207 Comments
User's avatar
⭠ Return to thread
Anti-Hip's avatar

Well, please tell me how, after more than a century of dozens of attempts in its name, it is (a) to be properly implemented and (b) to work for all.

I believe only in perpetually-evolving hybrid systems, because only those take into account all known, and emerging known, aspects of human nature. IMO Marxism is a fatal perversion of the original Leftism, in which democracy was undermined in support of an (admittedly brilliant) insights of certain aspects of economic activity, but also along with a huge pile of totalitarian claims and demands, as if they were not only positive, but normative, economics as "settled science". It was a call to create intramural armies, not solve societal problems. In my experience, Marxist pretension on these things is just breathtaking.

Expand full comment
JennyStokes's avatar

Well there is China and Russia but they are a bit less communist than before.

Both seem to be doing ok!

Expand full comment
Anti-Hip's avatar

China is communist only in name (they're completely two-faced about it, copying only the totalitarianism part), and Russia hasn't been communist since 1991.

Expand full comment
Mazirian's avatar

Cuba + Vietnam.

Expand full comment
Anti-Hip's avatar

Cuba: How is this a successful society?

Vietnam: As with China, is this really communist any more?

Expand full comment
Mazirian's avatar

Have you been to Cuba?

Expand full comment
Anti-Hip's avatar

How does communism, specifically, make Cuba a successful society?

Expand full comment