207 Comments
User's avatar
Feral Finster's avatar

The sociopaths who run things are unimpressed by our cleverness, our word games, our tightly reasoned arguments and close readings of texts, unmoved by facts, logic, evidence or morality, as long as they have force on their side, as long as the cops and army will shoot when ordered to do so.

It's like trying to reason with a schoolyard bully. Truly, this never grows old:

"A WOLF, meeting with a lamb astray from the fold, resolved not to lay violent hands on him, but to find some plea, which should justify to the lamb himself, his right to eat him.

He then addressed him: Sirrah, last year you grossly insulted me.

Indeed, bleated the lamb in a mournful tone of voice: I was not then born.

Then said the wolf: You feed in my pasture.

No, good sir, replied the lamb: I have not yet tasted grass.

Again said the wolf: You drink of my well.

No, exclaimed the lamb: I never yet drank water, for as yet my mother's milk is both food and drink to me.

Upon which the wolf seized him and ate him up, saying: Well! I won't remain supper-less, even though you refute every one of my imputations.

Moral: The tyrant will always find a pretext for his tyranny, and it is useless for the innocent to try by reasoning to get justice, when the oppressor intends to be unjust."

Expand full comment
Melissa Campanella's avatar

I wish every word you wrote was an exaggeration, but it is anything but. It is a reminder for me that not everyone has their eyes open. I have to get out of my bubble because I shouldn’t be shocked that so many are still kneeling on the throne of the Empire, the MIC, supporting Endless wars,& “strikes”(let’s be real, it’s bomb dropping)against those standing with The Resistance. Here as protesters we get police brutality(hello “cop city”), smeared, targeted or just completely ignored. I have to do a better job talking to people, & encouraging BDS. I often say “If you don’t care about the massacre/ethnic cleansing, do you care that we send billions to them every year, while they enjoy free healthcare & college & we have neither in the U. S.?” There’s more than one reason to protest this war(?), no it’s not war, it’s GENOCIDE.

Expand full comment
Fran's avatar

Thanks. I read it. Glad to see people actively protesting. Now you need those in charge of things to listen. Maybe if there is enough of us things can change. Hope so, because what is happening now may wind up the end of things.

Expand full comment
Fran's avatar

I refuse to live with the idea things are hopeless. That's no way to live. I know that I was as active as I could be during the US's many middle eastern wars as were so many and you do feel hopeless, and you realize you didn't stop anything. However that doesn't mean you give up because if you do you sell your own soul, and become one with them. I will never do that. Screw them.

Expand full comment
Feral Finster's avatar

I don't see how hope has anything to do with it.

It just is.

Expand full comment
Fran's avatar

Doesn't mean it always has to be that way, and it changes only if you have hope that it can be different. .

Expand full comment
Steven Marriott's avatar

One brick in a wall

Expand full comment
Fran's avatar

Even when it comes to Gaza. No a lot more has to be done sooner then later, otherwise he will implement his genocide.

Expand full comment
Steven Marriott's avatar

Have a listen to Judy Small sing "You don't speak for .me".

Expand full comment
Feral Finster's avatar

Our hope isn't what makes things different. Life is just a series of temporary expedients, regardless of anything we may wish for.

Expand full comment
Fran's avatar

Not hope alone but without it nothing changes. No one is saying wishing for something will bring change, but trying for it can.

Expand full comment
Feral Finster's avatar

"Act without regard to results." L.N. Tolstoi

Expand full comment
jamenta's avatar

"How can the 'civilized nations' repeatedly rationalize the invasions of another's land and culture by bringing their own unacknowledged heart of darkness to them? The simple truth is: It is easy. All one has to do is find a 'reason'."

~James Hollis, #GPBT #p135 #Jung

Expand full comment
Feral Finster's avatar

"The tyrant will always find a pretext for his tyranny." In Japan after WWI, there was a schoolyard ditty to that effect, that the great powers of the world preached about law and justice, but they ignore them whenever they saw fit at the moment, because the only real law is force and fraud.

