314 Comments
User's avatar
GS-z-14-1's avatar

This cannot spare them. Nuremberg ruled that support of said crimes was itself serious political crime. Prosecution cometh.

Expand full comment
Susan T's avatar

There must be money involved, somehow. Trump just accepted a 400 million dollar gift from Qatar. But I hope my cynicism is off and the whole world is really turning against genocide.

Expand full comment
includeMeOut's avatar

Qatar is also the headquarters, if I am correct, for Hamas.

Expand full comment
Victoria Jean Bingham's avatar

Wrong. Tel aviv is the headquarters of hamas

Expand full comment
Gnuneo's avatar

I look forward for when Jerusalem is their capital.

Expand full comment
LaVerne Karras's avatar

Qatar is an Israeli bagman, that was how the Nutty Yahoo sent money to Hamas until they were more useful as an enemy.

Expand full comment
martin's avatar

... hamas, who are the good guys even compared to any westerner in the comments.

Expand full comment
Jennifer Akdemir's avatar

Hamas is still vastly out-gunned by the combined forces of Israel and the US.

Expand full comment
JennyStokes's avatar

So were the Yemeni's!

Expand full comment
Vin LoPresti's avatar

Latest info I hear, Jenny, is that the tech the Yemenis have (likely developed by those brilliant Persians) is pretty hot stuff, that the missile that hit near Ben Gurion was supposed to do just that, a warning shot -- that slipped both Israeli & US defenses. Implication: they might/could flatten the hell outta that airport should they choose. AND the fact that other countries' airlines have indicated reluctance to use Ben Gurion is a gigantic validation of the threat to Israeli Zionazis. Everybody say: "Bravo Yemeni brothers"!!!

Expand full comment
LaVerne Karras's avatar

There isn't as far as I've heard, any serious connection with Iran as far as their tech goes, they are building their own missiles. On the other hand, if it is Iranian technology, that should scare the hell out of the Israelis, they'd have no defence against hundreds of missiles coming in at one time.

Bravo Yemeni brothers!!!

Expand full comment
Landru's avatar

Yes, we in the u.s. are ill prepared for a hypersonic missile landing on the deck of an aircraft carrier. Can you imagine the joy seeing the shame on so many u.s. israeli military/gov. faces. OH JOY : ) With a bit more guidance precession and my dream can come true : ) That is the real reason Yemen is calling the shots with Genocide Don : )

Expand full comment
JennyStokes's avatar

Yes. I did hear that they are quite capable of making their own weapons. Amazing to me that Western Nations think other peoples are not capable!

At this moment I am quite prepared to believe there never was a thing as the Iron Dome.

The only people standing up for the Palestinians apart from Hamas.

Expand full comment
Roslyn Ross's avatar

Actually Hamas and the dozen other factions in the Palestinian Resistance are not because they are real soldiers who know how to fight, not cowards playing with techo drones and dropping bombs from a safe height and shooting toddlers in the head and heart from a distance.

Expand full comment
Roslyn Ross's avatar

FFS next you will be saying that Hamas is causing Climate Change and if the US economy crashes it will be the fault of Hamas???????????

That is the shitraeli catchcry - not my fault, Hamas made me do it. Everything is the fault of Hamas.

Yes I killed those emergency aid workers but Hamas made me do it.

Yes, we made bombs out of food cans so we could watch starving Palestinians, particularly kids, blow themselves to pieces but Hamas made us do it.

Yes I shot that three year old through the head and heart but Hamas made me do it.

Yes I shot that pregnant woman in the stomach but Hamas made me do it.

Yes I raped that Palestinian woman but Hamas made me do it.

Yes I raped that Palestinian man with my gun barrel but Hamas made me do it.

Yes I tortured that Palestinian child but Hamas made me do it.

Yes I tortured that doctor but Hamas made me do it.

Yes I tortured that old woman but Hamas made me do it.

Yes I murdered 232 journalists but Hamas made me do it.

Yes I murdered hundreds of doctors but Hamas made me do it.

Yes I murdered hundreds of thousands of children but Hamas made me do it.

Expand full comment
includeMeOut's avatar

I am speechless, which is fortunate for both of us. Stating a simple fact gets this type of response is a characteristic of the disembodied nature of the digital world we inhabit online. Breathe and slow down, hug your cat and plant a tree.

