142 Comments
User's avatar
Mike Hampton's avatar

Three cheers for Palestine Action. Three boos for Biden.

Indu Abeysekara's avatar

I am running out of words for the ignominy of it all... but Caitlin has words for all of us. Our horror, frustration, hopelessness in a wicked, wicked world gone mad, the empathy we have with the suffering of the Palestinians are reflected and given voice powerfully, always with a generous heart by Caitlin.

Les's avatar

"I am running out of words . . . ".

For the words you ran out of . . . https://les7eb.substack.com/p/genocide-and-economics

A Parseeker's avatar

In Gaza Unsilenced, co-edited by the late Prof Refat Alareer who was murdered by Israel in Dec 2023, there are documented reports of IDF soldiers placing women and young children in windows and shooting out from behind them. So, it’s the IDF that uses women and children as human shields.

You’re so right, Caitlyn.

Jonathan Reece's avatar

Yes, that last paragraph is so cogent. This faction have always accused their "enemies" of doing what they do, or are about to do.

David Avenell's avatar

Otherwise known as 'The pot calling the kettle black'. Widely used by abusers.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Mar 30, 2024
Comment removed
JennyStokes's avatar

Bollox.

I am sorry Jeano BUT the Holocaust ended in Europe in 1945

In the present time we are watching a Holocaust in Palestine. Years have gone by and please do not tell me that the Israeli people are not complicit!

We ALL have been through hell in our lives I don't know one person who hasn't. IF you put all of us together it would not be dissimilar.

Please tell me why Israel is a country when other countries have similar problems ....out casts in their own countries.......BUT we do not pay attention to them.

There is absolutely NO reason for the Jewish people to have a country.

"Blaming" has nothing to do with this..........yes the holocaust was undeniably horrific BUT is it any more horrific than what the US has done to other countries in the name of greed?

How many people have died in the name of DEMOCRACY?

Take a look at YOUR wars.....S. America/Iraq/Syria etc. Next up Taiwan.

Just sit down and take notice.

Your country is owned by AIPAC.

Too much work's avatar

You don't know. Actually, they are both the same Holocaust, both Hitler and Netanyahu are/were Jewish; should tell you something.

Sam's avatar

And then the world put rules in place so the Holocaust couldn’t happen again. Israel has been ignoring the rules since they went into effect.

Jonathan Reece's avatar

Mmm ... tell that to the people doing it!

User's avatar
Comment removed
Mar 30, 2024
Comment removed
Simon's avatar

Then there was the Russian holocaust prosecuted by the Soviets( not ethnic russians according to Solzhenitsyn) accounting for 20 to 60 million deaths if it could be counted,the Mao holocaust in China 20 million dead, Turkish slaughter of Armenians 1.5 million dead, Pol Pot accounting for 3million Cambodians and of course the Trans Atlantic Empire slaughter in the middle east in the 21st century.

Apparently there is only one holocaust we need to be constantly reminded about and one that can be atoned for by enacting another holocaust on a largely defenceless people.

Sam's avatar

Reminds me of when Caitlin said that we don’t bomb schools when people take the students hostage so why give Israel a pass for bombing buildings because Hamas is hiding in them.

Caitlin always has the words I can’t find.

George Hazim's avatar

The persecuted can longer lay claim to being victims. They’ve lost the right to hide behind the veil of the holocaust.

Fran's avatar

They should have lost that cover many, many decades before. How about after the Nakba?

Too much work's avatar

Let's see what April Fools Day brings us.

George Hazim's avatar

Not much joy and hilarity I gather!

Too much work's avatar

This bitch who's funding Netanyahu reads every thing I write, and I'm not on this planet on my own behalf, so let's just see on April 1, what happened the day before; the possibilities are literally endless.

Jonathan Reece's avatar

"Never again"?

... meaning genocide or genocide of Jews?

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Mar 30, 2024
Comment deleted
Jonathan Reece's avatar

When does it expire? When they show they've learned from it?

And other mass killings? Do we owe special treatment to the Chinese, Cambodians, Russians, Saxons?

Levi Tate's avatar

Israel was in possession of Hamas' Oct 7th jail break plan a full year before.

The entire political/intelligence/military leadership read Hamas' plan.

Israel recognized that Hamas' written plan for Oct 7th could not succeed without Israel's help.

Several months before Oct 7th Israel limited access to the information gained from monitoring Hamas' hand-held radio network to a select few insiders.

