329 Comments
User's avatar
David Baird's avatar

In the same way that it was damned difficult to find a Nazi in Germany post WW2, the title of Omar Al Akkad's recent book is absolutely appropriate: 'One day, everyone will have always been against this'. There's going to be a great deal of attempted arse-covering going on by the defenders of the Israeli genocidists.

Expand full comment
Nick Douglas's avatar

FUSA and FEU are on record of enabling genocide of Palestinians. This cannot be erased. EVER! FUSA has vetoed every resolution legalizing self-determination of Palestinians and the establishment of the Palestinian state. Supremacism, exceptionalism, genocides, and violence is so deeply rooted in FUSA and FEU cultures. FUCK that shithole called "israel".

Expand full comment
Spunty's avatar

They've also vetoed every attempt to stop the mass killing of civilians. Evil bastards.

Expand full comment
JennyStokes's avatar

What are: FUSA and FEU. Acronyms are never helpful.

Expand full comment
Nick Douglas's avatar

F stands for Fascist, Fuckin', Fugly, ... and all of those together.

Expand full comment
Rosalind Dalefield's avatar

I'm guessing they are fuckin' USA and fuckin' EU.

Expand full comment
Cornelia HEMMELDER's avatar

Fucking USA and Fucking Europe

Expand full comment
SW's avatar

Some celebrities just can’t let it go. I saw a clip of the odious Megan Kelly saying on Piers Morgan she doesn’t believe the pictures and, to top it off, the Palestinians would starve their children so they could take these horrible pictures of starving children. She went on to wail the Israelis have essentially destroyed their credibility—they’ve gone too far and she’s concerned the world won’t forgive them.

How much aid will get in? The Israelis are blocking the trucks and as far as I know, no credible organization has been put in charge of distribution.

Expand full comment
Jack Bowers's avatar

Well Megan Kelly is right about two things: Israel has destroyed its credibility; and no, it will never be forgiven. Not ever.

Expand full comment
Nick Douglas's avatar

That fascist jewish entity never had any credibility. One cannot lose/destroy something it never had.

Expand full comment
gypsy33's avatar

Well said, Nick!

KILL ISRAHELL!

Expand full comment
martin's avatar

megan kelly is not concerned the world won't forgive her?

Expand full comment
poetinapaperbag's avatar

Definition Shiksa Slut: ..adjective noun, Megan Kelly.

Expand full comment
Susan T's avatar

One day everyone will have always been against this war just the same as one day everyone was against the holocaust. That atrocity was ignored for too long and the atrocity in Gaza is even worse. One day lets hope our world wakes up for real. Let's hope that happens before it is too late and we all burn up in fires created by the other human developed situation: the climate catastrophe. Which this human created situation of genocide is making even worse. We have to keep hoping. I guess.

Expand full comment
martin's avatar

maybe act.

Expand full comment
poetinapaperbag's avatar

Aye...Hope is just another Judean/Christian trick.

Expand full comment
Susan T's avatar

Yes, act. And hope. I feel as if there is not enough that I can do in terms of acting.

Expand full comment
poetinapaperbag's avatar

Arm the Palestinians.

Expand full comment
Rosalind Dalefield's avatar

One person can't do much, but get enough snowflakes together and we form a mighty avalanche!

Expand full comment
Rosalind Dalefield's avatar

Fortunately, the internet, while not perhaps eternal, has a long memory.

Expand full comment
Joy in HK fiFP's avatar

They're likely to try and wipe the internet clear. They will delete all their posts, tweets, videos, etc. People might want to download or screenshot, or print copies for posterity.

Expand full comment
Rosalind Dalefield's avatar

You're right. They are really into historical revisionism.

Expand full comment
Joy in HK fiFP's avatar

18 U.S. Code § 1091

Let's make sure they remember. We need to get every single member of the current administration, along with the entire Biden administration, charged under 18 U.S. Code § 1091, the statute that incorporates the Genocide Convention into US criminal law. Members of these administrations shouldn't go a single day without having this statute in their faces, up front and center, at every protest, at every meeting, press conference, briefing, and trips home and abroad. Let them consider what is looming. They should have visions of prison all the days of their lives, and echos of those cell doors slamming shut.