Expand full comment
Roslyn Ross's avatar

Not quite sure what has upset you but being upset about something someone else says is a choice. The point I sought to make was that blaming someone else for everything is ridiculous. Qatar is probably anyone's bagman and the relationship between Hamas and Israel is more complex than suggested. Israel helped create Hamas because it needed an Islamic enemy and it funded it for the same reasons. As long as Hamas exists, so the Fizzraelis think, they have someone to blame for everything.

Sorry if my point was poorly made.

Expand full comment
includeMeOut's avatar

Thanks, I appreciate the nuanced points you made.

Expand full comment
George Cornell's avatar

Nope.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 12
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
John Turcot's avatar

Free everyone!

Expand full comment
Contrarian 33's avatar

Susan T. Trump will no doubt accept the Qatar gift of an aircraft. At the end of his reign, selling it could assist in the building of the Trump Country Club in Gaza.

However, the gift will no doubt be welcomed by Trump. It would be fair to say that there would be little else other than money, or a personal aircraft, both being extravagant ego trips that would excite a megalomaniac like Trump.

But would that make a difference? He still has to break ranks with Israel and that could be very risky.

One remembers Epstein who died of his own making (let’s continue the Hans Christian Andersen version), Ghislaine Maxwell tucked away securely for 20 years and even more commitments for him to continue the Israel crimes which could be based on such matters.

As I have said before referring to a piece of American history in 1963, Presidents can be assassinated and have been in the past. In that case, a sad event indeed.

Think on this. How could any human being be an enthusiastic partner in the inhumane crimes of Israel without some other motivation….. other than money?

But look. This is what America has to do to return to normal (US normal, that is).

It has to overcome probable 10% of the US population who are connected, controlled, owned by Israel; convince 86% of all the US politicians (AIPAC-owned); subdue the Davos bunch; calm down the City of London bankers and investors (very quiet behind the scenes, names predominantly starting with “R” ); all the European money men (been there for years); entrepreneurs by the score; the Blackrocks of the world; military industrialists who need wars for profits; probably less than 5% of the Western world populations ……..but 100% of Western governments however (such as Australia, New Zealand, Canada, Germany, France, UK); the Israel government including 97% of the supporting population and then,…...90% of the world media, predominantly controlled by and supporters of Israel / US crimes.

Now that is a monumental task.

Expand full comment
Contrarian 33's avatar

My response Susan is 13 comments below. at this hour and on this day.

Subject to change, of course.

Expand full comment
Vin LoPresti's avatar

We hope so, of course. But if history tells us anything, it is that justice against imperialist aggression has the spirit of the god's swift Olympian messenger Hermes, but the lard-ass density of insensate inaction of that shithead man-child Marco Rubio.

Expand full comment
GS-z-14-1's avatar

It will be necessary to build a mass movement to secure those prosecutions.

But the flip side is that the process of radicalization has already begun.

Expand full comment
Vin LoPresti's avatar

I wouldn't disagree with that analysis at all. I cite the mythical Hermes versus the lard-ass mediocrity Rubio, however, for quite obvious reasons: rate of change. I'm an old molecular biologist picturing enzymes and activation energies. I want to see these bastards prosecuted and/or hung upside-down in Palestine ala Mussolini's treatment by Italian partisans in Milano.

But after all the condemnations by international bodies, high courts, institutions established after the last World War to ensure [Ha] the non-repeat of such atrocities, nothing of substance has transpired(save your increased radicalization -- I grant you). So, you will forgive me; for I know the probability of my witnessing justice before I die; it is small.

Expand full comment
GS-z-14-1's avatar

‘I want to see these bastards prosecuted and/or hung upside-down…’

So soon as my eyes fell on those words, two things happened simultaneously. 1] My mind went straight to ‘Il Duce.’ 2] I realized that we are of the same generation, and that like you, I will likely not live to see these things.

That said, one can spread and act as if seeing that day is their sole civic aspiration.

In this year’s ‘May Day’ observance, World Socialist Web Site International Editor David North noted the same promises, plus the fact that they have [obviously] forgotten.

Expand full comment
Landru's avatar

Oh my friend, these times are a changing : ) Three of us will celebrate a Free Palestine for all people of peace : )

Expand full comment
Vin LoPresti's avatar

I like your optimism. I'll take it right now because this day in and day out shite is truly loathsome. Mothers day, we get Gazan mothers in tents struggling to keep their month-old infants alive. It's everything, everywhere, an optimism killer. So I look forward to such a celebration.