Israel claims that they stopped monitoring Hamas' hand-held radio network altogether, no one was monitoring (nonsense!). With this monitoring, sophisticated equipment could have pin pointed where Hamas was concentrated and where it was headed. This is huge! Also, Hamas radio traffic would have become volcanic during the jail break, establishing a major Red Alert.

Of course they have to make the excuse that they no longer had this ability. They need to cover up Israel's own assistance in the Hamas Oct 7th attack. They need to claim Israel was blinded as their surveillance cameras were sabotaged by Hamas. Note, though, with the push of a few buttons Israel could have disabled the surveillance themselves, so taking Israel's word on who brought down the surveillance cameras in actuality is suspect. Also, if indeed key surveillance cameras were taken off line by Hamas that itself would set off a Red Alert!

In the weeks and months before Oct 7th Israel had to intentionally ignore the alerts being sounded by border watchers.

They had to give a thumbs-down to written reports by intelligence officers

warning of an imminent Oct 7th (this happened!).

They had to ignore that Hamas had been trying to lull them into complacency (Hamas had detailed in writing how they would cause complacency. It was in the Hamas Oct 7th plans, and Israel read them).

******They had to remove the vast majority of the IDF troops surrounding Gaza just in time for Oct 7th.****** This was paramount, if Israel wanted Oct 7th to be successful!

Once the jail break was under way support troops had to be delayed for hours. (They refuse to explain

why this happened, stating that they will "investigate" only after Hamas is defeated.)

They had to implement the Hannibal Directive in order to achieve maximum civilian casualties.

The confluence of too many huge failures and too many horrible decisions

to be a credible accident, it was premeditated.

Israel betrayed and slaughtered their own and then commenced to commit Genocide.

-------------

https://archive.is/9msVK

"IDF Allowed Rave Later Attacked by Hamas Despite Key Officer's Concern"

"During the days preceding the massacre, the system had received warnings that Hamas would try to attack on Israeli soil. The information was based on several sources who noticed alarming preparations by Hamas personnel, as well as intelligence that raised the concern growing among various security figures.

Haaretz has not been able to verify whether Lt. Col. Fogel was aware of this intelligence, or whether his opposition to the event was related to it.

Then came Oct. 7. Hours before the terror attack, the security establishment received signs and warnings leading to its decision to prepare – if only partially – for a terrorist incursion. But no IDF officer updated the thousands of revelers or the rave organizers of the fear of an attack, or demanded that they break up the party and leave the area."

Recalling that Israel had been in possession of Hamas' detailed plans for Oct 7th and they had it nearly a full year before Oct 7th. Detailed. Israel knew the Rave was in the danger zone, but the Rave was relocated to within 3 miles of the Gaza wall. People in Gaza could hear the Rave taking place.

Fran's avatar

I also believe Israel knew about the attack beforehand and let it happen. On the UNZ Review, Johnathan Cooke published the following article: "We Were Lied Into the Gaza Genocide.

al Jazeera Has Shown Us How"

He makes the following commentary in regard to the theory Israel knew beforehand of the impending attack by Hamas and let it happen.

"Second, the documentary undermines the conspiracy theory that Israeli leaders allowed the Hamas attack to justify the ethnic cleansing of Gaza – a plan Israel has been actively working on since at least 2007, when it appears to have received US approval.

"True, Israeli intelligence officials involved in the surveillance of Gaza had been warning that Hamas was preparing a major operation. But those warnings were discounted not because of a conspiracy. After all, none of the senior echelons in Israel stood to benefit from what unfolded on 7 October."

I saw the documentary and that wan't my perspective, since I didn't feel they posed any opinion on this issue. His explanation doesn't really substantiate his conclusion.

https://www.unz.com/?CommentOrder=ASC

Sam's avatar

I disagree with Jonathan on that too. And remember that Israel moved the bulk of its troops to the West Bank just before the attack and it took hours for them to get back to the area.

Israel’s own security told them that Hamas had been seen at the border for weeks, but they were told to shut up about it. Of course Israel knew. My big question is were they working with Hamas to make the event happen? Bibi had been funding Hamas for years. Yeah I’m this cynical.