Let us find the way.

Expand full comment
Hanief's avatar

Just like in South Africa, when apartheid statutorily ended, it was impossible to find anybody who supported that disgusting philosophy, except of course the diehard rascists who still exist today and some of whom the fucking deranged orange lunatic is now housing in the USA!

Expand full comment
Nick Douglas's avatar

All racists, fascists, nazis, rapists, zionists, war criminals, etc. always find refuge, safety, and prosperous futures in FUSA.

Expand full comment
LSweet's avatar

I agree. However, there is one major difference between now and then: we have the receipts. Social media has captured the atrocity in real-time.

Expand full comment
Chang Chokaski's avatar

Everyone that supported (and still supports) this Genocide needs to be held responsible! NEVER FORGET, and NEVER FORGIVE!

Hit them where it hurts! Boycott businesses that are responsible, boycott buying products from such companies/corporations (as far as possible). Boycott artists, musicians, performers, hollywood actors/actresses, media outlets, etc. that have supported this Genocide (for ever if possible). HURT THEM WHERE IT HURTS - their pockets! (as that seems to be the only thing they understand - money/profits).

Expand full comment
Rosalind Dalefield's avatar

I will never stop practicing BDS, even if Israhell is wiped from the face of the planet.

Expand full comment
Chang Chokaski's avatar

💯 Me too!

Expand full comment
Contrarian 33's avatar

All of us, I trust.

I never cease to be so impressed with the efforts of Caitlin and Tim.

I am sure that I speak for all when I say that both of you are so highly regarded.

You have more than earned your place in history.

Expand full comment
Davina's avatar

If Israel ceased to exist, the Israelis need to be kept away from humans. Put them as far from human habitation as possible, and the can start killing each other. Should only take them a day or two start.

Expand full comment
Lily East's avatar

They can all go to Epstein Island and rot there.

Expand full comment
Nick Douglas's avatar

One needs to put multiple thick high walls, mine fields, observation posts, automatic machine guns, high-voltage electric fences, etc. around such place. The world had enough of them. Rotting is the correct word for that human filth.

Expand full comment
Lily East's avatar

Totally agree. There are no worse than these zionazi filth in all of humankind.

Expand full comment
Rosalind Dalefield's avatar

Much too nice there.

Expand full comment
Rosalind Dalefield's avatar

I suggest Novaya Zemlya. It is very radioactive from Soviet nuclear testing, and maybe with time the Zionists might mutate into decent human beings.

Expand full comment
Davina's avatar

I wouldn't put money on them mutating into decent anything, but the place is a good idea.

Expand full comment
Rosalind Dalefield's avatar

Especially as the polar bear population in Novaya Zemlya is rising.

Expand full comment
Landru's avatar

Neutron Star?

Expand full comment
Landru's avatar

https://bdsmovement.org/ I follow and donate as well : )

Expand full comment
Cornelia HEMMELDER's avatar

That would be what recognizing the State of Palestine should be. Not à two states solution.

Expand full comment
Contrarian 33's avatar

The list of actions by Chang and others today need to be implemented.

As with the identification of all those from other lands who became part of the IDF, the ones on the ground doing all these crimes, day in and day out.

They need to be known to the governments.....no, not governments, but known to the people in the countries where they are domiciled. Australia, the USA so many from there, paid for by Netanyahu and his accomplices in America; France, Germany, the UK and on.

Weak corrupted governments who put profit before humanity. Even at the time of this writing, still not having stated clearly that this has been a genocide.

In my book, the paid mercenaries should all be killed as a repayment for their crimes. They have been reported as having enjoyed their roles as killers, bombers, rapists and snipers, never ever to be forgiven for their crimes.

Expand full comment
Davina's avatar

Yes, they need to be cattle herded in a fenced in food line while being shot at indiscriminately each day(only one small feeding per day)until none are left. You reap what you've sown, should absolutely apply.

Expand full comment
Joy in HK fiFP's avatar

Now you have become your enemy. I think my side is better than this.

Expand full comment
Cornelia HEMMELDER's avatar

What book please ?