Expand full comment
Davina's avatar

Can you make that four?

I have watched this horror each day with such sorrow for the people of Gaza, while writing, correcting mis/disinformation and setting the record straight for those who think this all began on Oct 7, especially those biased on the side of Israel (who called me names I have never been called in my 85 years).

Expand full comment
Vin LoPresti's avatar

What would be the point of any other civic aspiration, other than asserting energy to promote the empire and its buddy (Massa?) Israel going down the poop-shute of international prominence? I try everything I can, including music video to my "fency" friends featuring images from a Gazan photojournalist whom I think of every day, hoping he's still alive. I'm astounded by how connected I have gotten to these people. Hope persists despite Milekowsky and his EasternEuro Nazi-derived thugs.

Expand full comment
The Dissident in Us's avatar

Justice American style is more like Luigi. 126 gun deaths a day in the US. He's just one more.

Expand full comment
Vin LoPresti's avatar

Yeah but I'm Italian-American and had a now deceased friend who was a young child in Mussolini's Italy during the war, so I had a close connection to those stories. There's something really pleasing about a fed-up citizen militia physically executing and displaying the corpse of the washed up Duce. Of course, we now have the internet making it unnecessary, so I see I am a dinosaur, and I beg everyone's noblesse oblige. WTF else can I say?

Expand full comment
Longtrail's avatar

Vin, we're old, got wise and don't give a fuck, right? I was thinking of El Duce long ago regarding the Zelenski's.

Expand full comment
LaVerne Karras's avatar

I'd like to be able to live long enough to see that, but I'd probably be competing with the mythical Methuselah for oldest before that happens.

Expand full comment
GS-z-14-1's avatar

When societies enter revolutionary periods, events flow with extraordinary rapidity.

Bear in mind that the Russian revolution was completed in 8 months.

Expand full comment
LaVerne Karras's avatar

We can hope!

Expand full comment
Davina's avatar

I don't think the Palestinians have eight months, this needs to be stopped now.

Expand full comment
Landru's avatar

Nope, we will live and celebrate in one live Caitlin party. Free Palestine!

Expand full comment
Landru's avatar

Can I tell you I love you ha. Damn that was the description all envy : )

Expand full comment
Patrick Saunders's avatar

Never mind Eichmann in Jerusalem, how soon Netanyahu & co in The Hague?

Expand full comment
Robert the Skeptic's avatar

If only…

Expand full comment
Kurvingrad's avatar

The Hague is only for political prisoners.

A kangaroo court.

Expand full comment
JennyStokes's avatar

I truly hope so but I am not holding my breath.

Expand full comment
Patrick Saunders's avatar

Who knows? Imagine him being kidnapped and taken there by force. Even more unlikely, but that would be a sight to behold ...

Expand full comment
Patrick Saunders's avatar

I'm thinking, of course, of Eichmann's abduction from Argentina by Israeli agents - how interesting that Hannah Arendt has just been named amongst the top 250 Americans scheduled by Trump to be honored in the National Garden of American Heroes. Let's hope Mr Tangerine Man doesn't inadvertently stumble across "The Origins of Totalitarianism" before she gets her place in the metaphoric sunshine, and then decides instead to erase her from history through damnatio memoriae...

Expand full comment
Tristam's avatar

Indeed. And it was zionist leadership that created that Nuremberg ruling.

Laws of physics are inexorable: What comes around goes around.

Expand full comment
Oracle's avatar

One day everyone will have been against this.......

Expand full comment
CK's avatar

Perhaps not the US defense contractors who profit from it. Their business models are based upon the prosecution of perpetual wars and the fear of perpetual wars. They also employ several millions of American workers whose paychecks have an economic multiplier effect in their communities.

Expand full comment
John Turcot's avatar

That day should have been from Day One, not Day 600 plus

Expand full comment
JennyStokes's avatar

Of course.

Expand full comment
Kurvingrad's avatar

"One day everyone will have been against this......."

Like everyone "was" against Iraq or Libya genocides but still enjoy Libyan or Iraqi oil as long as its price is low enough....

Expand full comment
Robert the Skeptic's avatar

Oh, I know some people who will not.

Expand full comment
Dr.Who's avatar

always* - phenomenal book by Omer El Akkad

Expand full comment
Philip Morris's avatar

Genocide is ongoing, every day Israel slaughters more civilians and is starving an entire population in its effort to eliminate the Palestinian population of Gaza . It’s about time that the world press wake up and call out Israel.

