialists and we see those countries, that "don't step in to stop any of this behaviour,” are themselves imperialists or white settler siblings, of this US backed genocidal zionist apartheid project in occupied Palestine 🇵🇸.
"Zionism means nonstop apartheid, ethnic cleansing, war, genocide, and abuse."
This should be the official definition of the z-word. It's how you act that defines you and Zionists seem to be experts in those fields. (That should make them happy being the world's best ethnic cleansers/genocidaires/abusers/segregationalists/war hawks, right?)
Reasonable people can see that Zionism is the core reason for the total destruction of Gaza, the ethnic cleansing and the oppression of Palestinian life. That it is a political taboo to say so is a product of the ethnostate’s easily observable, asymmetrical influence within the Western political class.
We shall now see why it is a political no‑no to mount a moral opposition to Zionism: the coming shitstorm for the Greens will only demonstrate how effective Israel’s disproportionate influence over empire has become.
“Israel” should always be in quotes because it is illegitimate. It’s pure deception for them to try to claim the name. The legitimate, biblical Israel was destroyed in 70ad. The 1948 version is a counterfeit from satan. Anyone that knows of their founding documents knows this to be true. “Israel” wasn’t even their first choice for a name. They failed two others before passing the name for the purpose of deception. Wake up!
Thanks Caitlin & Tim. In far off better days of the UN when decolonisation was happening, there was a movement to equate zionism with racism. But the same countries which are now supporting a genocide scuppered it.
These countries are now in the dock with zionist, apartheid Israel.
When I was in high school, half a century ago, this was being discussed at the United Nations. I remember talking about it with my history teacher. He thought it was pretty uncontroversial that Zionism was racist.
- My wife is a Muslim, of Pakistani descent - so I understand a bit about racism
- I am a member of The Green Party
- And I am the very opposite of a nice, latte-sipping, liberal.
- Yes, the fascist, Israeli regime has committed genocide in Gaza & ethnic cleansing in the West Bank
- And yes, the UK government is complicit
- The proscription of Palestine Action is wrong, and an abuse of the Terrorism Act.
- Arresting peaceful protestors who support Palestine is wrong
- Israel should be sanctioned and all arms sales stopped
But... this motion is Corbyn-level* political naivety. It will damage the party's credibility - and thus, diminish its voice. All our voices. The motion achieves nothing. It is pure, (naive), political posturing, that puts a target on the back of the Green Party, and puts its MPs on the back foot. It demonstrates that a politically naive, idealist minority can capture the Green Party agenda. And that is going to damage its reputation.
Yes, I know... that's how democracy works. Unfortunately, the zealots know how to exploit it.
* I pretty much agree with everything Jeremy Corbyn stands for - but he is shite at politics. As is evident from where he now is. You don't "win" at politics by shooting yourself in the foot. Ahhh... Michael Foot. Another politician who stood for all the right things, and... yeah!
I think it is ultimately a supremacist ideology that is inherently racists. Talmudic Jews and/or and especially Zionists base their belief on "Gods chosen people" mythology. Ironically, it's a lot like Nazism. White nationalism's recent incarnation as ''we just want to be masters of our own land" trope is an attempt to disguise the fact that first they will need to ethnically cleanse or outright murder everyone else. No one would actually accept a Zionist as God's message to the world that they are inferior and must bow.
To clarify it is not Zack Polanski who made this policy. It is the members. He was not even there when the motion was written and put forward by Palestinian and anti Zionist Jews and other members. The motion was filibustered in the Spring conference and finally was discussed and won yesterday after wrecking motions were voted down.
"Zionism means nonstop apartheid, ethnic cleansing, war, genocide, and abuse." And worse, Zionists think that they have the right to impose all that because they are "special". Even worse, the US, UK, Canada, Australia and many other countries do not step in to stop any of this behaviour. In fact, many send arms to Israel. It seems that the lives of some do not matter when there is a profit to be made.
Right, Susan. The states you list are complicit through technical and arms support provided to Israel in its pursuit of murderous policy and action. Clearly our political representatives are scared shitless of Zionazi influence, and can't summon the spine to confront the Israeli bastardry that's so clearly undeniable. 'Straya's performance is weak, embarrassing, sickening and infuriating. It's only Greens and some Independents who are in any way forthright in their condemnation of Zionazi slaughter, and our gutlessness.
Agree David Baird. Let's hope David Shoebridge will take a strong stand in exposing Israel for the genocide state that it is.