Expand full comment
Jim's avatar

Get the app No Thanks. It allows you to scan products individually and shows you if these items contribute to the Zionist genocidal demon.

Expand full comment
#FreePalestine's avatar

It's great, as is www.gaza.nu this is available in different languages and in some cases shows alternatives.

Expand full comment
Rosalind Dalefield's avatar

I use it, and another one called Boycat. Both very good.

Expand full comment
#FreePalestine's avatar

100%! I've collated a list of tech products; office suites, VPN, email, browsers, travel sites, taxi apps, started using open source, online shopping sites etc., that I'll use and update forever! I'll NEVER use companies like AirBnB, Edge, Uber again etc., it's caused problems but NOTHING in comparison to what the Palestinian people have gone through and facing going forward.

I'm also starting to write to various countries immigration divisions to request changes to their entry visas for Israelis, requesting them to BLOCK entry to Israeli war criminals, IGF soldiers and providing photos of known soldiers... it's been a process and if others did this it would increase pressure for change. If all we have against the Zionist murderers is our voice and 'pen' lets use it! Thailand just announced changes, which is fantastic! As you'll be aware various countries like Maldives, Malaysia etc., have already changed.

- BOYCOTT ISRAEL!

- BOYCOTT ISRAELI GOODS!

- BOYCOTT ISRAELI'S!

- BOYCOTT the GENOCIDAL MURDERERS!

They will NEVER feel freedom again, they will suffocate in their own HORROR!

FUCK ISRAEL!

Expand full comment
charles leone's avatar

Prison!!

Expand full comment
Chang Chokaski's avatar

Prison is too good for most of them. If I express how I really feel with the words that I'd like to, I'd probably get banned from substack.

Expand full comment
#FreePalestine's avatar

Laughing, that's already happened to me earlier this year! Keep a list of people you need to stay in touch with, just in case. You can always create a new profile, as I've done.

Substack is Zionist, hence why no list is available of 'staff', something I commented on and lost access when a Zionist 'head of comms' came on board late last year. When you push truth too much and ask them direct questions, they crack... I use them as much as they use us.

Expand full comment
Chuck Nasmith's avatar

Bin Banned is a name once used !

Expand full comment
Davina's avatar

You would not be alone.

Expand full comment
Landru's avatar

Very well said my friend, the dollar their ultimate God.

Expand full comment
Landru's avatar

Amy Klobuchar prime example, oh wait Obummer is now looking to escape his history.

Expand full comment
Nick Douglas's avatar

Klobuchar, Obama both filthy human excrement.

Expand full comment
Cornelia HEMMELDER's avatar

Chang, you are so right. But this concerns ALL the Westerners. Still going on, by the way.

Expand full comment
Chuck Nasmith's avatar

Shut Them Down.

Expand full comment
K Miller's avatar

All these ghastly and ghoulish Dems who couldn’t bring themselves to utter a word of support for the Palestinians for decades, let alone the last 2 years, now come out of the woodwork because they know 80%+ of the population still alive now will be dead given the trajectory of extermination they’re enslaved in. The ZioNAzis have nearly completely their slaughter. All with the support of our entire government - repugnicans and Dems. Every single one of them is owned by AIPAC and they’re now being given permission to pull out the humanitarian act…but only so many at a time. FuCk every single one of them.

Expand full comment
Whatistobedone's avatar

.....fuck them all....to hell, their true homeland.

Expand full comment
Lily East's avatar

Yes exactly. They are given permission to do this as a tactic to control the narrative and thus to make the people subservient and docile. It's such an old and tired tactic and yet we still collectively fall for it. Crumbs and circuses. We all need to stay vigilant, not placated.

Expand full comment
jtolbertjr's avatar

No one gets a pass now. No one.

Expand full comment
Chang Chokaski's avatar

I second your sentiment!

Expand full comment
Rosalind Dalefield's avatar

I agree. The Pro-Palestine train left the station sometime in 2024 (a late departure, but a departure). Some of us have been on it for decades, some for years, some only in the months after 7 October when they listened and learned. At this point, anyone running along the tracks after it whining "Me too!" has missed out.