Expand full comment
Fran's avatar

So, as an individual what do you do? Nothing,since you realize your input often means nothing, or do you continue to try because that is only way you don't lose your soul as well.

Expand full comment
Feral Finster's avatar

L.N. Tolstoy said that you act, regardless of outcomes.

Expand full comment
Fran's avatar

l

Expand full comment
ChazLB's avatar

As long as you always remember to sign and date the tax checks..they can steal your labor and energy through your blood sweat and tears right out of your body and build bombs to rip others apart with and channel the profits to the top of the control pyramid that enslaves you.. Hurry run get that pen and checkbook it's your civic duty now to be taxed without representation,,,, sheep.

Expand full comment
Feral Finster's avatar

Democracy, as a practical matter, is basically an exercise in passing the buck, in avoiding responsibility.

Everyone in power claims to answer to and derive their authority from someone else, going ultimately back to "the people" who themselves do not directly exercise power, and who would find it difficult to exercise as a collective action problem, even if they had the formal authority to do so.

What this means is that real power is often in the hands of unelected bureaucrats, who typically don't even want to stand for election because they don't want the voters to know what their programs are, much less to exercise any oversight. Robert Moses is the classic example here.

Even that minimal level of scrutiny is too much for some, and real power is often exercised by people not formally part of any government structure. Corporate lobbyists or Robert Kagan come to mind.

Note how western politicians and their policies are all incredibly unpopular, but they claim to be acting on a popular mandate.

Expand full comment
Bill Hull's avatar

Robert Moses has a huge "mountain" of river sediment unofficially named after him on the south shore of St. Lawrence "Seaway." During the construction of the "Seaway," many people lost their homes and farms, including some historic landmarks. Those that tried to stop the destruction were put down by Mr. Moses as 1950s-era "deplorables."

Another interesting aside: the destruction of the Nord Stream pipeline occurred on Robert Kagan's birthday in 2022.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Mar 4, 2024
Comment removed
Expand full comment
Veritas's avatar

Consider how the Pacific Railroad precisely enabled the final nail-in-coffin Native American genocide.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Mar 4, 2024
Comment removed
Expand full comment
Joy in HK fiFP's avatar

Perhaps not that raiiroad, in exactly that way, or at that moment. We don't have to reject something even as we reject how it was accomplished. If it is truly good and needed, there may be a better way.

Expand full comment
Veritas's avatar

To whom ought your questions be addressed, JohnZ? Me? Or the People who'd lived on the land for time immemorial?

Expand full comment
Debbie's avatar

#3 - those with power over significant projects & ego motivated have little regard for how their actions impact anyone or anything else.

Prejudice/Bias/Exceptionalism makes those neg consequences exponentially worse because the powerful sees neg consequences as a feature not a bug

Expand full comment
Bill Hull's avatar

Hi John,,

To the best of my knowledge, the 19th-century canals around the rapids in the St. Lawrence River could have been enlarged to allow ocean-going ships; and perhaps several smaller power dams could have been built. I have heard that the gross destruction of the communities along the river was due to the United States wanting to build a bigger dam than one that had recently been built on the Nile River (as I recall), perhaps by Russia (as I recall).

The people who lost their homes and farms through eminent domain received a pittance (so I have been told). Many were given a short time to pack up and leave - one newspaper report tells of a family that just got in their car and left - never looking back.

A few years ago an author in Canada interviewed people who had lived in the "Lost Villages" destroyed by the Seaway. She found many who had never spoken about it in over fifty years, similar to those who were displaced by a war.

Expand full comment
Debbie's avatar

Katrina? The levies? Hmmm

Expand full comment
notBob's avatar

Can you agre that the form of government is irrelevant ? Democracy, dictatorship, monarchy, republic it is all irrelevant camouflage to the tyrant. The bureaucrats are the same regardless of the formally declared government style.

