Discussion about this post

User's avatar
bardamu's avatar

Beautifully set up in the main, and in the abstract and social points.

I have a secondary point as regards the neurology. Most elements of empathy are mediated by the limbic system. That's why dogs are not less empathic than humans and why crocodiles raise their young. Some aspects of perspective that we sorely need and that are indeed key to what you are talking about require frontal cortical mediation, but these also require limbic involvement. If you impair the connection to the limbic system so that the frontal cortex "runs free," so to speak, you get someone who is clever about perspectives but lacks empathy. They have some idea what others feel, but they themselves are little concerned.

As shows so beautifully in your writing, our centers are soulful, and more so than our peripheries, even within our brains.

Expand full comment
vj's avatar

This piece makes me think of the work of psychiatrist and scholar, Iain McGilchrist and his lengthy analysis of the Left/Right brain hemispheres. His latest books (two tomes) are titled "The Matter With Things" and they look at the complimentary (often contradictory) functions of the left and right lobes. (This is quite different from past ideas about the divided brain.) In a nutshell his theory proposes a necessary, but fraught, relationship between two fundamental cognitive functions--that I would call the "contextualizing function" and the "exploiting function". This is my grossly simplistic interpretation of his scientifically grounded theory, so I don't claim to speak for him with any confidence. But his theory shows how much the dominance of the left hemisphere has affected modern culture and society negativity, leaving behind the hugely important contextualizing aspect of cognition, the pace where things and people (living beings) are interconnected--on all levels. Anyway, you may find him interesting, although I can hardy do his theory justice here. Love your work Caitlin!

Expand full comment
52 more comments...

No posts