Fran's avatar

Don't forget Egypt's warning a day or two before, and they would know, and of course once again that warning was dismissed. I find that most people covering this topic don't go there unless they be called a conspiracy nut which is always the charge leveled at people who don't follow the official narrative. I know that Bibi enriched Hamas because he did not want a two state solution and neither did they, I wasn't really paying attention to the news to any great extent back in the 1990' but knew what was going on. I remember Yitzhak Rabin's wife blamed Netanyahu for her husband's death due his extreme rhetoric against a 2 state solution. He put on a mock funeral for Rabin and walked behind "his casket" spouting his rhetoric, which did inspire someone to kill him. When Hamas was in office by 2006 or 2007 Netanyahu cultivated them with millions and millions which came their way through Qatar since neither wanted a 2 state solution. I suppose the money no doubt was to make the Palestinians happier in their cage. I don't think he was working with Hamas, but interesting that Hamas thought they could be so blatantly open about their activities. I really don't get that especially since Israel had their detailed plans the year before. If you read Netanyahu's rhetoric after his win in 2022 it is so inflammatory when it comes to his plans for the West Bank, like listen man we're taking over, that it's hard to believe that was not his plan for Gaza as well.

Too much work's avatar

All the Israelis that died in the first two attacks; Hamas and the IDF's response to it; Bibi was going to have killed anyway; so no love lost there.

Too much work's avatar

I've met both Netanyahu's family and the bitch that's paying for this genocide personally. The latter is definitely a very sick person.

Mike McElfresh's avatar

In my discussions with Israelis, I have little doubt that they consider themselves victims. That Israelis treat Palestinians in such uncivilized ways, and believe that they are superior to them, has shocked me since I first saw it. Israelis seem to think it is their place to punish Palestinians as they see fit as deterrence, i.e. to keep the Palestinians in their place. The World needs to finally do its job and bring Israel into alignment with what we call civilized today. This should include complete accountability for the Gaza revenge killings, i.e the mass slaughter and genocide Israel and the US government is perpetrating.

Levi Tate's avatar

Psychopaths and narcissists and Israelis all share something in common.

They never do anything wrong in their own eyes. And if you point out their bad behavior they are genuinely puzzled as they cannot ever do wrong. Thus it must be something wrong with you -- therefore, "antisemite!!".

https://www.unz.com/article/israels-biblical-psychopathy/

Too much work's avatar

That's what I said in a private email to my sister last night and within hours the whole starvation bit was back on again

John Day MD's avatar

The Israel lobby is fractured, and so at last is the Jewish community

The Palestinian genocide is providing a moment of reckoning for the Jewish community.

https://mondoweiss.net/2024/03/the-israel-lobby-is-fractured-and-so-at-last-is-the-jewish-community/

'Israel' seized 50 square km of Palestinian land in 2023: Report

https://english.almayadeen.net/news/politics/-israel--seized-50-square-km-of-palestinian-land-in-2023--re

​ Security Council ceasefire resolution brings ‘little hope’ to Gaza as Israeli genocide rages on

​ It has been nearly a week since the UN Security Council’s ceasefire resolution, but little has changed in Gaza. When the resolution first passed with a U.S. abstention, it was met with Israeli protests and gave rise to the perception that, this time, Israel would be beholden to the UN. That turned out to be a fantasy, provoking discussion on whether the UN system has any real influence over what happens on the ground.

​ For one thing, airstrikes continued in Rafah, and the assault on al-Shifa hospital has entered its twelfth day. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu suspended the Israeli delegation that was supposed to meet with Biden in Washington before agreeing to reschedule the visit. The White House, for its part, said that the Biden administration hadn’t changed its position towards Israel’s war and that the resolution was “non-binding and has no impact on Israel’s capacity to go after Hamas.”

https://mondoweiss.net/2024/03/security-council-ceasefire-resolution-brings-little-hope-to-gaza-as-israeli-genocide-rages-on/

Israel Mounts Largest Attack On Syria In Years, Over 40 Dead

https://www.zerohedge.com/geopolitical/israel-mounts-largest-attack-syria-years-over-40-dead

Jonathan Reece's avatar

Yes, recent events re. the ignoring of the UN resolution just clarify the pecking order.

If you have children, and aren't concerned about them getting drafted into the latest meat-grinder, I suggest you become more aware of the nature of modern warfare.

It has the WW1 analogue of the then new Ford assembly line; plus the explicit moral bankruptcy of WW2, when "we" carpet-bombed civilians; plus the efficacy of modern weapons.

The spotting from balloons of WW1, and the aerial photography of WW2 has become drones and AI-analysed satellite and thermal imagery.

The modern equivalent of V2s have GPS precision and real-time informed guidance.

You should also look at how easy it has been, historically, to change the group-think attitude of being pro peace and staying out of the war, to the opposite. In WW1 and 2 they had the radio; in WW3 they have brain-entraining TVs and tailored group-think on social media.

Too much work's avatar

It would be a whole lot better in the eyes of the world if the Jewish community took care of this themselves, than if an outside entity had to step in. Netanyahu's financer knows exactly what that entity would be.