It's past time someone did. Although some are making their choices known in different ways. What sickens me about Australia is how our PM makes no moves until others have, the hangs on the coattails as though that means anything., especially when this same person before his step up was a "Friend of Palestine". He sure as he'll dropped that super fast, I keep wondering just who whispered in his ear long enough to change a whole stance so radically, so fast.
Agree and he’s not the only one. PW seems a timid shadow of her former self…..
💯%
Actually, I don't think it is about anyone being scared of Zionazis except that maybe they might lose some money. I don't think they really care about the "Zionazi influence" anywhere near as much as they are concerned about their bank accounts being affected.
Unless, of course, they are in the Epstein files.
Even at that, I think they don't see what Epstein and his crowd did as all that bad unless they were in the position to lose money over it. Maybe I am getting too cynical, but there seems to be very little that really gets to these people other than when their bank accounts are hit or when they might lose some of the power over other people that they have taken for themselves.
Zionism also means using jews until they are no longer useful to "world domination" that zionists plan. On, if, that should happen jews become of no more use to them, so up go the concentration camps once again, just like they helped the Nazis with the planning of the camps in the 1930s and on.
It's pretty sick when you think about it; the moneyed cult that helped, actually pushed for the killing of six million jews, give or take a few hundred, then planned to use the survivors in their takeover of another country - out of a choice of four countries, Palestine lost big time, and still are.
That's your gentle, peace-loving, zionist liars cult, so enamoured by themselves they'll use anyone to get their agenda completed. I'm not sure if I should feel sorry for the jews that were taken in by their lies, and what is coming, or be angry that they believed themselves to be as important as the zionists believe themselves to be, and went along with the killing because of that lie?
Except that the number of 6 million is impossible. Many of them weren't even killed anyway, the Final Solution was about relocating them, not killing them.
AI helped refute this common neo-Nazi denial.
" The key facts are:
“Final Solution” did not mean simple relocation by 1941–42. Earlier Nazi policy had indeed emphasized forced emigration and expulsion. But after the invasion of the Soviet Union, policy shifted to systematic mass murder. At Wannsee in January 1942, officials discussed roughly 11 million European Jews under the “Final Solution.” The surviving protocol says many forced laborers would die and that the surviving “remnant” would have to be “treated accordingly.” By then mass shootings and gassings were already underway.
“Resettlement to the East” was Nazi camouflage language. Deportees were routinely told they were being relocated or sent to labor camps; many were actually transported to killing centers and murdered.
The Germans generated enormous amounts of documentation. The Einsatzgruppen and associated units murdered more than one million Jews in mass shootings in the occupied Soviet territories. Entire communities—men, women and children—were shot.
The approximately six-million figure is not based on one witness or one postwar guess. Historians combine surviving German records, transport and killing-center records, prewar and postwar demographic data, Jewish records and other archives. The US Holocaust Memorial Museum estimates roughly 2.7 million murdered at killing centers, about 2 million in mass shootings, 800,000–1 million in ghettos/labor/concentration camps, and at least 250,000 in other violence and deprivation.
A concise reply you could post:
Reply to Holocaust denial
That is Holocaust denial, not history.
The Nazis’ own records refute it. By 1941–42 the “Final Solution” meant the systematic destruction of Europe’s Jews, not merely relocation. “Resettlement to the East” was one of the euphemisms used while Jews were deported to killing centers.
The Germans also kept records of the killing. Einsatzgruppen reports document mass shootings of entire Jewish communities—men, women and children. More than a million Jews were murdered in these shootings alone."
And six million is an approximate historical total derived from German documents, transport records and prewar/postwar demographic studies—not a number somebody simply invented. About 2.7 million were murdered at killing centers, roughly 2 million in mass shootings, and hundreds of thousands more in ghettos, camps, forced labor, starvation and other killing operations.
You don't have to trust Allied propaganda. The perpetrators left the paperwork."
" AI helped refute this common neo-Nazi denial. "
You needed AI to find public information that has been available for 80 years, and you STILL got it wrong. Just because someone wrote that something happened doesn't make it true. AI scanned those sources which were fed by info which was already incorrect. How many other sources did you comb through to see if what you wrote is correct? Oh, my bad...YOU didn't write it, you relied on AI to do the work for you, then you copy/pasted the incorrect responses given to you by AI. Most of the points you gave here are incorrect. The Germans didn't just randomly kill everyone, they actually provided what amounts to health care because they didn't want diseases such as Typhus to infect all the people in the labor camps. The number of 11 million can't be correct, as i said about the number of 6 million being incorrect because the numbers were inflated to make the Nazis sound worse than they actually were. For example, outside of Auschwitz the memorial plaque stated 4.5 million dead. They changed it to reflect that only around 1.1 million died. So around 3.4 million people did not die there, and also in how many other camps? The info you provided is not correct.
