On Sunday the UK Greens adopted a motion asserting that Zionism is a form of racism, defining the ideology as “an ethnonationalist political project.”
Green Party leader Zack Polanski, who is Jewish, was immediately banned by the Israeli government from entering the nation after the motion was passed.
As you might expect, Israel apologists are presently churning out hasbara trying to spin the new Green Party policy as an evil attack on Jews and arguing that Zionism is actually a perfectly lovely and normal thing that we should all support.
“Zionism is just the belief that Jews deserve a homeland and self-determination,” they’ll claim, often adding a suggestion that the real racists are those who would oppose such a reasonable position.
The problem with these arguments is that they have already been soundly refuted by objective reality. You don’t get to just make up your own pleasant-sounding definition of Zionism when there has been a Zionist state showing us in stark terms exactly what Zionism is for eight decades. Zionism means nonstop apartheid, ethnic cleansing, war, genocide, and abuse. That is what Zionism is. The evidence is in. This is a settled matter.
There is no way to implement Zionism without implementing fundamentally racist policies. As Richard Sanders put it, “If you can work out a way to create an ethnically defined political entity in a territory that, at the start of the process, was almost entirely populated by people of a different ethnicity, without resorting to ethnic cleansing and Apartheid, then you need to tell the Israelis. Because they’ve certainly never worked it out.”
The Palestinian author Mohammed El-Kurd summed it up eloquently with the following anecdote:
“At a recent closed-door meeting in London to discuss BDS with various publishers and writers, a well-intentioned, well-known author asked me if Zionism could hold a double meaning: To some, it is a settler-colonial movement motivated by expansion and racial elimination, and to others it is a movement for Jewish self-determination. ‘No,’ I said. ‘Zionism is best defined by its material manifestations — the most recent being genocide. It is irrelevant whether it could contain multitudes.’ “
In other words, Zionism is what it does. And what it does is visible to the entire world.
There is no argument to be made that Zionism doesn’t necessarily entail racism, apartheid and abuse; if it did, the modern state of Israel would have existed without these things at some point.
If you think racism, apartheid and abuse are bad, then you necessarily oppose Zionism. If you support Zionism, then you necessarily support racism, apartheid and abuse. If you tell me you can have Zionism without racism, apartheid and abuse, then you are simply lying to me. And maybe to yourself as well.
Genocidal apartheid ethnostates should not exist, and it is racist to believe that they should. It’s amazing this isn’t obvious to everybody.
_________________
My work is entirely reader-supported, so if you enjoyed this piece here are some options where you can toss some money into my tip jar if you feel inspired. All my work is free to bootleg and use in any way, shape or form; republish it, translate it, use it on merchandise; whatever you want. All works co-authored with my husband Tim Foley. No generative AI used in any works.
Feature image via Adobe Stock.
"Zionism means nonstop apartheid, ethnic cleansing, war, genocide, and abuse." And worse, Zionists think that they have the right to impose all that because they are "special". Even worse, the US, UK, Canada, Australia and many other countries do not step in to stop any of this behaviour. In fact, many send arms to Israel. It seems that the lives of some do not matter when there is a profit to be made.
Exactly. Kudos to Green Party leader Zach Polanski for naming what is obvious to anyone paying attention.
Any philosophy shows itself by what it does. If I like what a person does, I'll be interested in their philosophy, and the same goes for a state. If it's people are thriving and doing good things in the world, I'll be interested in the philosophy that's guiding it.
When we see what Israel has done and continues to do, there's no other conclusion to come to except that it's a racist ideology.