Expand full comment
AnF's avatar

Per the recent UN announcement, these countries are now legally required to send in soldiers to prevent the ongoing genocide.

We'll see who does first, and who rushes in to follow so they're not left out to dry.

Expand full comment
John Turcot's avatar

Absolutely right about sending soldiers…. ABSOLUTElY !

Expand full comment
Longtrail's avatar

Naval escorts for Freedom Flotillas are needed!

Expand full comment
LaVerne Karras's avatar

The US is vying for that title, they want to send in contractors, .......... to help the Israelis!!!

Expand full comment
George Cornell's avatar

It was about time 40 years ago. Anyone changing their stripes now should be seen as weaselly unprincipled phonies.

Expand full comment
Neil Procter's avatar

Agreed, but surely 77 years ago..

Expand full comment
John Turcot's avatar

Amen to that…

Expand full comment
Longtrail's avatar

The world press is complicit! They're just covering their a$$es

Expand full comment
John Turcot's avatar

It should have been done from Day One Not Day Two.

Expand full comment
Susan Harley's avatar

That is amazing after all this time, there must be a new agenda. Which is cynical but I have learnt nothing is done by the pressditutes without a plan.

Expand full comment
Ohio Barbarian's avatar

There is no new agenda, only a recognition of material reality by Big Oil and the MIC. Israel is now a liability for them, therefore the Empire's support for Israel is being withdrawn.

Expand full comment
CK's avatar

The US military weapons manufacturers will need to find new sales opportunities. They never fail to do so, with the support of the US Congress. Several million US jobs depend upon that.

Of course, the government could simply pay all of the defense contractors’ employees — including those of their supply chains— to stay at home or to participate in community service. The taxpayers’ expense would be the same, but without the pollution, waste of materials and destruction of lives and infrastructure.

Expand full comment
mirandapoet's avatar

True, many jobs are created by the arms industry. But in a country where so many things are in desperate need of attention, why is making stuff to kill people the only option for making a living?

Expand full comment
CK's avatar

Aside from mercenaries, defense contractors don’t kill people. They will manufacture whatever the government pays them to design, engineer and manufacture for guaranteed profits. Ask “the government” to answer that question.

Hint: most of the exceptionally wealthy are willing— perhaps grudgingly— to support taxation for the armed forces and law enforcement to protect their personal property. They aren’t eager to pay much for the support of society in general.

Expand full comment
TS's avatar

That's like saying, the U.S. has no responsibility for the murders in Gaza just because we've been supplying the bombs. I don't think that will stand up in court, after two parents were convicted for owning the gun their son used in a school shooting.

Expand full comment
LaVerne Karras's avatar

This is worse than that, the US is like the guy who put the idea in the head of a school shooter, stood beside him handing more guns and ammo all the while telling the police nothing was happening and if anything were, it was the fault of one kid that called him names.

Expand full comment
CK's avatar

Which court will hold the US accountable and responsible?

Across the USA, federal agents and most law enforcement officers have been granted immunity from prosecution.

The US government doesn’t recognize the authority of the UN or ICC. US armed forces have committed war crimes without prosecution for centuries.

Expand full comment
The Revolution Continues's avatar

And those arms factories could be re-tooled to make things that are non-lethal and helpful for ordinary people... But capitalists don't like spending money on re-tooling factories when there's so much profits to make in arms manufacturing.

Expand full comment
CK's avatar

The tooling for those defense contractors was 100% paid for by the US Government. Those contractors are pseudo-capitalists enjoying the benefits of government contracts that cover all of their expenses with guaranteed profit margins on their military production.

They would gladly retool if the government paid them to do so. They actually do retool for new weapons procurements programs. The retooling includes machine tools, jigs, fixtures, hand tools, robots, CNC equipment, inspection tools, test equipment and more.

If they were actual capitalist firms, they would have to issue stocks and bonds to procure capital, and would have to distribute profits to their shareholders. The contractors don’t sell shares to the government and don't pay dividends to the government.

You may already know all of this, but most taxpayers don’t. This was not taught in most undergraduate and graduate's business schools.

Firms such as Boeing, Pratt & Whitney, Lockheed-Martin, etc. that produce products for the military and for civilian customers do — or did — issue stocks for capital equipment that may be different from what they need for the military production but their entire enterprises benefit from shared processes and procedures.