Here, if you can still use your own mind to find details, try reading this instead of using fallible AI, which always comes with the disclaimer,
" information related by AI may not be accurate; may contain mistakes " ...not to mention the obvious fact that your search for any relatable info on the Holocaust would have immediately searched through all the propagandized and incorrect info that we were told as compared to the real narrative which was buried due to the involvement of US and other forces arming and financing BOTH sides in WW2.
https://archive.org/details/hoaxoftwentiethc0000butz
Stop centering how Jews "suffer" from Zionism, the vast majority support and benefit from its existence.
Iranian diplomat speaks out against the UN for giving Netanyahu a platform. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1_skrhP0KPw
Exactly. Kudos to Green Party leader Zach Polanski for naming what is obvious to anyone paying attention.
Any philosophy shows itself by what it does. If I like what a person does, I'll be interested in their philosophy, and the same goes for a state. If it's people are thriving and doing good things in the world, I'll be interested in the philosophy that's guiding it.
When we see what Israel has done and continues to do, there's no other conclusion to come to except that it's a racist ideology.
Capitalist ideology may also be a factor. Palestine has massive reserves of petroleum to be exploited.
I wish someone would explain to me why Jews "deserve" or "have a right to" self-determination. What other religion demands a collective self-determination for all its adherents? Where does it say in international law that a group who share a religion is entitled to self-determination?
All people are entitled to self-determination, it's a jus cogens norm. People just confuse external self-determination (creating a state) with internal self-determination (having equal rights and the ability to determine your future through the political process) within a state.
Jews in NY have a right of self-determination and exercise that right as internal self-determination (equal rights, right to vote and be elected, etc). Palestinians in the OPT also have a right of self-determination and are obviously denied that right by Israel (ICJ/2024)
Individuals have a right to self-determination, I agree. It's the claimed right of collective self-determination on the basis of religion that I balk at.
It doesn't. It's the zionist using them and telling them they have that right, until their usefulness is over, then it's the camps again.
Many nations involved seizing a territory through violence and defending it with violence. They call this their "right to exist."
Like the the good ol’ U S of fucking A built on genocide, settler colonialism, slavery, greed and profiteering.
Judaism is only a religion. Sephardic Jews, Ethiopian Jews, Ashkenazi Jews, Iranian Jews and all the other Jewish groups do not have a shared history or culture. Hebrew is a very modern, ersatz language and is not universally spoken by Jews. Palestine is not the ancestral homeland of European Jews. I know Jews who are as pure Han Chinese as you can get, and they don't claim Palestine as their ancestral homeland. I also know converts to Judaism who have no Levantine ancestry at all.
Self-determination is a right of individuals, not groups. There are many ethnicities that don't claim land on the grounds that they have a right to those lands, so there is no reason why Jews are entitled to steal land on the imagined basis of collective "self-determination".
One thing is very sure; Zionists are incorrigible liars. You are a classic example of that, Phillip.
Claiming that Zionism is racist is as absurd as claiming the KKK is racist.
"Claiming that Zionism is racist is as absurd as claiming the KKK is racist."
You might want to check your sentence construction there.
Here's a correction: Claiming that Zionism is not racist is as absurd as claiming that the KKK is not racist.
No, I'm pretty sure that sentence was correct.
Read it again! And maybe work on your English comprehension?
The KKK (Ku Klux Klan) is a white supremacist hate group; calling it "racist" is obviously true, not absurd. So if the sentence says "claiming Zionism is racist is as absurd as claiming the KKK is racist," the literal logic is: both claims are absurd. That would imply the speaker thinks calling the KKK racist is absurd — which is self-evidently false to most people.
Exactly. Both claims are self-evident, so they are equally absurd.
sarcasm flips the script as a moral construct.
Your "correction" removes the sarcasm, which removes the moral intent of my sentence construction: "The moral purpose of sarcasm is usually to expose a contradiction, hypocrisy, or moral absurdity by making it sound ridiculous.
It can do several things at once: shame hypocrisy, puncture self-importance, reveal that an argument leads somewhere absurd, and communicate moral outrage without giving a long lecture. In that sense, sarcasm can be a form of moral criticism." I am sorry you missed the intent and on that basis, want to remove something you missed.
Following this thread, I think your attempt at sarcasm is unclear (though it may seem clear to you from your perspective). Hence the pushback you seem to be receiving.