A communist bureaucrat is indistinguishable from a democratic one.

Expand full comment
Feral Finster's avatar

Learn well The Iron Law Of Oligarchy and its corollary, The Iron Law Of Institutions.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Mar 4, 2024
Comment removed
Expand full comment
notBob's avatar

No Thanks. I have acquired a distaste for quisling half measures and trivial statements, they seem to be the fall back for statists.

Expand full comment
Feral Finster's avatar

Another favorite trick is for a functionary to wear two hats and switch them as convenient.

The classic example is how Sheriff Buford could proclaim himself to be the law in dis heah county when it came to arresting civil rights protesters on any pretext, but just a private citizen exercising his constitutional rights when it came time to address the local Klan meeting.

Expand full comment
Bakelite72's avatar

Thank You for mentioning Robert Moses! -- I agree, his story is an excellent example of how real power works behind the dressy curtain of "democracy"; I urge everyone to read Robert Caro's masterful study "The Power Broker" (and as with ANY book, make sure you get a copy published before 2010, if possible).

Expand full comment
Joy in HK fiFP's avatar

I saw a documentary called "The Opera Hoise," by Susan Froemke. It made very clear what a destructive, and tyrannical force Moses was, as well as bringing Lincoln Center into existence. We really do need to find better, more human, community-centered ways to make stuff happen, just like the railroads, the airports, the Chavez Ravines, et.c.

Expand full comment
Debbie's avatar

Your point applies to corporations, churches & a family with more than one child or pet equally. We in a society must hold ourselves, institutions, and individuals there accountable and support each other when we can’t trust those with power over us.

Expand full comment
ChazLB's avatar

All of it goes back to the dynasty family banking oligarchs and they probably grew out of every royal family and rich fuck that colonized the planet.. these Euro Anglos have been stomping on the face of indigenous peoples for centuries.. add the whole middle eastern roman christian Jewish supremacist and there you have this whole world of opulent sociopath cunts living off all our backs and blood!

Expand full comment
Feral Finster's avatar

Far as I can tell, it goes back more to power than money. The Kagans of this world don't exactly live in sybaritic luxury.

Expand full comment
Dorothy's avatar

Thank you for this essential essay. I do what I can as an elder. Teetering on the edge of nihilism, your work is one of few things that keeps me going.

Expand full comment
peta's avatar

Thanks to a fellow elder. I’m in the same boat my friend!!

Expand full comment
Veritas's avatar

See the current Billboard for Peace in Times Square, styled after John Lennon's WAR IS OVER Billboard of 1970. The Pentagon has admitted that the Peace campaigns of the early 1970s did bring an earlier end to the Vietnam War than intended. Now see the work for the CEASEFIRE and prevention of ALL wars of ALL kinds: www.JohnLennonReturns.com . Actions appear on the site.

Expand full comment
ChazLB's avatar

I have never seen any protest actual dissuaded any government obsession with war. They just say that shit now to pretend that they had been wrong then so they wont look like cunts now ..this is all bull shit to make people think they have a say today...yeah go protest and get it out of your little systems.. unless you hit them in the money belt they will never stop tricking you into the big protection racket pyramid scheme..

Tax revolt or remain slaves..

Expand full comment
jamenta's avatar

Having the talent and written voice and growing popularity Caitlin has does come with that unavoidable sense what one says can effect people profoundly (good or bad). Reminds me of something Robert Redford once said about his own growing stardom:

“I never trusted success... Early on, when movies like ‘Butch Cassidy’ put a huge spotlight on me, I ran from it. I never fell into the traps of having an entourage and being surrounded by yes-people. It never interested me to do Leno or go to parties, and I think that served me.” ~Robert Redford

Expand full comment
Mary Wildfire's avatar

YES. The Democrats actually don't like it when they have all three Houses, because then they have to awkwardly explain why they can't deliver on any of their promises to their base, instead of simply point to the Republicans. The PTB don't like Trump because he's such a loose cannon, but they managed him for four years once. And YES, we can change things once we have the people--or a hefty percentage of us--united, but they requires a lot of education, a lot of deconstruction.