Most of their inventions and technologies have been heavily subsidized by the US government.

Expand full comment
mirandapoet's avatar

So, if you make stuff whose purpose is to kill people, that's perfectly OK, as long as the government pays you to to it and you are netting amazing profits in the process. I just love that logic.

Expand full comment
The Revolution Continues's avatar

And you're employing workers at pretty decent wages too, workers who will go on to vote for those same politicians in the corrupt government that is keeping the war machine going. It's like one endless circle for the war-profiteers.

Expand full comment
Reno de Caro's avatar

"....the government could simply pay all of the defense contractors’ employees — including those of their supply chains— to stay at home............." With the trillions of dollars saved over the years they could be rechannelled into a major domestic infrastructure program.

Expand full comment
CK's avatar

Of course. However, fear of war is a motivator to support taxes for the military-industrial complex. Not as many Americans are willing to pay taxes for domestic infrastructure, healthcare, education.

The billionaires and mega-millionaires don’t need much in the way of domestic infrastructure, healthcare, etc. They can afford to pay for the best for themselves. They can buy private aircraft, ocean-going yachts, mansions and villas around the world. Most of them do not directly participate in wars. They profit from them.

Expand full comment
Paul Zickler's avatar

Hm... saving trillions by not going to war, investing them in infrastructure, lifting tens of millions out of poverty, improving the national economy. Somehow this reminds me of somebody. Feels like it's on the tip of my tongue... (Rhymes with mynah)

Expand full comment
CK's avatar

And creating a middle class of more than 440 million

Expand full comment
Margaret Henderson's avatar

....Not going to war....Lifting tens of millions out of poverty....China?

Expand full comment
Michael's avatar

Yup. China.

Expand full comment
LaVerne Karras's avatar

But, but, but...... socialism!!!!!!!

Expand full comment
Michael's avatar

Sounds good to me.

Expand full comment
CK's avatar

😅

Expand full comment
Susan Harley's avatar

That would be great , especially if it happened quickly, too many have already died .

May your words come true, Ohio Barbarian

Expand full comment
John Turcot's avatar

One child death was too many… I say ‘Toolittle too late’ for anyone who supported genicidal actions at any time.

Expand full comment
Susan Harley's avatar

Agree John , it is too little and disgracefully far too late

Expand full comment
Oracle's avatar

New agenda? The United States didn't send billions in weapons and bombs for nothing........ cmon now

Expand full comment
Susan Harley's avatar

You’re right, too much blood money for the overall agenda to change.

I meant the part the press is playing….this is probably a distraction , so people stop protesting and think the battle has been won . That they are on our side, in an ideal world they would be , but this is far from an ideal world.

Expand full comment
Sam's avatar

I agree with Lily Tomlinson.

“No matter how cynical I am I find it’s not enough.”

Expand full comment
Denis Rancourt's avatar

I hope this does not mean that the genocide has essentially been accomplished? Western states always normalize and even apologize AFTER a genocide has been completed

It's just very hard to believe that the empire would openly throw its Zionist apartheid entity under the proverbial bus if it was not forced to do so by real military resistance and potential (Yemen, Iran...)

Expand full comment
Jo Waller's avatar

Perhaps the pressure is too great? Perhaps they do need an out? Perhaps they realise Israel as a State cannot survive international public opinion, let alone international law? Perhaps they realise they can't survive the attacks from Yemen on their economy? Perhaps too many Israelis are trying to leave or have left?

Maybe the Israeli billionaires will now exist in a supranational way like US ones?

Expand full comment
Sam's avatar

We don't want any of those Israeli Jews here. Jews have already damaged our democracy too much. It's disgusting. We should require that they submit themselves to deprogramming from the cult they identify with.

Expand full comment
The Dissident in Us's avatar

They are losing travel privileges. No one wants a land thief in their restaurant, AirBnB, etc.

Expand full comment
John Turcot's avatar

“Western states apologize” ? I am still waiting for the U.S. to apologize to the Japanese for bonbing Hiroshima and Nagasaki…

Expand full comment
Shambo Clandestino's avatar

Yes. Whenever I try to bring up the evil of Hiroshima and Nagasaki with average Americans, they regurgitate faithfully, the propaganda inculcated in their (and my) high school history class; "it was necessary to save millions of American soldiers "! Even when I tell them that contemporary scholarship has put the lie to that, that it was simply to impress and send a message to the Russians, they don't realize the implications.