Since you seem to be a proponent of AI, why not try asking an AI the following two questions?
(1) "Is the sarcasm or irony in the statement "Claiming that Zionism is racist is as absurd as claiming the KKK is racist." apparent or obvious?"
(2) "how to denote sarcasm when it is not readily apparent from sentence construction"
Here is the response from one AI on the question "Is the sarcasm or irony in the statement "Claiming that Zionism is racist is as absurd as claiming the KKK is racist." apparent or obvious?"
----------
No. The statement will generally be read as literal rather than sarcastic: it appears to argue that calling Zionism racist is absurd, just as—according to the speaker—calling the KKK racist would be absurd.
If the intended meaning is sarcastic—that calling Zionism racist is not absurd—most readers may miss it because the comparison is grammatically straightforward and the KKK example strongly invites a literal interpretation. Make the intended reversal explicit, for example:
“Yes, obviously the KKK is racist—but apparently calling Zionism racist is supposed to be absurd? That logic is itself absurd.”
Or add a marker:
“Claiming that Zionism is racist is as absurd as claiming the KKK is racist. (Sarcasm.)”
Even then, the first version is clearer because it states the intended meaning rather than relying on a sarcasm cue.
--------
You can try it with other AIs to see what you get.
DR's sentence is perfectly clear to me as it is offered in a stylistic choice that in effect states: we all know the KKK is racist, so there's nothing absurd about saying as much. Equally, there's nothing absurd about saying Zionism is racist because it is indeed very much as racist as the KKK. Both, thus, are profoundly racist ideologies and there's nothing absurd about point out these clearly evident facts.
No. DR's sentence construction is rhetorically slippery. It relies on the audience sharing the speaker's premise about either Zionism or the KKK.
If DR's actual intent was to defend Zionism, then my version expresses the opposite sentiment. If DR's intent was to attack Zionism, then my version is the logically cleaner and much harder to misread way to say it, and the original was just a confusingly worded version of the same idea. Hence I suggested checking 'the sentence construction'.
Which one is "correct" depends entirely on what the original speaker (DR) actually meant, and the original is ambiguous precisely because it's badly built.
You're really overthinking this. You just misread it, that's all.
You really don't know how sarcasm works, do you? And then you double, triple, and quadruple down on your lack of understanding. The original sentence was perfectly understandable in the context of SARCASM. Obviously it's not meant to be taken literally.
“Logically cleaner”, perhaps, but sadly stylistically sterilised in the process.
No, you only have to see the KKK claim as absurd.
No, it's correct.
Here we go again...
I think your ‘irony enabled’ switch may have been inadvertently inactivated.
The sarcasm presents as a moral criticism, not just an obvious (yawn) fact.
Racism includes religious bigotry. Jews who believe they are superior humans are no different to Christians, KKK, believing they are superior humans.
Zionism seeks to steal someone else's country and exterminate all non-Jews. That is racism, genocidal racism.
I read all the protests against this statement below, but initially when I read it I took it as just dripping with sarcasm. Am I wrong?
You are right: I used sarcasm as moral criticism.
Apparently Jay Tse has blocked me because I have the audacity to understand sarcasm. Odd thing to get upset about.
Some people, who feign certainty, are so insecure about their claims, that when shown to be unjustified, rather than saying "Thank you; now I am able to be correct," get defensive and start to gaslight or invent excuses or go ad hominem or in your case, block you. I try always to thank the person who corrects me as a great gift. Some see it as an attack, signaling a primary lack of committment to the truth, or being correct. We all make errors and the quicker we admit it, the quicker we are in truth.
Did you see my two replies to you here ? (https://www.caitlinjohnst.one/p/zionism-is-obviously-a-racist-ideology/comment/353727669, and https://www.caitlinjohnst.one/p/zionism-is-obviously-a-racist-ideology/comment/353782687)
You haven't bothered to reply, so I assume you understand better now.
Oh, yeah. I'd rather have a correct understanding that means my previous opinion was wrong than bravely defend my wrong opinion to the death. It’s not a good look.
Look here if you want clarity -
(1) https://www.caitlinjohnst.one/p/zionism-is-obviously-a-racist-ideology/comment/353727669
(2) https://www.caitlinjohnst.one/p/zionism-is-obviously-a-racist-ideology/comment/353782687
But you say that you don't use AI or search engines. What's your basis for "correct" understanding? Whatever you think is correct? Without evidence backing up your arguments, it's just an opinion like any other.
Which Christian Denominations believe they are superior to the rest of Mankind?