JennyStokes's avatar

I have a question: Why is it that Israelis/Zionists have their own country?

Why is it that these people cannot fit in anywhere in the world like others do?

Why not make a Tamil Country in N. Sri Lanka for the Tamils who have been used and abused for generations?

There are other people who live in small enclaves around the world who have no rights.

I am sick of this.

Get rid of Israel

Too much work's avatar

Israel isn't really for the Jews, It's for Criminals to hide out in, so that no single State can issue a warrant for their arrest; the Israelis are just for cannon folder. Not really free at all, no choice mostly

Jonathan Reece's avatar

Yes, look at the Israeli "vaccine" programme, and aftermath.

Chang Chokaski's avatar

>>"Why not make a Tamil Country in N. Sri Lanka for the Tamils..."

There are many Tamilians in India. They also have a state called Tamil Nadu (I am assuming you know this). The real issue is basing a country on "ethno-nationalism" - which is what Israel is doing, and which is also what India is currently doing with the Modi regime and the Hindutva ideology (which is similar to the Zionist ideology).

>>"Why is it that these people cannot fit in anywhere in the world like others do?"

Jews do fit in - they do so in the US, in Canada, and many other places in the world. It is the Europeans (mainly) that have had a problem with Jews for thousands of years. The original sin lies with Europeans.

JennyStokes's avatar

Ethno Nationalism yes is wrong.

We have millions of Israelis here in Europe as well as other countries.

No reason for them to have a contry.

Tamils have lived in SL for thousands of years and depending on what History book you choose to read were there before Buddhism arrived.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Mar 30, 2024
Comment removed
JennyStokes's avatar

I know this BUT since this Holocaust there should be NO Zionist state. If any sensible? politician can't see this I don't know what to say.

Israel will continue it's wars on Syria/Lebanon etc.

Israel has to be nullified!

Too much work's avatar

That's why if the Zionists don't take down their fearless leader themselves they will no longer be facing a clueless world.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Mar 30, 2024
Comment removed
JennyStokes's avatar

Nope. My view is rock bottom!

Too much work's avatar

LOL, clueless, but other than that right on.

francis titterton's avatar

Biden is completely on board with the genocide in Gaza, and all his weasel words are just an act. The purpose of destroying Gaza is in order to steal the oil and gas off of Gaza's coast, so they don't have to buy it off Russia. I believe that Biden may have underestimated the Horror people in west feel and the genocide in Gaza, he probably did not think they would care so much about people who are not white.

Brian Bixby's avatar

Actually there's not that much, reserves of natural gas and petroleum off the coast stretching from Lebanon to Egypt is valued (generously) at $524 billion, most of which is off the Israeli coast. It's in water that's around 600 meters deep, so will be expensive to extract, too. If Israel wants the resources off Gaza they'll just slant-drill to extract it without paying, like Kuwait was doing to Iraq before the first Gulf War.

Israel doesn't need a reason to go into Gaza and slaughter civilians, they've been wanting to do it for years. any natural resources they could steal is just a side benefit.

francis titterton's avatar

Then why is Biden and the EU on board with the genocide? It can't just be racism, this is a vote looser, and it can't just be "guilt" about the holocaust, or they would feel guilty about the Gaza genocide. Is the Jewish lobby that well funded?

Feral Finster's avatar

"Is the Jewish lobby that well funded?"

Yes, although it's more a matter of influence and ability to punish than it is of cash.

Too much work's avatar

It's the money, drug addiction and blackmail. Included J. Edgar Hoover.

JennyStokes's avatar

It HAS to be cash too.

Brian Bixby's avatar

No, it really doesn't make a whole lot of sense, does it? I'm sure part of it is the 'anti-semite' card that they don't hesitate to play on the least excuse, and another part is the Zionist Christian vote here in the US (although that's not really an issue in the EU). The only thing that I can really figure is a whole lot of really nasty blackmail, and since Israel used to be the primary source of both ecstasy and roofies smuggled into the US (may still be, don't know any more) perhaps that makes sense. Once 'deep fakes' get a little better the pols may be able to dismiss any blackmail video and we'll see a change, but for now "seeing is believing".

Sam's avatar

Could be for the canal that Israel wants to build through Gaza. There has been talk about it for some time.

But I think the gas comes into play too. Maybe both things?

Ron Stockton's avatar

Israel is simply an American base in the Middle East. One of many (800?) American bases around the world to enforce the dictates of the empire.

