53 Comments
User's avatar
Doris Wrench Eisler's avatar

Education and democracy are supposed to make the individual less partisan , more citizens of the world and universe. Not being able to see past your country's self-serving propaganda is nothing to be proud of: it is a weakness. It is in fact a failure as a human being, and ends in the disaster that results from hubris. . .

Expand full comment
russian_bot's avatar

So we have neither education nor democracy.

Expand full comment
Doris Wrench Eisler's avatar

Draw your own conclusions.

Expand full comment
William Paul's avatar

If by citizen of the universe, you mean son or daughter of a loving God, I understand.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Nov 15, 2022
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
bill wolfe's avatar

You twist that comment, create a straw man, misconstrue Chomsky, and then expose your extremely ideological individualism - quite a feat and in so few words!

Expand full comment
Doris Wrench Eisler's avatar

What straw man, what misunderstanding of Chomsky, and "ideological individualism?"If you can't elucidate, your comment is meaningless. But that's no surprise .What the hell do you have to say for yourself?

Expand full comment
Doris Wrench Eisler's avatar

I said education and democracy, as a combo, are supposed to make you less partisan. It is a claim that I did not ratify by any means, but is it not a common claim and the basis of propaganda? "We know better because we are more advanced technologically, materially and intellectually"? I fully agree that many "unschooled" people are not only more intelligent, but better informed than many PHDs. My reference to the Universe is in the post-modern sense that parochial ideas should be measured against a wider background of time and space. It is not literal and grandiose, but poetic.

Expand full comment
Bob D.'s avatar

You had me until the last sentence. I believe it should read “democracy -can- give cover to bad ideas.”

In the absence of democracy, what better system do you suggest? A guaranteed benign dictator, perhaps?

Expand full comment
The Revolution Continues's avatar

" I wonder if my own government is being truthful about its actions in that part of the world? "

I don't doubt that my government is lying through its teeth--especially when it comes to resource grabbing in all parts of the world. Sigh.

Expand full comment
Beli Tsari's avatar

Sounds like an OLD Steve Martin schtick, where he's momentarily AWARE of the insanity of our sneeringly brainwashed, echo-chamber servile obsequiousness & specious suck-up Idiocracy... then goes,

"NAHHHHhhh!"

Expand full comment
Tereza Coraggio's avatar

May I add: Is what I see real or a projection of what I reject in myself? What happens if I don't judge others? Does it enable me to forgive myself? Accept myself? Love myself?

Expand full comment
Al X G's avatar

I wonder if my FTX funds that were wiped out last week helped elect insane Democrat candidates via my government funding an insane proxy war in Ukraine?

Expand full comment
pepa65's avatar

All good questions. But taken together, too much for most people to productively use. People are usually clearest about their core values, the awareness of which helps anchor them. But we do need to dismantle falsehoods in our thinking and beliefs, one by one or clusters at a time!

Expand full comment
Boris Petrov's avatar

THANK you !! - https://thegrayzone.com/2022/11/13/un-envoy-fabricating-viagra-russian/

UN envoy admits fabricating claim of Viagra-fueled rape as ‘Russian military strategy’

By Alexander Rubinstein – Nov.13, 2022 (Note: Hillary Clinton, i.e., the US War party, has established that particular UN envoy (its loudspeaker) position)

Expand full comment
William Paul's avatar

Here are a few more questions:

* What if the vaccines kill some people? The Epoch Times says 100% of the people get some heart damage.

* What if masks are an instrument of social control?

* What if the war against Russia is all about breaking up Russia so we can steal its resources?

* What if BLM's founders all have 5 houses each, now, off of your fundraising, and they don't give a shit about anyone except themselves?

* What if your processed food isn't safe?

* What if the carnivore diet got your relatives off of all their meds, like Dr. Shawn Baker is finding out?

* What if fiat currency is based on nothing, but it's just a way for the tyrants to steal your savings?

* What if big food, big pharma, big government, and big charity are all just scams?

* Why don't public schools teach anything useful? But instead, they just lie to you about history?

* What if Facebook hates you, and that's why they keep all your data and let you sign up for 72 genders?

* What if the tyrants want you to distrust your own body? And hate it? And want you to mutilate it?

If they can make you mutilate yourself...if they can make you lie...then they own you.

They own you.

They want you fat, sick, depressed, poor, isolated, and uneducated. The better to extract all of your economic value from you, and then kill you.