Zionism is aiming and shooting children in the face. Zionism is blowing babies into baby bits on a daily basis. Zionism is bombing the limbs off of thousands of humans and taking medical help and food away from them. Zionism is not just terrorism. Zionism is abject EVIL!
Zionists train dogs to rape prisoners.
Thanks for the perfect reply to:
“Zionism is just the belief that Jews deserve a homeland and self-determination,”
...and to train dogs to rape prisoners.
If Judaism had never been invented no Jew would exist. No religion has a right to land, homeland, self determination and that includes Jews. More so because while Zionism is a fascist political movement created by atheists the only reason they are in Palestine is because of Jewish fairy tales, i.e. religious reasons which are illegal and immoral.
No religion gets a homeland. If Jews had such a right then every religion would have the same right. None do.
The zionist Ashkenazi power structure is “special."
After all its the spawn of white supremacist European imperialists and we see those countries, that "don't step in to stop any of this behaviour,” are themselves imperialists or white settler siblings, of this US backed genocidal zionist apartheid project in occupied Palestine 🇵🇸.
"Zionism means nonstop apartheid, ethnic cleansing, war, genocide, and abuse."
This should be the official definition of the z-word. It's how you act that defines you and Zionists seem to be experts in those fields. (That should make them happy being the world's best ethnic cleansers/genocidaires/abusers/segregationalists/war hawks, right?)
Reasonable people can see that Zionism is the core reason for the total destruction of Gaza, the ethnic cleansing and the oppression of Palestinian life. That it is a political taboo to say so is a product of the ethnostate’s easily observable, asymmetrical influence within the Western political class.
We shall now see why it is a political no‑no to mount a moral opposition to Zionism: the coming shitstorm for the Greens will only demonstrate how effective Israel’s disproportionate influence over empire has become.
“Israel” should always be in quotes because it is illegitimate. It’s pure deception for them to try to claim the name. The legitimate, biblical Israel was destroyed in 70ad. The 1948 version is a counterfeit from satan. Anyone that knows of their founding documents knows this to be true. “Israel” wasn’t even their first choice for a name. They failed two others before passing the name for the purpose of deception. Wake up!
Thanks Caitlin & Tim. In far off better days of the UN when decolonisation was happening, there was a movement to equate zionism with racism. But the same countries which are now supporting a genocide scuppered it.
These countries are now in the dock with zionist, apartheid Israel.
When I was in high school, half a century ago, this was being discussed at the United Nations. I remember talking about it with my history teacher. He thought it was pretty uncontroversial that Zionism was racist.
First, let me state where I am:
- I am a Muslim
- My wife is a Muslim, of Pakistani descent - so I understand a bit about racism
- I am a member of The Green Party
- And I am the very opposite of a nice, latte-sipping, liberal.
- Yes, the fascist, Israeli regime has committed genocide in Gaza & ethnic cleansing in the West Bank
- And yes, the UK government is complicit
- The proscription of Palestine Action is wrong, and an abuse of the Terrorism Act.
- Arresting peaceful protestors who support Palestine is wrong
- Israel should be sanctioned and all arms sales stopped
But... this motion is Corbyn-level* political naivety. It will damage the party's credibility - and thus, diminish its voice. All our voices. The motion achieves nothing. It is pure, (naive), political posturing, that puts a target on the back of the Green Party, and puts its MPs on the back foot. It demonstrates that a politically naive, idealist minority can capture the Green Party agenda. And that is going to damage its reputation.
Yes, I know... that's how democracy works. Unfortunately, the zealots know how to exploit it.
* I pretty much agree with everything Jeremy Corbyn stands for - but he is shite at politics. As is evident from where he now is. You don't "win" at politics by shooting yourself in the foot. Ahhh... Michael Foot. Another politician who stood for all the right things, and... yeah!
I think it is ultimately a supremacist ideology that is inherently racists. Talmudic Jews and/or and especially Zionists base their belief on "Gods chosen people" mythology. Ironically, it's a lot like Nazism. White nationalism's recent incarnation as ''we just want to be masters of our own land" trope is an attempt to disguise the fact that first they will need to ethnically cleanse or outright murder everyone else. No one would actually accept a Zionist as God's message to the world that they are inferior and must bow.
Besides being racist,Zionism eminently serves the interests of imperialism.
To clarify it is not Zack Polanski who made this policy. It is the members. He was not even there when the motion was written and put forward by Palestinian and anti Zionist Jews and other members. The motion was filibustered in the Spring conference and finally was discussed and won yesterday after wrecking motions were voted down.