Expand full comment
Sam's avatar

Bingo! And it’s why when democrats do hold all branches of government they also always have a rotating villain. During Clinton’s tenure it was Ben Nelson. Obama had Joe Lieberman and Biden has Joe Manchin. And if they fail there are many house democrats that will fail in life to derail the agenda. Biden even used the parliamentarians who has no power.

Expand full comment
ChazLB's avatar

Managed and manipulated ...Netty and Kushner had him wrapped around their fingers and all these Trumpeters still can come to grips with that because of their blind hero worship..

Expand full comment
Pxx's avatar

still shouldn't vote for him

Expand full comment
Medical Truth Podcast's avatar

The FIX is in and has been for decades!! Both parties stink!!

Expand full comment
Feral Finster's avatar

Also, a few years ago, there was a "leak", supposedly from a Capitol Hill area pharmacist, to the effect that multiple Congressional leaders, Team D and Team R, were taking Alzheimer medications.

Said disclosure appears to have been memory-holed, and I have no idea whether or not the leak itself was genuine, but I do believe that a lot of the political leadership are senile.

n.b. stupid autocorrect.

Expand full comment
Sam's avatar

Feinstein, Pelosi, Mitch the Glitch, ect.. Grassley is 90!

Expand full comment
notBob's avatar

I recall working on projects in D.C years ago, how walking into the Capital building there was a big Cadillac parked on the sidewalk, my companion for the day said oh don't worry thats M. Waters car, she always parks on the sidewalk because she doesn't know where she is.

Expand full comment
Feral Finster's avatar

Lexus and Vovan did a hilarious prank on Waters, getting her to call for the invasion of a non-existent country to prevent Russian influence from spreading there.

For that matter, it was an open secret that Dianna Feinstein had severe dementia in the the years before her death. Hell, her daughter wanted a guardianship over her because she was that incompetent, but she was still nominally in the Senate.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Mar 4, 2024
Comment removed
Expand full comment
Feral Finster's avatar

Demonstrating their manifest senility mere underscores this.

Expand full comment
Klonda56's avatar

The U.S. is not a democracy. That’s why it doesn’t matter which of the two big party you vote for.

https://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-echochambers-27074746

Vote for anyone except the corrupt two parties. Or don’t vote b

Expand full comment
Jack Large's avatar

A propos this post, I'm halfway thru Ep2 of 4 of the docuseries, "American Conspiracy" on Netflix. Spooks galore. Check it out, all four episodes. Handle with care. It isn't a journalist-safe zone.

Expand full comment
Sol Sön's avatar

Vote for Caitlin

Expand full comment
jamenta's avatar

lol Well she's Australian. Lives in the land down under, where women glow.

Expand full comment
Sol Sön's avatar

Perfect

Expand full comment
Penelope Prill's avatar

You, Caitlin Johnstone, and George Galloway give me real hope. Thank you!

Expand full comment
Sari Tähtinen's avatar

Thank you Caitlin🙏

Expand full comment
Philip Mollica's avatar

And every time someone tells you that you need to save democracy, what they're really saying is you need to save their asses.

For Democracy cannot be lost if you never had it.

Expand full comment
Min Molloy's avatar

Totally agree and already in my community in the UK we are refusing to

vote for the two main party candidates and have vetted and selected our own

I am actively encouraging via social media others to do the same. Our Labour opposition party under Starmer in also under the thumb of the USA and Israel

Gaza is the tipping point of enough is enough

Expand full comment
jamenta's avatar

I find George Galloway from the new Worker's Party becoming an MP a bit of ray of sunshine. I know he's controversial for some, but he is unequivocal about the Gazan genocide.

Expand full comment
Jane's avatar

He’s only controversial because he has been standing for Gaza and Palestine for decades, and been smeared accordingly.