Abomination and vast moral turpitude is beyond their willingness to grasp, because it will require forever that they change their opinion about what the nation is, and who they are . they can't bear the cognitive dissonance.

I admit it is a lot to deal with. Let me stop here. Oh the horror, the horror...

Expand full comment
Daraja Press's avatar

What took them so fucking long?!

Expand full comment
Kurvingrad's avatar

Because Israeli were too slow to complete the task.

It would not be the first, neither last case where US admitted atrocities after the fact and after a massive smear campaign.

.

Mission accomplished for Israel. Next mission is already in works. Let's give some admission to gullible so that their anger can subdue and drown under forgetfulness, promise to punish those who are guilty but actually never find who was guilty.... rinse and repeat.

Expand full comment
The Revolution Continues's avatar

My thought exactly... What took them so fucking long? Did their "conscience" not bother them until they saw the writing on the wall and wanted to cover their asses? Sigh!

Expand full comment
Andrew Thomas's avatar

At least the Tory admitted, by pretty clear implication, that he had gotten it wrong for his entire 20 year career. By contrast, the editorials almost dripped with condescending moralizing; as if their authors actually expect that their readers will just forget 75 years of complicity and support for actions which have been explicitly genocidal for the entirety of that time.

Expand full comment
Reno de Caro's avatar

The MSM is attempting to save what little credibility they still have. The Tory is pretending that it took 11/2 years of a genocide to realize that there was a problem with Israel. He is just another rat trying to leave the sinking ship.

Expand full comment
JennyStokes's avatar

He's just saving himself before the shit happens.

Expand full comment
umbra illumino's avatar

Just remember, this may be a change in narrative, not a change in the fundamental end goal. Colonialism changes narrative when they lose control of it, then aligns with the dominant narrative until they can reshape it to regain the populous. It’s all theatrics. An act called “Emotions” in a play called “Control for the ruling class”

Expand full comment
Mikhael's avatar

Agreed. Leopards don't change their spots. These people are very organized conniving weasels.

Expand full comment
Sam's avatar

Interesting possibility. Thanks.

Expand full comment
Luis A. Melendez Albizu's avatar

It's a negotiating ploy in order to gain some fake sympathy during negotiations with Hamas, Houthis and Iran. Trump is setting up a Trojan Horse.

Expand full comment
ikester8's avatar

I'm going on that assumption as well. We welcome any aid to Gaza, even rhetorical, but actions matter, words don't.

Expand full comment
MaryJane's avatar

Most likely. They did the same trick with Zelensky calling him a dictator. Once they got all they needed, he became "great" again, and weapon deliveries to kill Russians resumed.

Expand full comment
Sam's avatar

Yup. If Trump really wanted Palestinians fed he’d lean on Egypt to open the border and let the food trucks in right now.

Expand full comment
Davina's avatar

It's Israel that closed that border. For Egypt to open it would mean using forrce, what do you think Israel would do in response?

Expand full comment
Lisa Savage's avatar

The late journalist John Pilger met Nazi propagandist Leni Reifenstahl in the 1970’s. “She told me that the “patriotic messages” of her films were dependent not on “orders from above” but on what she called the “submissive void” of the German public.

Did that include the liberal, educated bourgeoisie? I asked. “Yes, especially them,” she said”

Expand full comment
William Kearney's avatar

Very insightful

Expand full comment
Reno de Caro's avatar

"Leni Reifenstahl in the 1970’s.............." What she or any other former Nazi elites said at that time was nothing more than self-serving and consequently meaningless.

Expand full comment
ikester8's avatar

It is strange that it's happening all at once in the British press. As others here have said, this may be a movement against "this" government and PM, but what about the next one? Or, indeed, any Israeli government since its founding on stolen land? Only a couple of Israeli administrations have even hinted at the injustice of a people moving in en masse and terrorizing the existing populace to get them to flee to a strip of land you can now surround with razor wire.

Expand full comment
MaryJane's avatar

Is there anything that's NOT happening "at once" in the British press lately when it comes to key geopolitical events?

Expand full comment
Reno de Caro's avatar

The responses by the press are not only coordinated n Britain but in the entire West for an obvious reason. I'm American but linguistic, and read articles in the European press that looked like translation from the NY Times.

Expand full comment
Sam's avatar

Thomas Friedman also wrote an op-ed in the NYT saying that the genocide must stop.