Expand full comment
Lily East's avatar

LOL at Ariana Scam-de and Obama and Dems and Repubs and anyone else who think that NOW it's a red line. Wait....not "LOL"...but rather FUUUUUCK THEM ALL. Off to hell they go. I spit on them all. May they all suffer immensely in this life and in the next, beyond what any human can conjur in the imagination, as payback for every single drop of Palestinian blood spilled in this HOLOCAUST.

Expand full comment
Davina's avatar

Go Lily, that's how I feel every day for the past 22months, but also for about forty years as well.

We are supposed to thank these people when it took them ^only^ 77 years to stand up and be counted - because the people are rising against them and that would affect there bank accounts.

Expand full comment
Lily East's avatar

Exactly! They give us crumbs and we are supposed to slavishly accept those crumbs? It's a numbing tactic to keep the people docile.

Expand full comment
N/'s avatar

Ariana signed a letter asking for ceasefire back in 2023 when this round of the genocide began, this isn't any break from a previous position for her. Not defending her from the obvious or as a person etc, but she's not been a turncoat as the Dems have.

Could she/other celebs do more? Definitely. But it's wild to think a pop star had more principle than the party that positions themselves as defenders of human rights and allowed the genocide to be carried out anyway.

Expand full comment
Lily East's avatar

Yes, I'm aware, and sadly it is not near enough to what she (and other "celebs" could and should do) considering the MASSIVE each they have. Side note: we've made a lot of people famous for the wrong reasons.

Anyway, you tell me, if you had that amount of reach, and wealth, would you remain as timid as she and others have? The US is completely and utterly infiltrated by zionazis, who are actively destroying this country, and we cheer when a "celeb" does the bare minimum? Remember Bernie? Controlled opposition. He single handedly let down millions and he did it on purpose by distracting and then deflating those millions. People like Ariana Grande have that same role. Give us juuuust enough to make us "relax."

No thanks.

Expand full comment
Davina's avatar

Spot on, Lily. I am so angry, at what these Israelis are doing to Palestinians it chokes me at times. You probably notice that my typing is a mess then 😤

Expand full comment
Lily East's avatar

Reach* not each

Expand full comment
Whatistobedone's avatar

👍💪....you are my kinda gal: ENRAGED. I am.

Expand full comment
Longtrail's avatar

Oh Baby! Superb!

Expand full comment
Ian Brown's avatar

Anyway who was paying attention knew exactly what Israel's intentions were the first week. They literally said what they were going to do, what the Israelites did to Amalek, that they were going to target the entire civilian population, and that no food or water would get in. They talked about turning Gaza into a parking lot, and sending Palestinians into permanent exile, from the beginning. This from a state founded and built on ethnic cleansing of Palestinians. Within a couple months South Africa was charging genocide with a damning case at the ICJ.

But as always, we have to wait until the evil is mostly complete before it's acceptable to denounce it. There is no ignorance here. What happened was something else...

Expand full comment
Ian Brown's avatar

And just saying, if you understand what atrocity progaganda is, and what it is used for, all lurid stories about beheaded babies and mass rapes were an instant giveaway. Throughout history, these stories are concocted to enable atrocies. Even the scripts are the same, savages attacking out precious white women, babies on spikes, thrown from incubators etc etc All of these have been used before.

Expand full comment
Davina's avatar

Israeli attack on the other is a confession of their diabolical actions of rape (men women and children) with instruments that do permanent damage internally. They truly are sick bastards.

Expand full comment
gypsy33's avatar

Yes they are Davina.

As you saw in another Substack, my comment that Israhell is a hotbed of sexual perversion.

Expand full comment
Nick Douglas's avatar

Yes, and unbelievable how gullible and stupid people are to fall for the same lies.

Expand full comment
Nick Douglas's avatar

Fascist USA was involved in every genocide in the last 300 years. Shitsrael since 1948. Add to that Germany, France, UK, Belgium, Netherlands, Spain, Portugal, AU and NZ. Humanity needs to get rid of malignant tumors or it will kill us all.

Expand full comment
Rosalind Dalefield's avatar

I'm willing to cut Spain some slack because they are actively opposing what Israel is doing. Fuck the rest of them, though.