Expand full comment
jamenta's avatar

Tony Blair booted him from Labor because of Galloway's opposition to the Iraq war. I still remember watching Galloway in action during a US congressional hearing - where he told US representatives to their face - that the entire WMD's farce was a pack of lies. Galloway was so impressive back then that it remains etched in my memory even now.

It will be interesting on how they will work hard to smear him and whether it will succeed or not. The corrupt parties (the effete Elite and Corrupt Establishment) have control of UK's mainstream media outlets and have a loud megaphone, and if they can find something to smear Galloway on - which they were successful with Corbyn, they will most certainly exploit it to the hilt. Sunak is finished as PM (he and his party just don't know it yet) - his circus like appearance the other day in front of 10 Downing street finished him. But that won't stop the Established powers from marginalizing Galloway as much as they possibly can in the coming months ahead. The first way which is now obvious - they will come at him labeling him "divisive" like he and the public support he has are children who are not behaving. And that as soon as you complain about any of these despicable immoral people who now inhabit two cheeks of the same backside in parliament - you will be labeled as a supporter of Putin, a divisive figure or an anti-semitic by these same miscreants. But I think the gig is coming to a close to the rampant corruption - given just how much Galloway won his seat, quite a mandate - and how fed up the UK populace has become - especially with this ongoing genocide in GAZA. One can hope it is. We shall see.

Expand full comment
Jane's avatar

The great thing about Galloway is his incredible oratory. No one has a better or cheekier way with words. He’s unparalled and highly entertaining. Years with a talk radio show probably honed that skill. He’ll say what needs to be said in the HoC.

Expand full comment
jamenta's avatar

George really is next level. You just don't see people with his quick wit, keen intelligence, and oratory skills every day - they are once in a generation type individuals. It will be sad if they figure out a way to get the best of him - and they will pull out all stops (methinks) to do so in the coming months. Galloway will need as much support as he can get from the general public, and those who are in the political class - who have enough sense that the GAZA genocide must be a red line for us all, and that Sunak's clownish speech the other day - is quite ominous to the general human rights of all people within the UK. No one should stand for it - and hopefully Galloway will bring that point home with the majority of the British people on his side.

Expand full comment
Chang Chokaski's avatar

Focusing on oratory is what got Obama elected (similar to Bill Clinton). Public personas is one thing. Policies, ability to make deals and compromises, and navigate constant conflict scenarios and environments is quite another.

There is a long and storied history of media personalities winning elections due to popularity. Examples: Reagan, Trump, Zelensky (Ukraine), Imran Khan (Pakistan), Schwarzenegger, the list is endless.

List of actor-politicians (international):

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_actor-politicians

Having said that, almost anyone is better than Sunak, and I do like George Galloway's stances on foreign policy and geo-politics, but do find him conservative in many areas.

Expand full comment
Veritas's avatar

Why speak of "enough" genocide? Really.

Expand full comment
Joy in HK fiFP's avatar

I took the expression to mean:Enough of this horror. End to war-mongering BS. Stop, already!

Expand full comment
Basil Rathbone's avatar

It's why I've said for years, Don't vote! Don't participate in a rigged system in which you can never win or benefit in any way. Both wings of the Uniparty don't want you to ever understand this. Stop being bamboozled.

Expand full comment
jamenta's avatar

By voting, you give a very corrupt electoral process a legitimacy it no longer deserves. I agree.

Expand full comment
The Revolution Continues's avatar

If you vote for alternative candidates, you mess with the heads of the oligarchy. Keeps them confused and off-balanced. Once they're in a state of confusion, then we attack and bring out the guillotines...

Expand full comment
jamenta's avatar

I think I'm beyond that point and have reached the guillotines part. But I understand what you're saying.

Expand full comment
ChesterView's avatar

The collapse of the dollar, now only a matter of time, will do the job of waking people up. That will not be a happy time and the unhappiness will be visited on the powers that be.

Expand full comment