Expand full comment
gs's avatar

This may be against the Gaza genocide and Netanyau, but once he is out, general support for Israel will remain

Expand full comment
Ohio Barbarian's avatar

That cannot happen, for that general support you speak of is already gone. These establishment mouthpieces would not be saying what they are saying if this was not so.

Expand full comment
Jennifer Akdemir's avatar

And we'll be back to the "working for peace" bullshit.

Expand full comment
JennyStokes's avatar

True BUT no-one trusts the US anymore.

Expand full comment
George Cornell's avatar

The famous ‘’PEACE PROCESS”. No peace, no process, no progress.

Expand full comment
Reno de Caro's avatar

".............but once he is out, general support for Israel will remain........." I agree, once this horror show is over and Netanyahu is gone, everything will be blamed on him, ignoring that his policies were supported by over 80% of the Israeli population.

Expand full comment
Sam's avatar

Reno, I'll go with your guess, because I guessed this on Oct 8. But it's only a guess, and I could be wrong. However, what will the Jewish Lobby do? I find it hard to believe that Jew Power will diminish in the West. So my best bet is that Israel will return as a great effort of survival fo Jews against the world, and Netanyahu will be made a scapegoat, afterwhich the slow burn kind of genocide and ethnic cleansing that Israel has been conducting since its inception will continue. But interspersed will be extremely violent excursions, just like those events that dot the past. It will be soon business as usual. If you're interested in knowing the humongous nature of the Jewish Lobby, here's a link on the list of Jewish political organizations that make up that Lobby:

The Jewish Lobby:

https://iwasathought.substack.com/p/the-jewish-lobby

Expand full comment
Reno de Caro's avatar

".............It will be soon business as usual......." I don't think so, Jim. I'm very familiar with the effectiveness of the Israel lobby. But their effectiveness is based on financing pro Israel politicians and the MSM singing their tune. After the horror show in Gaza, money won't be enough to get a pro Israel politician elected once the pro Israel propaganda is no longer is effective. The fact that even the MSM is posting denunciation of Israel tells me that the Genie is out of the bottle and can't be put in. As I pointed out in another post, the rats are leaving the sinking ship, and being identified as a rat does not bod well if you need public support. Regardless how much money you spent on your campaign. This is what will undermine the effectiveness of the lobby.

Expand full comment
Sam's avatar

Reno, you're much more optimistic than I am, and I genuinely hope you're right.

But you must realize the humongous power of the Jewish Lobby. With due respect, you mislable it as the Israel Lobby, which indicates that you do not fully grasp what we're dealing with. The Jewish Lobby has interests that go far beyond Israel. It's also concerned with US politics and US society. Those concerns involve the legal definition and governmental/societal response to “antisemitism”; the political and/or dominant roles played by Jews in government and US society; the control of the public debate on such concerns via the formulation of a Jewish public narrative; the control of what is politically correct in such a debate; the passage of laws deemed necessary to protect Jews as a group separate from all other U.S. groups - such as the anti-BDS and "combating antisemitism" laws and incorporating the IHRS definition of "antisemitism," which insults our intelligence; the many funding methods used to transfer U.S. citizen monies tax free to Israel and its Jewish citizens, and many others.

If you go to the link I gave in this thread, you'll understand that money-wise and organization-wise, the US Jewish Lobby is the largest political interest group in the country. It's not reasonable to expect that this lobby will simply vanish because only one of its concerns are running into trouble. What do you think these creeps are up to, with the billions of dollars and thousands of offices they work with on a daily basis?

For instance:

The IHRA Leaders Insult our Intelligence:

https://iwasathought.substack.com/p/the-ihra-jewish-leaders-insult-our

Expand full comment
George Cornell's avatar

Why? Israel was a huge mistake. The first clue was it is populated by a people unable to establish self-governance for 2000 years.

Expand full comment
Feral Finster's avatar

We've seen this movie before. A few cracks in the MSM narrative, alt-media supporters declare victory, a couple days later, the MSM reverts to form, often with a groveling apology.

Even assuming that this does in fact turn out to be a trend, it raises the question of why? What caused this change?

Expand full comment
Mikhael's avatar

Well you can damn be sure that they didn't just get a conscience overnight. They'll be back. Watch them.

Expand full comment
JennyStokes's avatar

Saving their arses?