JennyStokes's avatar

The US is simply a Zionist base used to control any country not willing to 'toe the line!'

francis titterton's avatar

Israel is a millstone around America's neck. It is very expensive and makes enemies for the US. The wars in Afghanistan and Iraq were in many ways for Israel's benefit. The only people who benefit from America's support for Israel are the arms manufacturers, not only from America's military aid but from the wars America gets entangled in. Politicians in he US will say that Israel is a strategic asset because AIPAC is paying them to say so. is

francis titterton's avatar

Also, many of those bases are there to protect Israel's interest.

Chang Chokaski's avatar

Simply brilliant article Caitlin Johnstone. Thank you for continuing to expose evil empires and the power elite and the many ways they use propaganda to achieve their objectives and oppress people all over the world.

Contrarian 33's avatar

Thanks Dave,

I have checked out with my jurisdiction as well , but he is a foreign national to two countries....by birth, the USA and by allegiances, subservience and his future comfort and welfare, Israel., of course.

Lots of ways out for him..........

"Nothing to do with me personally because as you should know, it was approved by Congress and they are 86% Israeli controlled"

"Israel just purchased the bombs and for us it was just a nothing more than a commercial sale...for profit."

However, we are checking with Rome to see if he can be viewed there as am anti-Christian sadistic killer and as a result, be ex-communicated from the Catholic faith. So much for humanity.

He is absolutely finished as a human being and soon as a feeble, puppet President. Sadly the deaths before then could be in the many, many thousands with little concern from any of the white, Anglo, Christian countries.....anywhere. Now that is also a crime as well, worthy of legal challenge.

Example....what has Palestine done to Germany and Chancellor Scholtz, for the most obvious example today to justify support for genocide. Look at England, Australia, New Zealand, the UK, France, Canada. What has Palestine done to any of these countries?

Nothing. Just view the photos everyone...starving children, thousands dead, shot and bombed mercilessly by the very same country and supported by Christians, everywhere in Government.

David Avenell's avatar

A foreign national? Then how could he ever become POTUS? There must be be some checks and balances.

Kevin Hammond CMT's avatar

I knew a marine in Kansas City Missouri who said his job in Iraq was to bulldoze mass graves and he still has nightmares to this day.

Elisabeth's avatar

No wonder that soldiers come back deeply traumatized (why can't we understand that young people are just used for the plans of the 'old elite' - never was different of course - greed greed greed - I think it is addiction similar to drug addiction - at least that is what Dr Gabor Mate thinks ...)

BJ's avatar

Quite galling to say the utmost least when it comes to "returning campaign donations" from Jews such as Sam Bankman-Fried, Harvey Weinstein and Jeffrey Epstein. However, when it comes to not only pursuing but then accepting and "retaining donations" from the Israel Lobby, Tom Steyer, Sheldon Adelson, George Soros, Michael Bloomberg, et al they seem to have no qualms whatsoever! Amazing isn't it?

gypsy33's avatar

I thought I’d left, but I couldn’t. I admire y’all too much including our esteemed author.

Ah, Jonathan Gleenblatt, the walking , talking cadaver. “Keffiyahs equal Nazi armbands”… 😂😂😂

If anyone desires to purchase a keffiyah, please contact katiemiranda.com. That’s where I purchased mine and it was made in Palestine. This was several years ago, but she may still be able to procur them. She is an American Jew who converted to Islam and her specialty is fine jewelry bearing Arabic calligraphy. I believe she is located in the PAC NW.

Kevin Hammond CMT's avatar

Interesting event here in San Francisco California today. As I was walking along the pier to my gym this morning I saw a Ukrainian naval vessel docked at the pier. There were about 10 cop cars and about thirty cops on guard and that perturbed me but I kept on walking and went and trained for a couple hours. When I got out of the shower I heard all kinds of sirens.

It turns out that the ship is transporting something to israhell and there was a protest and they tried to breach security and storm the ship! Yahoo! Anyway, I'm curious about what's on that god damned ship. Talk about rubbing salt in the wound!

Too much work's avatar

Probably those 2,000 pound bombs; talk about a rip off. One ton of ammonium nitrate, what's in those bombs cost less than $600, and they charge the US $2 million for them; for what? The packaging?

Levi Tate's avatar

This is an amazing amazing amazing article, it covers the history of Palestine and it's oppressors from A to Z.

"Gaza War: Deceptions, Distortions, Misperceptions. What are the Relevant Actual Facts?"

https://covertactionmagazine.com/2024/03/29/gaza-war-deceptions-distortions-misperceptions-what-are-the-relevant-actual-facts/

Read it 3 times.