Jul 20, 2022·edited Jul 20, 2022

Good points made, but as a primatologist I'll mention that chimpanzees are excellent ecosystem engineers, spreading fruit seeds around the forest and generally fitting into their ecology. Unlike consumerist human cultures, they don't wreck their own habitats and their hunting is pretty small-scale. We would actually do well to be more like chimpanzees and less like rapacious planet destroyers.

Expand full comment

You are confusing biology with mother culture, IMO.

We modern industrial "civilised" humans are no longer homo sapiens. Talk to any remnant indigenous humans (homo sapiens!) and they will tell you: we modern industrial "civilised" humans are crazy and our dominant culture (aka "civilisation") is insane. They are really pissed off to be lumped in with us when we begin making this a species problem.

Who's "we"? We are homo colossus, homo economicus, homo rapiens, homo stupidus, homo separatus, homo parasiticus, homo indoorsians, homo domesticates....

Faced with peak everything, The 6th Mass Extinction and climate chaos, we're going to either change hard and fast to a low-tech, light ecological-footprint, local culture, or we're joining the die-off.

This is a cultural crisis. We are "civilised", swimming in an ocean of mother culture, so encompassing, so captive, so inculcated, so indoctrinated, the vast majority can not see it. And it's mostly by design. We've been raised to be energy and ecologically illiterate. This really suites The Powers That Be, who have been actively farming us for quite some time.

The issue is not us as human beings. The issue is us as "civilised" dumb-arsed idiots...city idiots, citiots.

What was needed was a massive cultural revolution 40-50 years ago, before the globalized "growth" and "progress" fetish took off. Now it's really late in the game. I wonder if there are enough waking up who can see? Even this late in the game, we could at least make a difference for whoever gets to survive the collapse, already underway and obvious to those who will look.

"The dominant culture is insane and unreachable, as are most of it's inhabitants. It has a death urge. It is pathological and suicidal. It wants to kill everyone and everything, including itself. And it will do so, unless we stop it."

Derrick Jensen

Expand full comment

A positive message. Lets hope and focus on that.

The trouble in this world is that if you ain't growing, you are dying. The chimps recognize that in their subconscious as does any bacteria on the planet.

Ever try to get rid of toe fungus? The real cure is to wipe out all bacteria in the body almost killing the host.

We are nothing more than fungus on the planet. Despite all of the crap we invent, we are one winter power outage, one volcanic eruption, one little comet, one virus, one giant solar flare from becoming the Walking Dead running around killing each other for some dried rice.

Civilization as we call it is nothing more than some mutant monkeys run by the lowest common denominator, the rich guys.

I will continue to work my farm. I hope and pray for humanity. But we really are too low on the evolutionary scale to really achieve true greatness.

I heard Schwab speak yesterday. It reminded me so much of Hitler speeches. I am flabbergasted that everyone cant see this whole lie.

With Conservatives they tell the evil, then do it. With liberals they tell you a lie and then do the evil.

Expand full comment

I appreciate the vision and the positive conception of humanity. So much work has gone into subverting that, which is really the essence of evil: finding new artful ways to subvert the natural thirst for truth (which children are born with ie curiosity) and often replace genuine spiritual or intellectual investigations with a bunch of fake “imitations” that look like they’re good, but are actually designed to send people off course. The Narrative Matrix is designed to that.

The piece Whitney Webb recently published on the Malthusians’ Revenge is the kind of thing more people should get a chance to read to get a sense of what the enemy is really vying to control, on an epistemological level.


Beyond what people think, the oligarchy concerns itself with how people think. Certain “scientific” theories about the universe are popular and considered the “official line” not because they are true or there isn’t plenty of evidence against it, but because on a deeper fundamental level it upholds the imperial view of humanity that makes it controllable, that makes its story easy to “re-frame” in a way that shapes our imaginations, and consequently, the kinds of ideas we are capable of generating.

“Black-pilled” people are ultimately operating under the pathological assumption that everything has already been decided. But the “New World Order” has failed many times, as in the first try with the “League of Nations.”