Expand full comment
Nick Douglas's avatar

Agree.I think Spain and Portugal have atoned. The rest of western garbage didn't.

Expand full comment
#FreePalestine's avatar

Portugal has done NOTHING! Believe I lived there and spoke up, helped MSDS etc., and they did nothing! Mainly due to the fact Israelis have invested a lot in Lisbon, agriculture, Porto etc., and PT government needed this, and surprise, surprise the E(non)U and the Nazi Zionist bitch Ursula backed and allowed. The Israelis have done the same in Greece, the corruption in GR is astounding BUT the Greek people are rising up, boycotts have started from small posters in cafes, to 'Free Palestine' vigilantes walking the streets in Athens ✊🏼🇵🇸, our voices, letters, emails, posters are POWERFUL! ✊🏼🇵🇸

FUCK ISRAEL!

Expand full comment
Lily East's avatar

IsraHELLis are everywhere like cockroaches. Jesus Christ.

Expand full comment
gypsy33's avatar

And FUCK GREECE, which is sheltering Satanyahu when he should be in chains.

Expand full comment
#FreePalestine's avatar

He's back in Israel, but Greece offers him a ‘safe place’ if and when needed…

Expand full comment
Landru's avatar

My friends in Argentina have told me, israeli's (lowercase for disrespect) israeli Genocide Force troops are being given a citizenship. I am not 100% sure on that yet though.

Expand full comment
Nick Douglas's avatar

Maradona is turning in his grave. He was big supporter of Palestine. He was a great sportsman and even better human.

Expand full comment
#FreePalestine's avatar

That will be correct, Milei loves Israel, and the bilateral agreement with Argentina had been strong since 1949. After WWII many Jews left Europe and headed to Argentina. Ironically so did the SS and Nazis. It has the largest Jewish population in South America. The rest of South America hates Israelis and won't be offering such as easy deal.

Expand full comment
Paula's avatar

I wish someone would contemplate "why now and why everyone all at once." Nothing anyone ever does at this point will make the world forget what has unfolded and played out before us and the silence from those who might have made a difference.

Expand full comment
Whatistobedone's avatar

EXACTLY. Almost 2 YEARS OF GENOCIDE. Where the fuck were they then? Cowards.

Expand full comment
Nod Dranoel's avatar

100 years of genocide

Expand full comment
Rosalind Dalefield's avatar

My theory is that they are confident that the erasure of all the people in Gaza is close. That will leave only the treacherous quisling Palestinian Authority for them to deal with.

Expand full comment
Lily East's avatar

Exactly! It's narrative control by the zionazi controlled cesspool that is Hollywood. And New York, etc

Expand full comment
Chuck Nasmith's avatar

One State Palestine.

Expand full comment
Lily East's avatar

💯. It's the only solution

Expand full comment
martin's avatar
2dEdited

i guess the establishment has realised that bibi will go all the way. the red line they now 'suddenly' see, will be the only red line established. i think they will get in the humanitarian aid to prevent what is brewing, being worldwide union actions that will actually disrupt trade (with israel). once the starvation has been stopped and looming business disruption averted, they will continue with the other tactics as before. manufacturing 'comprador' palestinians (and islamists, like the druze and sunni arabs in syria) and establish another palestinian authority-like capo-class to replace hamas (and especially the tiny socialist factions in the resistance) in government.

maybe some of the obscenely rich have figured out how this u-turn can be commodified.

Expand full comment
vansdan's avatar

convenient to wait til AFTER ITS TOO LATE!!! we've been screaming at the top of our lungs for almost 2 years and now they listen? when its beyond too late? when its beyond too obvious? when its beyond too indefensible? un fucking believable.

Expand full comment
Whatistobedone's avatar

Where were they last year? Where were they in 2023 when the genocide began? Obviously, they lack a keen sense of the obvious.

Expand full comment
Bevan's avatar

The Jewish holocaust was hidden while it occurred. The Gaza genocide is broadcast every day. Trump’s advice, “Finish the job!”🤮

Expand full comment
Nick Douglas's avatar

Genocide Don or Genocide Joe. They are both the same human garbage. The first precondition to be a president of FUSA.

