172 Comments
User's avatar
⭠ Return to thread
Fran's avatar

Unfortunately our closest living relative on planet earth is the chimpanzee. We share a common ancestry with them, and as we now know chimps are very territorial, aggressive and establish a hierarchy which they can fight for tooth and nail. They can be particularly aggressive to other groups. Genetically we are more closely, not by much, to the bonobos who love to kiss, but as life would have it we share a common ancestor with the chimps.

Expand full comment
Michael Natkanski's avatar

Yes we share an evolutionary heritage, but modern science has shown robustly that genes do not determine behaviour as such. Genetic determinism remains well-established in the public mind, because it is the most established hard-right propaganda that serves to maintain the toxic status quo that Caitlin challenges.

Expand full comment
George Cornell's avatar

You’re repeating yourself. Genetic influence, not determinism is what people believe, at least at an individual level, except for those who are childless or have not studied it. On a population level however “determinism” seems more apt. But separation from the influence of environment, is usually impossible. Rare experiments of nature cf. MZ twins separated at birth serve to distinguish to a degree. See gene-environment interaction and epigenetics.

Expand full comment
KW NORTON's avatar

Yes, precisely. Well said.

Expand full comment
George Cornell's avatar

The bonobos also like to smear feces and reingest it.

Expand full comment
Fran's avatar

Perhaps trapped in a zoo or some other unnatural environment animals will eat things they normally wouldn't in their natural environment.

Expand full comment
George Cornell's avatar

True enough.

Expand full comment