10 Comments
User's avatar
Jos Backus's avatar

“Thank you for your service” is an admission of ignorance of US history.

Peter Best's avatar

The police protect us from bad people and we’d never be bad people so police are all right. Soldiers protect us from foreigners who are probably all bad people and we’d never be foreigners so soldiers are good

Ian Brown's avatar

The deepest propaganda, and what few even “liberal” people question is the notion that the world is filled with all these “bad guys” “evil dictators” “terrorists”, and no matter how bad America behaves internally or with its “allies” all these other countries are way, way worse and will spread evil and tyranny everywhere if America the hapless bystander doesn't take the responsibility to stop them. Whatever we do, well we meant well, and anyone is better than Maduro or Ortega or Diaz Canal, well just because, and if we don't support “democracy” in all these countries, countries who silently call out for the America white knight to rescue them, but are to afraid to say so publicly, the bad guys win and democracy is lost.

Probably about 95%+ of Americans believe some version of this, and absolutely cannot fathom the idea that the US is an aggressive country, it's targets are not nightmare dystopia, or that people around the world might have any legitimate point of view any different than what American mainstream believes.

This framework unites Amy Goodman with Marco Rubio, Bernie Sanders with Pete Hegseth.

This is the key pillar that has to be knocked down, and what is most protected with denial.

The Revolution Continues's avatar

Conscientious Objectors: Call the G.I. Rights Hotline at 1-877-447-4487 or the Center for Conscience & War at 1-800-379-2679. You don't have to die for Israel. Call today!

Clare McElroy's avatar

When I visited the U.S. a few years ago, it was quite bizarre to hear people reverently intoning “thank you for your service!” to any random claiming to be military or ex-military.

Here in Australia, being in the military is generally regarded with anything from suspicion to derision - weirdo private school boys being packed off to Puckapunyal to practise cruelty and misogyny .

Naila Claudia Schulte's avatar

THE SOLDIER’S TALE: I WASN'T BORN TO KILL

I was raised to be a good man in the home of the brave and free

Thankful for the good life in the land of liberty

My parents did their best to make me all that I could be

And I told myself, Gonna really make them proud.

The day I got my uniform they smiled and said, “My son,

Go fight those evil terrorists until this war is won.

You’re standing at the side of God with your courage and your gun

Forget He ever said, ‘Thou shalt not kill.’”

Then one day on the field of war I found myself alone

And somewhere in the distance I heard a mournful moan

I ran and found a man with a wound down to the bone

He shouted to me, “Brother, won’t you help me.”

I looked into his eyes, and he smiled through the pain

My heart reached out to hold him but I had to heed my brain

Compassion battled duty, but its struggle was in vain

My rifle raised, I shot him through the heart.

It’s been a year, I’m home again, the war’s been left behind

But life’s no longer life, and my mind is not my mind

And I just can’t find the part of me that’s gentle, calm, and kind;

Anger, grief, and shame are all I know.

Darkness is my only friend, whiskey sees me through

Those eyes still haunt my memory no matter what I do

It wasn’t God who put me here, and the only thing that’s true

Is this, my friends -- I wasn’t born to kill.

Claudia Naila Schulte

Michael's avatar

It’s hard to fight the constant pressure to worship military. What would happen if I boo during the giant flag ceremony during EVERY pro sporting event or when they wheel out the decrepit WW2 vet, I start screaming “murderer”! Would others join me or attack me for being unpatriotic and unappreciative of the sacrifices that old fool made for “our freedom “. The constant military worship is grotesque but most don’t see it or don’t want to. All they are or ever will be is wrapped up in that flag.

Jane Stoll's avatar

I live with a Vietnam vet. (Don’t mention the war!!!) The wars are the reason half of America has PTSD. The soldiers bring it home and pass it to their families. Over the last 200 years, the trauma load has been continuously built up, which is why the US has such high rates of all mental illnesses. Research is showing all mental illness is caused by some form of trauma—physical, psychological, & emotional. Traumatized people are easier to grift. And Trump is the master grifter.

Still Just Alison's avatar

If more citizens of the USA could see their country’s history from the perspective of others, they’d have a very rude shock.

Governments overthrown for the cardinal sin of wanting to nationalise their own resources (eg Iran 1953), and so many bombed and attacked over the years for similar crimes against US supremacy.

Anyone who wants to learn about this should read Killing Hope by William Blum - it’s a catalogue of many of the US wars since WW2.

BRIAN KRAJCI's avatar

Just look. Just look at who collected the insurance, (twice), on 9-11. Please don't kill or die for Israel. Just look.