346 Comments

At this point, we have to assume that all governments and institutions are lying.

Expand full comment

1. If Hamas is behaving so barbaricly, why does Israel present so many fake atrocities?

2. If Israel has so much evidence, why do they present so much fake evidence?

Expand full comment

Not just "at this point," but for decades and decades.

My own heuristics, which has never failed me: The balance of power will always be a reliable guide as to whom to believe and whom to not believe. For the weak have only the truth to cling to. The powerful have force and other means.

Expand full comment

I'm not sure I've ever believed the Israeli government (or the US government), especially since 911. Even before, when I discovered what the Israeli government did to the sailors on the USS Liberty in 1967. What they did to Rachel Corrie showed their true character, savages.

Expand full comment

Sickening. Not sure what can be done to stop this. UN seems completely dysfunctional and the USA vetoes everything. Other than the Houthis, nobody has the backbone to actually stand up to this.

Expand full comment

Israel is a country built on lies.

Lies like Palestine was a country "without a people for a people without a country"; Palestine was "undeveloped"; Palestine was empty, then "settled" by Arab Muslim hordes who emerged from Arabia (vs conversion to Islam after the region was conquered by Arab Muslims in the 8th Century); the Zionists repeatedly offered peace plans in 1947/48, 1967, etc., mostly outright fabrications in that others put forth plans which invariably short-changed the indigenous Palestinians by blocking true national sovereignty AND leaving Jewish settlers in place and constantly expanding. Think the "settling of the West" in US history.

The one silver lining in the current bloody tragedy is that the true face of Colonizer Israel is on display in its manifold raw public declarations and deliberate military actions to exterminate Gaza as a viable society and ultimately ethnicly-cleanse the West Bank of its indigenous population which it has repressed for over 50 years.

The truth is finally emerging to the world in the ashes, in the rubble, and on the bodies of 20,000 Palestinians and counting. The truth is written in the blood of 10,000 Gazan children.

Expand full comment
founding

israel, proof that monsters exist. We need no further proof. My heroes are the Palestinian people and the people of Ansar Allah. Every day I wake thinking how can I go on supporting this genocide of Joe Biden and yet I get up work on an experiment I love and my life's work and continue feeding the monster. Question, outside our building a row of flags. The flag of israel punches me in the face every time I walk into the building, walk into the hall, get a cup of coffee. Should my letter be, raise a Palestinian flag or take down the flag of genocide? Every building should be given notice remove the flag of genocide. A pirate flag would be far more honest. I read Caitlin's brilliant words not expecting to write any of this not wanting to distract others. If only I could reach into the hell of Gaza.

Expand full comment

The past 2 years have seen the most momentous change in the power structure of the world. Accelerated by the proxy war and the world's abhorrence at the treatment of Gaza; China and Russia are now at the top of a growing BRICS alliance increasing in purpose, integrity and economic might as the US and UK (the EU has already been shafted by the US) behave like unhinged lunatics. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DkuKnYdtW9w

Expand full comment

I am wishing everyone a calm Xmas. We have decided to treat it as just another day because I simply cannot think of stuffing myself while people are dying. Just a nice walk along the beach with our dog.

Caitlin have a holiday if you can and thank you for being brave.

Expand full comment

Yes, the default is that all members of the Blob GAE are lying all the time...Israel is a special case, since it has been an outlaw that only exists because of Blob military support, yet it can't go for even one year without committing war crimes that would get another country shunned and ultimately destroyed...

Expand full comment

Just read something pertinent to this:

Egypt is in serious debt. There is a proposal being talked about that Egypt will allow the Palestinians home in the Sinai and the IMF will cancel their debt!

NO NO NO.

I am not a person who believes in fake anything but I AM beginning to wonder if this was the idea in the first place. Israel get more land.

Expand full comment

A country can't lie. Only their illegitimate government can.

Expand full comment

*No Such Thing As a Progressive Democrat*

“No true progressive would be a WILLING member of the corporate owned, corrupt, primary rigging, wall street butt licking, warmongering, genocidal Dem Party!” - Thor Swayze

Expand full comment

The problems in the world today are the Direct Result of US Empire building. So many Americans income is derived at the tax trough. Robbing Peter to pay Paul, you can count on Paul's support. This link is to an International law that both the US and Israel Ratified, it should be enforced with a vengeance; https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convention_on_the_Prevention_and_Punishment_of_the_Crime_of_Genocide

Expand full comment

What I want to do is to encourage more of us to think about new ways to think and act on this issue.

here must be a permanent ceasefire in Gaza, not with Palestinians suffering under oppressive conditions, but as a place where all live with peace and equality. It is time for Pope Francis to do more than talk. He must go to Gaza and make a stand for peace and freedom.

Please sign the petition and share widely.

https://chng.it/CRQ7qw4Gzn

Other petitions, including

Codepink:

https://www.codepink.org/cnngaza?utm_campaign=12_15_pali_update_alert_3&utm_medium=email&utm_source=codepink

Ceasefire Now:

https://www.change.org/p/sign-and-share-this-urgent-petition-calling-for-a-ceasefirenow-in-gaza-and-israel

Signing petitions is one small thing we can do. If we can do more, let us do more.

Expand full comment

A friendly note about your headline: While at war, all nation states (of whatever political leaning) routinely lie about that war. Official statements and associated partisan media should never be read w/o intense skepticism.

Most of mainstream media in the US relies heavily on official and quasi-official Israeli sources for their reporting on the Gaza campaign. This is irresponsible journalism ... except in the sense of the editors being responsible to the State Department’s preferred take.

Expand full comment