Discussion about this post

User's avatar
G.W. Borg (Shadow Democracy)'s avatar

How might we get out of the current mess? For a possible answer, I'll go back to last summer's fit of statue-tipping.

It was as if we collectively slapped ourselves on the head and exclaimed, "Hey, wait a minute! The Confederate generals lionized in the statues were TRAITORS! And they owned SLAVES!! Tear them down!"

But why were the statues there in the first place? There were specific reasons in different places but the general attitude was one of reconciling ourselves to our past and trying to symbolically welcome back into the union (with spotty success) the many southerners who fought for what they regarded (with some justification) as a noble cause. Through the erection of statues and a few other gestures, a somewhat greater peace was achieved than would likely have occurred otherwise.

I see no such impulse in the current environment to acknowledge the frustrations of many Trump voters who feel (with some justification but little fact-based specificity) that they've been trod upon and held in contempt for decades by a heartless corporate and elite establishment in ways that have very little to do with race and quite a lot to do with class. In fact, there seems to be a trend in the opposite direction among the elites, who appear to feel empowered (among other things) by the outcome of the Senate elections in Georgia.

So maybe we need to start thinking about how we can re-erect those statues.

Expand full comment
Stephen Simac's avatar

Sleepy Joe is now being given credit for being the "author" of the Patriot Act- pushed it in the 90's, but was shelved until GWOT was declared. Patriot 2 will be for "domestic" terrorists and liberals will cheer them rounding up white gun nuts and "insurrectionists", until they come for their progressive causes. Most Americans are basically ahistorical, in that they can barely remember yesterday, much less the lessons of history. Look up eco-terrorists and animal rights activists- early FBI targets of domestic terrorists.

Expand full comment
9 more comments...

No posts