75 Comments

Defending the indefensible. Israel's excuses and fabrications hearken me back to adolescence during a summer between sophomore and junior years of high school, the first time I stayed out on NYC streets drinking with friends until 3 or 4 a.m. Returning home and sneaking in the back door only worked for a moment as I was caught and confronted by my dad during the act of massively puking into the bathtub. My face drained of blood, my head pounding, I scrounged every synapse for an excuse, a rationale. But there was none to be had. That's you, Israel, except that my dad ultimately displayed compassion for my plight, a humane emotion completely lacking in your repertoire.

Expand full comment
Dec 7, 2023·edited Dec 7, 2023

Without question, truth will always suffice and always be used when truth furthers your position. Thank you Caitlin for your steadfast adherence to honesty and reason.

Trying to undo the sins of the nation state within the confines of the nation-state concept is likely to be unsuccessful. Part of what I want to do is to encourage more of us to think about new ways to think and act on this issue.

There must be a permanent ceasefire, not with Palestinians suffering under oppressive conditions, but as a place where all live with peace and equality. It is time for Pope Francis to do more than talk. He must go to Gaza and make a stand for peace and freedom.

Please sign the petition and share widely.

https://chng.it/CRQ7qw4Gzn

This is one small thing we can do. If we can do more, let us do more.

Expand full comment

I've been saying this all along.

For that matter, if Ukraine really were having such success and Russia committing so many atrocities, why was it necessary to make so many easily disproven claims?

Hear anything from "The Ghost Of Kiev" lately?

Expand full comment

It seems that over 95% of the Jewish-Israeli population are consumed by hate and paranoia. (Max Blumenthal quotes a new poll where only 1.6% of the Israeli public thinks that the the IDF has used too much fire power.) I wonder if that has anything to do with occupying and oppressing the people whose land they stole, for 75 years?

Expand full comment

If your position was based on truth and morality you wouldn't say bombing 8,000 babies is good actually

Expand full comment

I am presently reading Gad Saad's book , The Parasitic Mind. It is all about truth and freedom and very worth reading. It is a very scary book because the lunatic fringe in our societies ,namely the elites, have decided they decide what truth and freedom is and know full well they can get away with anything. Netanyahu is another monster of our times as he knows this is a time in history when he can commit genocide and get away with it . Like numerous other war criminals he will never see the inside of a court room or the noose he deserves.

Expand full comment

Israel Revokes UN Humanitarian Coordinator’s Visa for ‘Not Condemning Hamas’

https://www.globalresearch.ca/5842388-2israel-revokes-un-humanitarian-coordinator-visa-not-condemning-hamas/5842388

Israel-Palestine war: Israel shut down NGO for reporting rape of teenager, ex-US official says

NGO Defense for Children International's offices were raided after they reported the sexual assault of a 15-year-old by an interrogator while in Israeli custody

https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/israel-palestine-war-ngo-shut-down-reporting-sexual-assault-ex-us

Expand full comment

Fascist hate for the truth and morality. From Biden to Bibbi. Thank you Caitlin!

Expand full comment

Should be as obvious as 2+2.

That it’s not for so many is a jet engine loud testament to the power of the system and its pervasive propaganda techniques, conscious or otherwise….

It heartens me a lot to see just how many younguns are sidestepping it, on this particular issue at least :)

Expand full comment

Amen Sister!!!

Expand full comment

"If your position is based on truth and morality, you don’t need to make up lies to defend it, and you don’t need to hurl false accusations at those who disagree with it... You can defend it in a truthful and moral way, instead of the exact opposite."

Amen! The lies are getting stale and the false accusations are breaking up families, friends, and organizations that could be doing positive things in the world. Stop the lying, Israel propagandists/apologists! It's for your own good. It's for EVERYONE'S good. Stop the bombing, stop the lying, stop the false accusations, call it a day and call a permanent ceasefire. Find what's left of your morality and make the peace stick.

Expand full comment
founding

I was at a store and casually said to a young person, please write to our congress people and the white house to stop the genocide of the Palestinian people. The reply, I am only one person what good would that do? Discussion time : ), I said my emails are half as powerful unless you write also. Eyes blink. I said together we are powerful and the Palestinian people need all our voices. They agree to write. I will not stop asking people to resist genocide. Talking works, Kristina sent me this email.

We met at the rally in defense of Gaza in Chicago in Evanston, my name is Kristina.

I want to invite you to the meeting hosted by the Socialist Equality Party and International Youth and Students for Social Equality this Thursday, December 7 @ 6pm - “The Global Fight Against Israel’s Genocide in Gaza: The way forward” at the Harold Washington Library (Loop/downtown) Meeting Room on the 8th floor.

If you are in the area please attend and support young people standing up : )

Expand full comment

It’s clear that this situation is a propagandized event designed to capture the attention of the masses.

All we can do is awaken people to the illusion being pushed on us and be sure that we’re not giving all our attention to where they want it to go vs putting that attention on our friends, families and loved ones:

https://unorthodoxy.substack.com/p/why-the-average-american-should-stop

Expand full comment

Israel took a turn for the More Monstrous after October 7, clearly. Unfortunately, many people will be confused by Israel's propaganda blitz to confuse all Jews with Israel. Part of the insidiousness of Israel's campaign is that they are in fact trying to stoke anti-Semitism which, in a fit of reverse psychology, somehow justifies all their crimes against Palestinians, who are defined a priori as "anti-Semites"--as if Palestinians weren't Semites themselves, which they obviously are.

Expand full comment

Yes. If your position was based on science you wouldn't have to censor, discredit, demonetise, de-platform or sack anyone who disagrees with you. You would just debate them and show everyone they're wrong and you're right. If your position was based on science you wouldn't have to emotionally blackmail, coerce or bribe people into taking untested and unnecessary medications. If your position was based on science you wouldn't have to constantly reinforce the idea that locking up the elderly, limiting exercise, isolating people from community and preventing hugging were actually saving lives- because anyone with any common sense and/or has read the literature knows that the exact opposite of this is true.

Expand full comment

One person here derided us who post on Caitlin's Newsletter as her echo chamber. If like Caitlin we value truth and justice and compassion - and through her Newsletter - we get to share it with other like minded human beings we are glad to be in her corner.

Whose echo chamber are you in Daniel? It must be terribly uncomfortable in there, to go on justifying the daily killings and destruction wrought by Israel; and the total disregard for any kind of human kindness. Are you sure that you are happy hearing the children cry? I can only imagine how being in there will addle your brain and harden your heart.

Will you be happy if the war expands into Lebanon as Netanyahu threatened this morning? He said - and this was on mainstream news - that he will turn Beirut into another Gaza!

Expand full comment