Expand full comment
James Anon's avatar

TRYING to save their arses... success not guaranteed. Hopefully.

Expand full comment
martin's avatar

normally one would assume that business drives these things. a sudden drop in advertising income? clicks? pr-image?

Expand full comment
Feral Finster's avatar

I don't think anyone buys a MSM news outlet to make money.

Regardless, it's not as if the genocide were a closely guarded secret known only to the initiates until just now.

Expand full comment
martin's avatar

ultimately they do, imo. it's narrative control that allows one to continue other rip-offs. up to now msm managed to at least confuse +50% of populations on the genocide (tapping in to learned behaviour and undeserved 'respect').

Expand full comment
Feral Finster's avatar

MSM is a loss leader in that respect.

Expand full comment
Ohio Barbarian's avatar

The word's out. Israel has become a liability for Big Oil, the MIC, and thus the US Empire, therefore Israel must be either reined in or allowed to die. It really makes no difference to them, but I'll do my bit to encourage them to take Option #2.

It won't even be that hard to do now. Even Texas oilmen don't like seeing children starve to death.

Expand full comment
Reno de Caro's avatar

"Israel has become a liability for Big Oil, the MIC.................," The real reason is that Israel has become a liability for Jews all over the world, who are now employing their Hannibal directive and are throwing the Israel project under the buss. They aware that the Israelis will have no problem to settle in other western countries.

Expand full comment
Ohio Barbarian's avatar

I hadn’t thought of that, obviously partly because I’m not Jewish, but also because the majority of American Jews still blindly support Israel.

I know there is a very vocal minority on the right side of both history and the survival instinct, but I didn’t think that “Jews all over the world” who are appalled by Israel’s actions had that much power.

I would love to see some evidence to support your claim.

Expand full comment
Sam's avatar

Interesting comment. There must be some way that Judaism will prevail, which is the prime directive for all Jews, according to their intense childhood indoctrination. Even beyond Israel. But I don't think they are that desperate yet. I think it's more likely that they will whitewash Israel by scapegoating Netanyahu, making him the source of all evil in Judaism. Judaism will sacrifice any person - Jew or non-Jew - or any number of people, in order to fulfill the prime directive that the Jewish Tribe survives forever. The reason is because the Tribe is a tremendous business model by which its leaders achieve wealth and power. How else can we explain it's survival in the last 2500 years?

Expand full comment
Davina's avatar

But which tribes of the twelve are causing hell on earth for Palastinians? I do not think they are the tribes of Israel, the man loved by God who obeyed His laws, the only tribes given a promise of a land of peace and pkenty.

The other eleven tribes certainly broke God's laws and were condemned to wander the Earth without a homeland.

Seems to me that Israel, the state, is not part of God's plan and have broken so many of God's laws over and over and over, so it would be fulfilling His laws if that state's population were disbanded and made to follow God's laws at last. Only those against His laws support tge current occupiers of Palestine.

Expand full comment
Sam's avatar

It seems to me you believe the writings in the Bible as authentic historical recordings. I don't.

With respect to our discussion here, I don't give a damn what's in the Bible.

Expand full comment
Davina's avatar

The zionists have, and still are, using the bible as their right to steal Palestine, I am refuting their lies by using the bible. If they can do that, so can we to show their lies.

It is your right not to believe in the bible, or to believe. What concerns me is its misuse in order to steal land, and then kill the people of that land for decades.

Use fire against fire, yeah?

Expand full comment
Sam's avatar

Davina, I don't object to what you're doing, and in fact, I've done it myself. I do it by pointing out that Israel is just one more false God or Sacred Cow that the Jews have resorted to as a salvation for their Tribe, and in doing so, they turn away from their God, who, according to the Bible must be their only salvation. I then ask, will their God thus punish them again, as we read in the Bible, collectively?

I've been voicing this idea for years, and only recently I heard Peter Beinart, a Jew who criticizes Judaism, use some of this reasoning.

Incidentally, Beinart is the only Jew that I heard who criticizes Judaism as the perpetrator of the crimes against the Palestinians - not just the Zionists/Israel. I commend him for it, because he's right and brave enough to say the truth. Even Caitlin cannot do that.

Expand full comment
Davina's avatar

By studying history for decades I have seen that so many of their tales are lies, and that quite the opposite happened.

Expand full comment
Kit Klarenberg's avatar

🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

Expand full comment
Jim S's avatar

Thank You Caitlin

Expand full comment