Expand full comment
Indu Abeysekara's avatar

Bevan, Trump said yesterday, "those children look hungry..." after seeing the photos of starving Palestinian children of Gaza.

Expand full comment
Feral Finster's avatar

Right now, Trump is preoccupied with his former buddy, Jeffrey Epstein and his own role in the Epstein Files and of course, Mr. Epstein's extracurricular activities.

Expand full comment
gypsy33's avatar

Feral, there’s gonna be some brave whistleblower. On Epstein, Trump, Clinton, and all the rest. Fingers crossed 🤞 I cannot wait for the Chernobyl event that follows.

Expand full comment
MakeTheWorldSafeForDiversity's avatar

Wondering who gave permission to all of these puppets to suddenly pretend to grow a conscience. They don't seem to be cutting off funding for the genocide or delivering actual aid to Gaza.

Expand full comment
Feral Finster's avatar

The answer is, in a roundabout way, Jeffrey Epstein.

Expand full comment
Hannah lewis's avatar

Absolutely brilliant as all your writing is. Thank you for all that you do, for your integrity, for calling it out, for your humanity, your insight, incisiveness and truth telling.

Expand full comment
Whatistobedone's avatar

Not me. I can do both at the same time. No. For me, NONE of them (perpetrators AND cheerleaders) can ever be redeemed. They are and will remain dead souls.

Expand full comment
Jocelyn's avatar
3dEdited

This article neatly documents a long list of atrocities that should have had us all out on the streets screaming things like "Death to the IDF" at the top of our lungs since roughly mid-October 2023. I'm proud of and grateful to everyone who did not stop screaming until their voices were heard (like you, Caitlin!). Horton isn't the only one hearing the Whos anymore, thank goodness, but that doesn't mean it's over. We have to keep on speaking out against these horrors and hold the perpetrators (and their facilitators) accountable.

Expand full comment
Peter Sawchuk's avatar

I'm reasonably sure none of the participants in this genocide will ever have to answer for their crimes. The U.S and Israel have already flaunted their contempt of the International criminal court because they own it. They have made a mockery of world justice for years and will continue to do so. Two steps forward and one step back means they will still advance their agenda only at a slower pace for a while.

Expand full comment
gypsy33's avatar

Hi Peter

Then WE will have to hold them accountable our own damn selves.

Tall trees, short ropes, signs on their bodies reading THIS IS WHAT HAPPENS TO GENOCIDERS.

Let them swing until the maggots consume them.

And WE THE PEOPLE thanks to the Second Amendment are armed to the teeth. (Well, I am, anyways.)

Expand full comment
Peter Sawchuk's avatar

I wish I lived there. Unfortunately I am in Communist Canada. Up here we are fighting to hold on to the few firearms that we still have.

Expand full comment
Nick Douglas's avatar

Hope not

Expand full comment
Nick Douglas's avatar

But this is exactly jewish pervert game. They are provocative SICK FUCKS. jews commit unspeakable war crimes and when people of the world protest and call for genocide to stop, jews cry "antisemitism", "why do they hate us", etc. Yes, they are sick fucks and I do not believe that they will ever change. Overwhelming majority of jews stand for genocide of Palestinians and everyone else who opposes shitsrael. We are all Palestinians. We are all resistance.

Expand full comment
gypsy33's avatar

Nick 👍👍👍

Expand full comment
Davina's avatar

Anyone who thinks this startedby the resistance by Hamas military arm in October 23 is fooling themselves.

IT STARTED 77 YEARS AGO WHEN ZIONISTS ARRIVED IN PALESTINEAND STARTED THROWING PEOPLE OUT OF THERE HOMES. NEVER FORGET- THEY ARRIVED ARMED, PROVING GHEIR INTENTION WAS NOT FRIENDLY.

Yes, I am angry that any slighly educated person would still think all thus is because of Oct 23. That was the excuse to speed up the holocaust.

Why else would Satanyahu have had troops moved away from the border - after having been informed that Hamas were carrying out exercises and gathering along Gaza's fence. Then ordering pilots nshoot their own so he could blame Hamas for that 1200 deaths by Israeli pilots?

Expand full comment
Lily East's avatar

Mielekowsky knew 100%

Expand full comment