Genuinely creative human beings are naturally drawn to the idea of doing the impossible.

Expand full comment

I'm not sure doing away with national terroritories is the way to go. Just as liberty implies the individual has self-determination, the same applies to groups; and we area very terroritorial species. The alternative is basically globalism, which is why the globalists are so intent on breaking down borders and transferring national sovereignty to their own hands.

Which doesn't mean nations necessarily have to fight. However, even when they do, having governance distributed as widely as possible is far preferable to concentrating it within one planetary polity. Even if the latter starts with good intentions, it's a singular point of failure that can easily be captured by bad actors. A redundant, localized governance system is more chaotic and less efficient, but far more resilient against tyranny.

Expand full comment

At the risk of being trite, hope is a revolutionary act. This has never felt more true than today.

Expand full comment

I read most every comment at this venue and I'm here to tell you, there is no hope of ever transcending ourselves. The majority posting here are a thousand times more vicious and ferocious and hateful than any chimpanzee. At least chimpanzees don't have pet cats.

Expand full comment

While I don’t believe we descended from apes (I wasn’t there), I do believe we have a God given responsibility to be stewards of the planet. We’ve done this poorly, particularly through the industrial revolution. It’s greed, simply. Wars are about greed. The call to better stewardship of the planet is always important.

Expand full comment

In THE CHALICE AND THE BLADE, Riane Eisler predicted a shift from the patriarchy (she called it the “dominator model”) to a collaborative model, as you suggest here. I’ve held to that vision since I read it many years ago. I dare say we are in the transition now, which explains the crazy times we are moving through. The “dominators” can’t navigate the shift and are desperate to hold on to the old ways. But it is inevitable. We just need to hold on.

Expand full comment

Humans are just another mammalian species on the planet, we don't like to think of ourselves as part of the greater natural world but regardless of what we want we are part of that larger system. I remember watching rabbits do the very same thing, over producing because of a lack of predators, millions of rabbits were culled and still the numbers were uncontrollable until natural took over, disease and famine wiped out massive numbers, much more than humans could manage.

Nature is a system with checks and balances and humans like any species are subject to that balance, the eco warriors are just as ignorant as to their side effects of their actions. The above mentioned rabbit horde was caused by the elimination of predators by humans. The restoration of predators has resulted in a healthy balance in the system.

The Savory institute has shown clearly that the destruction of vast herds of grazing hoofed animals has led directly to desertification, we have caused climate change not by burning fossil fuels but by eliminating all of the wild life that kept the system in balance. Fish stocks being decimated is shifting the oceans balance, decimation of millions of buffalo has led to destruction of grass lands.

In the end the academic environmentalist is a threat to the planet as much as the rancher, farmer, hunter or oil driller.

Expand full comment

Keep ‘em coming, Caitlin. I really appreciate your writing talent, sardonic humour and powerful insights. I tell everyone I can to read/listen to your work.

Expand full comment

I really appreciate this perspective, but also appreciate the fact that I have The Kinks Apeman stuck in my head now!


Expand full comment

Since childhood, I've felt like our species is on the cusp of a spiritual quantum leap, much as you've described so eloquently. I think there are millions of us globally who've had this feeling.

I have also felt that I am destined to witness this event, and it sure does feel imminent.

Expand full comment

The analogy with other primates in the relevant sense is unsound.

Expand full comment

I think people have different abilities to raise their consciousness. Unfortunately psychopaths are overrepresented in positions of power and these people have no ability (or interest) in doing something that is aimed less at their own than the common good.

In fact, I think the presence of psychopaths and sociopaths is one of the more profound societal dilemmas that we have. These people want power more than most and they suffer under less constraints (empathy, principally) in their pursuit of it, making them somewhat optimized for that goal. In the old days the odd psychopathic leader could do serious damage but he did not threaten life on the planet.

These are not the old days.

Expand full comment

This is her best one yet!

Expand full comment