* What if big corporations are pro-environment not because they love the environment, but because you can't face the fact that it's just another one of their scams?

* What if you wanted to beat the tyrants, and started participating in parallel institutions (like smaller businesses, banks, farms, etc.) and you gave up on Big Government?

* What if you always told the truth? Because the tyrants' whole system is based on lies and fear. Don't lie or be afraid.

And watch them blow apart.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Nov 15, 2022
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
William Paul's avatar

Good point. I'll edit the opening.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Nov 15, 2022
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
William Paul's avatar

I appreciate the offer, but I am satisfied with the questions I am posing.

Expand full comment
misc.misc.misc's avatar

My new faves are:

'why do I think that FDR was a great president?'

'how did I arrive at my assumptions about climate change?' (I know that is a loaded question, but more to the point 'is what I think accurate? could the entire narrative be wrong?')

'why did Michael Burry predict that water would become super precious?' hint: see article from 'Our Santa Fe River' - The Great Water Grab: Wall Street is buying up the world’s water. That will keep you up at night.

Expand full comment
Amking's avatar

If only there were free thinkers like Caitlyn in the MSM.

Expand full comment
William Paul's avatar

There are about three, but they are on the right. Make a list of those on the left, please, and post it here.

Expand full comment
Spaulding Showalter's avatar

Powerful. ❤️

And I love the Socratic method. Makes the essay universal and personal at the same time

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Nov 15, 2022
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Spaulding Showalter's avatar

I stand corrected. Either way, like you said, asking questions is great. And I believe makes the monologue universal (based on the questions asked) and personal as I thought back on my own experience to attempt to answer them. 😊

Expand full comment
MISS M NELSON's avatar

Us autistics ADHD aren’t programmable so therefore psychology DSM 5-10 labels us disordered and deficient and tells others to other and treat us as different. I’ve always asked question and said my piece. We are Neuro Divergent. That to me means Different, we aren’t normal. What is normal. Programmed battery chickens is that normal. I like my uniqueness, my differences. Newcastle university is trying to find out why autistics commit suicide. I was going to join them for other research . They had finished and they said they were studying this now. With a fascistic health secretary who prior was DWP ( welfare secretary) that hid the stats. Why would I give that info. She the fascist ableist, will be handed how to get autistics to kill themselves. The battery farmed chickens trust too much. I told the UNI where to go. And said who they would be giving that info too. Just doing our jobs huh.

Expand full comment
Lex Rex, Esq.'s avatar

I love this one. Just keep asking questions.

One of the best meditations I’ve done is, “but what if it wasn’t/I weren’t”.

Ask, “Who am I?” Wait for the response and say, “But what if I wasn’t?”

“I’m a <profession here>.” But what if I weren’t?

“I’m a father.” ...

“I’m a <religious or a-religious leaning here>” ...

“I’m a husband” ...

“I’m a <political leaning here>” ...

Keep stripping away these accidents of your humanity until you get to You.

The ability to peel back the bull shit has been obscured to us.

“But what if it wasn’t?”

Expand full comment
Spaulding Showalter's avatar

Kinda weird that all Trump supporters were banned and are still banned from Twitter. But leftist dissidents are still on Twitter. I like many of them. But why are they scared of honest discourse? Perhaps because they can’t handle honest debate?? Are you scared?

Expand full comment
William Paul's avatar

This really was an excellent article.

Expand full comment
sandi's avatar

Brilliant! Thank you so much. These questions are framed in a way that they can be presented to almost anyone without seeming to be hostile or disrespectful. Thank you!

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Nov 15, 2022
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
sandi's avatar

We're different in that way. I am in my senior years somewhere near the end of this life, and I've found that being kind and doing my best to see the goodness in people - recognizing that I can't account for their past but that they are part of the same humanity as I am - leaves an opening, however small, for us to inch towards understanding. If not today, one day. I speak of daily one on one relationships. Those in the echelons of control who are of mal-intent have their own demons and karma to face. They are trying to prop up structures which are crumbling. I'm looking towards the shoots of a new world being born and I want it to be born of kindness. Kindness doesn't obviate standing grounded and true to one's values.

Expand full comment
HappyHouse's avatar

All the way Caitlin! As we get closer to that Truth we find it is beyond understanding so let go, jump in and see where we go. Harder than it seems..

Expand full comment